Democrats cry foul over Judge Cannon's handling of Trump documents case
Senate Democrats are venting their fury over Florida Judge Aileen Cannon's decision to cancel the start date of former President Trump’s trial for mishandling classified documents, accusing the Trump appointee of “deliberately slow-walking” the case.
Cannon, who serves on the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Florida, asserted in a five-page order that too many pretrial issues remain unresolved to schedule a later date to hear arguments from federal prosecutors and Trump’s defense.
The judge’s decision cancels Trump’s May 20 trial date, postponing it indefinitely.
The decision sparked outrage among Senate Democrats, who say Cannon has encumbered the trial by unnecessarily raising complex problems of law. They say she has failed to manage her courtroom efficiently, showing a lack of experience on the bench.
Sen. Sheldon Whitehouse (D-R.I.), the chair of the Senate Judiciary panel’s federal courts and oversight subcommittee, said it looks like Cannon is “deliberately slow-walking the case.”
“Judges are responsible for managing their calendars and for seeing to it that issues are addressed timely, so it is hard for me not to reach the conclusion that this [judge] is deliberately slow-walking the case to put it into a position where should [Trump] be elected, he can order that the investigation and prosecution be terminated,” Whitehouse said.
What does it mean for Trump’s charges?
Democrats are close to giving up hope that the 40 felony charges accusing Trump of mishandling classified documents, obstructing justice and making false statements will reach a verdict before Election Day.
And they fear he will immediately kill the case if he defeats President Biden in November and returns to the Oval Office.
“Justice deferred is often justice denied. It is profoundly frustrating that the judge is managing this case in a way that is making it highly unlikely that it will be resolved in a timely fashion,” said Sen. Chris Coons (D-Del.), a member of the Judiciary Committee.
Senate Democrats are pointing to a series of rulings by Cannon, a longtime member of the Federalist Society whom Trump nominated to the federal bench in 2020, that are unusual and favorable to the former president’s defense.
What has Cannon done?
Special counsel Jack Smith, who is handling the case, complained in a 24-page filing last month that Cannon had issued a “fundamentally flawed” order to file preliminary jury instructions contemplating the possibility that Trump was authorized under the Presidential Records Act to turn classified documents into his personal property.
Smith’s legal team warned that the “adoption of a clearly erroneous jury instruction that entails a high probability of failure of prosecution” would create an “extraordinary situation” and “distort the trial.”
Cannon made another highly favorable ruling for Trump in September 2022, ordering the appointment of an independent arbiter to review the more than 11,000 documents the FBI seized at Mar-a-Lago before prosecutors could fully review the materials.
These moves are fueling Democrats’ suspicions that Cannon is pushing a political agenda from the bench.
Sen. Mazie Hirono (D-Hawaii) said Cannon bears responsibility for leaving legal questions unresolved for months, delaying the start of the trial.
“Why are they not resolved? Some of it’s because she hasn’t issued decisions on things that have already been briefed for a while,” said Hirono, a member of the Judiciary Committee.
“I don’t think that she’s being objective. I think she has an ideological agenda. I also think that she’s not very experienced in dealing with trials,” she added. “If there’s a way that she can be reassigned, I certainly would support that.”
The court for the Southern District of Florida does not list a phone number for Cannon’s chambers while it does for other judges. A staff member at the court said Cannon would review any complaints submitted to her in writing via the mail.
Other Democrats on the Senate Judiciary Committee say there’s little chance of removing Cannon from the case unless she voluntarily decides to recuse herself.
Senate Judiciary Committee Chair Dick Durbin (D-Ill.) called the lengthy delay “truly unfortunate.”
“There have been questions from the start as to whether or not she was up to the task of handling a complex case like this in a timely manner and even more serious questions as to whether her politics had anything to do with the rulings,” he said.
Who is Judge Cannon?
Cannon, who is 43, graduated from the University of Michigan Law School in 2007 and worked for a corporate law firm before becoming an assistant federal prosecutor in Florida. She had limited trial experience and just met the American Bar Association’s requirement of 12 years of legal practice when she was nominated.
Durbin said Trump is “entitled to his day in court” and “due process” but emphasized “a timely trial is important for the cause of justice.”
The senior Democrat said it’s unlikely Cannon could be removed from the case.
“I don’t think that’s a possibility. My understanding is there would have to be some effort to change venue, and she would be the first judge to rule on that,” he said.
Whitehouse said the 11th Circuit Court of Appeals could intervene but that it would be “quite unusual.”
Sen. Peter Welch (D-Vt.), a member of the Judiciary Committee, said Cannon’s “at it again, doing everything she can to delay."
He called it “disappointing” but “not surprising.”
Sen. Richard Blumenthal (D-Conn.), a member of the Judiciary Committee and former state attorney general, called the cancellation of the start of Trump’s trial “really regretful.”
“It’s denying justice to America,” he said. “I question whether this judge understands the magnitude or the legal import of this trial.”
Blumenthal said Smith could ask Cannon to recuse herself but expressed doubt he would risk adding to the tension with the judge.
“There is a procedure to seek recusal, but I also understand the reluctance of a litigant asking for recusal because it alienates the judge. It’s a classic dilemma for justice that a particular judicial officer may be conducting a trial that could be better done by somebody else,” he said.
Date: | |
Tag: | Donald Trump |
Filter
-
It Is Inexcusable How Judge Cannon Is Delaying the Trump Documents Case
She is utterly failing to keep the case moving along in a fair but timely manner.The New York Times - Top stories - Donald Trump -
Biden has asserted executive privilege over the audio of his two-day interview with the special counsel investigating his handling of classified documents.
Biden has asserted executive privilege over the audio of his two-day interview with the special counsel investigating his handling of classified documents.The Wall Street Journal - World - Joe Biden -
Ethics Panel Cautions Juan Merchan, Judge in Trump Trial, Over Political Donations
Justice Juan M. Merchan, the judge overseeing Donald J. Trump’s criminal trial in Manhattan, donated modest amounts to Democratic groups in 2020.The New York Times - Top stories - Donald Trump -
Supreme Court Justice Alito urged to step off Trump election case over U.S. flag controversy
Supreme Court Justice Samuel Alito and the other justices are considering if Donald Trump is immune from prosecution for 2020 election crimes.CNBC - Business - Donald Trump -
Calls for Justice Samuel Alito to recuse himself from Trump cases over inverted flag
Supreme Court Justice Samuel Alito is facing calls to recuse himself from cases before the high court involving former President Donald Trump after reports emerged of an inverted flag flown outside his home in January 2021. The inverted flag was ...CBS News - Top stories - Donald Trump -
Google wants judge, not jury, to decide upcoming antitrust case in Virginia
Google is asking that a federal judge, rather than a jury, decide whether it violated U.S. antitrust laws by building a monopoly on the technology that powers online advertisingABC News - Tech - Google -
Judge to Rule Next Week on Whether to Dismiss Alec Baldwin Case
During a heated hearing, Mr. Baldwin’s lawyers claimed prosecutors had improperly presented evidence to the grand jury considering the fatal shooting on the set of “Rust.”The New York Times - Top stories -
Democrats pan Trump's play for Minnesota as a 'head fake'
A Republican presidential candidate hasn't won Minnesota in 50 years, yet signs point to part of the "blue wall" being an emerging battleground.NBC News - Politics - Donald Trump -
Texas Democrat accuses Abbott of 'alliance with white nationalists' over pardon
Democratic Rep. Joaquin Castro (Texas) on Thursday accused Texas Gov. Greg Abbott (R) of having an "alliance with white nationalists" after he pardoned an Army sergeant who was previously convicted for shooting and killing a Black Lives Matter ...The Hill - Politics -
McConnell, Collins on collision course with Democrats over spending parity
Senate Republicans are on a collision course with Democrats who are insisting that nondefense spending programs receive equal treatment with defense programs. Senate Republican Leader Mitch McConnell (Ky.) says he won’t accept Democrats’ demand to ...The Hill - Politics
More from The Hill
-
Sullivan presses Netanyahu for a more focused military campaign in Gaza
White House national security adviser Jake Sullivan reiterated Biden administration pressure on Israel to limit its military operation in Gaza during a visit to the country on Sunday. Sullivan is on a combined trip to Israel and Saudi Arabia as ...The Hill - Politics - Israel -
Vance doubles down on praise for Viktor Orban's crackdown on universities in Hungary
Sen. JD Vance (R-Ohio) stood by previous comments praising Hungarian President Viktor Orban for a regulatory crackdown on the country’s universities on Sunday, saying the U.S. should embrace a similar mindset. Orban, as part of anti-democratic ...The Hill - Politics -
Biden on Trump’s next Supreme Court pick: ‘Do you think he’ll put anybody who has a brain?’
President Biden asked the audience at an NAACP Detroit chapter dinner to consider whether they think former President Trump, if elected for a second term in the White House, would fill hypothetical vacancies at the Supreme Court with “anybody who ...The Hill - Politics - Joe Biden -
US to pull troops out of Niger by mid-September: Pentagon
The U.S. military will pull all of its assets out of Niger by mid-September, the Pentagon announced Sunday, after days of talks with the country’s military junta finalized a timeline. A group of military leaders executed a coup in Niger last year, ...The Hill - Politics -
Elon Musk debuts Starlink satellite internet service in Indonesia
Elon Musk traveled to Bali this weekend to officially launch Starlink, the SpaceX satellite internet service, in Indonesia this Sunday. At a launch event with ministers in a health clinic in Indonesia, Musk stressed the significance of providing ...The Hill - Politics - Elon Musk