Democratic panic: Who should replace Joe Biden after Thursday’s disastrous debate?
![Democratic panic: Who should replace Joe Biden after Thursday’s disastrous debate?](https://thehill.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2024/06/bidenjoe_062724upi01_w.jpg?w=900)
The good news about last night's presidential debate is that there was a clear winner: the format.
The format was awesome. No audience. No interrupting. The traditional debate format, at least in modern times, puts a premium on being obnoxious at the cost of actual substance. As far as the structure of CNN’s debate went, it was one of the best I’ve seen.
As far as everything else went, not so much.
Each candidate had a job to do. Donald Trump had to come across as relatively normal and avoid appearing dangerous or unhinged. President Biden had to demonstrate that he has plenty of gas in the tank and is perfectly capable of being president for the next four years, despite his age. Trump more or less succeeded (although, in the process, he told multiple outrageous falsehoods and often refused to answer questions).
Biden did not. Though he got a little better as the night progressed, Joe Biden’s delivery was often halting and confused. At one point, he ended a long rambling answer by saying, “We finally beat Medicare.”
He also missed multiple opportunities, both to fact-check Trump and for devastating comebacks. When Trump was going on about migrants killing 12-year-old girls, for example, I was on the edge of my seat, expecting Biden to say something like, “Those deaths are on your conscience. You, sir, are responsible. I had a bipartisan border security bill in place and you killed it because you’d rather campaign on the issue than let us fix the problem.” This should have been a lay-up for the president, as it’s just a variation of what he said at his State of the Union address this year.
Instead, Biden started talking about veterans. At times, his answer strayed into Miss South Carolina territory. It got so bad that halfway through the debate, the Biden campaign began tweeting that he had a cold and was under the weather.
From a purely policy perspective, Biden won, in that his answers were both more substantive and more truthful. But as a matter of optics, Biden lost, probably catastrophically. This debate was going to answer the question about Biden’s fitness to be president, the biggest single concern among independent voters. Perhaps he did have a cold and was just having a bad day, but over 60 percent of voters watched this debate and none of them had their concerns put to rest.
The panic among Democratic movers and shakers began well before the first commercial break. Can Biden be replaced? Who should replace him?
As the convention isn’t for two months, replacing Biden would be easy — provided, of course, he decides to step aside. (The rules governing the convention are such that Biden can’t be denied the nomination without his consent.) Putting aside the issue of whether this is likely to happen, his obvious successor would be his vice president, Kamala Harris.
But having Harris at the top of the ticket doesn’t improve the ticket much, if at all.
For one thing, Harris may even be less popular than Biden. For another, one of the few clear outcomes of tonight’s debate is that she’s already at the top of the ticket, in a way. Trump will now most likely start running against “President Harris” and claiming that, should he win, “Grandpa Joe” will be quickly shouldered aside to make way for his “ultra progressive” successor.
If Democrats really believe that Donald Trump is an existential threat to American democracy, then both Biden and Harris should step aside. In that case, the ideal in-case-of-emergency-break-glass ticket would be Gretchen Whitmer, the popular governor of Michigan, and Josh Shapiro, the governor of Pennsylvania.
Whitmer has a national reputation and Biden is currently behind in both Michigan and Pennsylvania. Roy Cooper, outgoing governor of North Carolina, would also make an interesting VP choice, especially if Biden stepped aside and Harris became the nominee. Of course, there are problems with nominating Whitmer, including the risk of alienating African American voters. But there’s a good case that a Whitmer/Shapiro ticket would outperform Biden/Harris.
After tonight’s performance, a Biden campaign is going to be strictly a referendum on Donald Trump rather than a vote of confidence in four more years of Joe Biden. But people who are voting against Donald Trump — which amounts to about half the country — are going to vote for the Democratic candidate regardless. Whitmer, or someone like her, can make inroads with undecideds and “double haters” in a way that Biden now cannot. In an election that may well come down to a few thousand votes in a handful of swing states, that may make all the difference.
All this is extremely messy and unlikely to happen. Biden will probably remain the nominee. A week is a long time in politics and the Democratic convention is seven weeks away. Nor can you go by outside appearances. It is the nature of these things that Biden’s support in the party will appear rock solid...until it isn’t.
Chris Truax is a Republican and an appellate attorney.
Date: | |
Tag: | Joe Biden |
Filter
-
The Hill - Politics
House Democrat: 'Biden is going to lose to Trump' after debate
Rep. Marie Gluesenkamp Perez (D-Wash.) predicted in a new interview that former President Biden will lose November's election to former President Trump, adding to a growing group of Democrats questioning Biden's chances after his dismal showing in ...Joe Biden -
The Hill - Politics
Don’t let Thursday's debate become the Democrats' Capitol riot
We all remember the Jan. 6 Capitol riot. It was obvious that what happened that day was wrong, and it was equally obvious what it implied about Donald Trump. Then-Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell (R-Ky.) said that Trump’s behavior was “a ... -
The Hill - Politics
Biden seeks to reassure amid growing Democratic panic
President Biden is trying to reassure top Democrats that he’s up for the challenge of beating former President Trump in November and serving for another four years, amid increasing pressure for him to drop out of the race after his dismal debate ...Joe Biden -
BBC News - Top stories
'Something needs to happen' - Democratic voters on replacing Biden
We asked Democratic voters if they thought Joe Biden should be replaced and by whom.Joe Biden -
Financial Times - Business
Biden set for talks with senior Democrats as crisis deepens
Discussions come as polls show sharp drop in support for US presidentJoe Biden -
NBC News - Top stories
Hurricane Beryl nears Jamaica and Democrats await polling after Biden debate: Morning Rundown
Why the Biden administration is considering working with the Taliban.Joe Biden -
The Hill - Politics
On Biden’s debate, Democrats have no one to blame but themselves
Democrats' attempts to protect President Biden from scrutiny has resulted in a lack of viable replacements, leaving them stuck with a senile candidate and no bench for the 2028 election.Joe Biden -
NBC News - Top stories
Democratic Party rules show a clear path to replace Biden if he were to step aside
As Biden's campaign tries to calm nervous Democrats, the DNC is circulating talking points that misleadingly suggest there is no means of replacing the president at the top of the party's ticket.Joe Biden -
NBC News - Politics
Democrats fret while awaiting signs of how Biden will weather debate debacle
Democratic leaders are nervously waiting to see if a fresh round of polling shows that Joe Biden’s support has collapsed and he’s become a drag on congressional races before taking a unified stance on whether he should drop out of the race, ...Joe Biden -
Politico - Politics
Biden calls senior Hill Democrats as post-debate concerns grow louder
Joe Biden
More from The Hill
-
The Hill - Politics
Katie Porter: White House has 'clearly fumbled' response to debate
Rep. Katie Porter (D-Calif.) on Wednesday said the White House "clearly fumbled" its response to the fallout from President Biden's shaky debate performance, as a growing number of Democrats express concerns with their nominee's ability to carry ... -
The Hill - Politics
Biden praises Civil War soldiers, Medal of Honor recipients for 'heroic deeds'
President Biden on Wednesday posthumously awarded the Medal of Honor to two Civil War-era soldiers who he lauded for defending America and the values it was founded upon. Biden, speaking from the White House, praised Pvt. Philip G. Shadrach and ...Joe Biden -
The Hill - Politics
Biden-Trump race is tight amid debate fallout: Poll
President Biden and former President Trump are in a tight race amid fallout from last week’s presidential debate, according to a new poll from The Economist/YouGov. The poll, conducted between June 30 and July 2, found that Trump garnered 42 ...Joe Biden -
The Hill - Politics
Evening Report — Can Biden stop the bleeding?
A second House Dem is urging Biden to step aside {beacon} Evening Report Wednesday, July 3 © AP Photo/Evan Vucci Biden tries to rally the troops as Dem panic consumes Washington President Biden began widespread outreach to Democrats on ...Joe Biden -
The Hill - Politics
'Lost' creator calls on Dems to stop giving party money until Biden steps down
Damon Lindelof, a co-creator of “Lost” and a notable Democratic Party supporter, called on fellow donors to withhold their money until President Biden ends his reelection bid, citing his struggles in the CNN debate against former President Trump ...Joe Biden