DC’s baseless lawsuit against energy producers must be dismissed
The District of Columbia has joined a growing trend of progressive states, cities and municipalities across the country litigating the alleged impacts of global carbon emissions in state courts.
Bottom line: The lawsuits seek to extract payment from America’s energy producers purportedly to offset often amorphous climate adaptation programs — but in many cases more likely just to offset debts from poorly managed budgets.
On Thursday, March 20, and after years of procedural wrangling, the District of Columbia Superior Court heard arguments from energy producers regarding why it should dismiss the District’s meritless lawsuit — which names Exxon Mobil, BP, Shell Oil and Chevron among its defendants.
The plaintiffs in the lawsuit, led by San Francisco-based law firm Sher Edling, allege that the energy industry has caused global warming, resulting in rising sea levels, flooding and “longer-lasting and more severe storms.”
The suit also alleges that infrastructure damage either has or may result at some future point. Further, it says the defendants defrauded consumers by promoting their environmentally sensitive innovations and by not sharing information about climate change.
In other words, the plaintiffs argue that but for the defendants’ lawful marketing efforts, consumers would not have bought or consumed fossil fuels.
Around the country, energy companies are litigating approximately thirty such suits. This “flood the zone” litigation strategy is not about advancing claims moored in traditional or accepted standards for liability. It is about leverage.
The cases are designed to pressure the defendants to settle with terms requiring fundamental changes to industry practices — such as bans on drilling or requirements to subsidize less reliable wind and solar power — as well as damages awards the plaintiffs will use for anything from Green New Deal-type spending to backfilling steep municipal budget deficits.
The companies must successfully defend all of these baseless lawsuits; losing even a handful would be catastrophic to the energy sector. But that appears to be the top goal of Sher Edling and those who fund them.
While the law firm has yet to win any of the more than 25 such lawfare cases on a contingency basis, it can afford to keep going. That’s because its efforts are being underwritten to the tune of millions of dollars a year from climate activist organizations.
A Republican staff report from the Senate Committee on Commerce, Science and Transportation and the House Committee on Oversight and Accountability revealed that, in 2022, sources such as the Resources Legacy Fund, New Venture Fund and the Tides Foundation supported the firm’s efforts.
The novel litigation theories being advanced in these cases are riddled with legal problems. Chief among the flaws in the District of Columbia’s lawsuit, along with the over two dozen identical lawsuits, is the plaintiffs’ attempt to get state or D.C. courts to set national climate policy by way of judicial decree rather than careful legislation deliberation.
Courts are neither permitted nor suited to accomplish the careful balancing and policymaking involved. Thankfully, under the Constitution’s Supremacy Clause and the Clean Air Act, that authority is reserved for Congress. Thus, city, state and local law is preempted by federal law — it is void and unenforceable.
Time and time again, when state or federal courts have confronted the preemption issues, they have found these cases barred. Just last month, New Jersey Superior Court Judge Douglas Hurd dismissed a nearly identical case with prejudice, stating that “plaintiffs’ claims are preempted because federal common law governs this dispute.”
He added that “Fundamental principles of federalism in the United States Constitution are clear that state law cannot operate in areas of “uniquely federal interests,” and “such a uniquely federal area is interstate air pollution.”
The Sher Edling-managed case for San Francisco and Oakland was likewise dismissed in 2018 by U.S. District Judge William Alsup, a Clinton appointee. The Second U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals dismissed New York City’s climate change lawsuit in 2021 because “judicial caution and foreign policy concerns” suggest such claims should not proceed absent clear congressional direction.
The Second Circuit held that “To permit this suit to proceed under state law would further risk upsetting the careful balance that has been struck between the prevention of global warming, a project that necessarily requires national standards and global participation, on the one hand, and energy production, economic growth, foreign policy, and national security, on the other.”
Baltimore City Circuit Court Judge Videtta Brown dismissed that city’s case in July, noting that Congress never intended adjudication of climate suits in individual state courts..
By similarly finding preemption in the District of Columbia case and granting the recently heard motion to dismiss, the District of Columbia Superior Court can preserve the will of Congress expressed, and its sphere of authority exerted, in its Clean Air Act.
Suing energy companies has become a cottage industry for activists hoping to cripple America’s energy industry and trial lawyers chasing a get-rich-quick scheme. These are ridiculous attempts to assign a small number of energy producers sole responsibility for a complex worldwide concern and the alleged climate change damages associated with it.
But what ultimately matters most is that the law is not on their side. The D.C. Superior Court has a chance to once again make that clear.
Donald J. Kochan is a professor of law and executive director of the Law & Economics Center at George Mason University’s Antonin Scalia Law School.
-
Racketeering claims against Sean Combs dismissed in producer's sexual assault lawsuit
A federal judge in New York has dismissed racketeering allegations against Sean Combs in a $30 million sexual assault and harassment lawsuit brought by a producer who worked on his most recent album.NBC News - 4h -
Phillips produces 'the most stunning of catches' to dismiss Gill
Glenn Phillips produces yet another "incredible" piece of fielding, this time dismissing Shubman Gill for 31 runs with a leaping catch at cover to leave India on 105-1 in the Champions Trophy final ...BBC News - Mar. 9 -
Nicolas Cage dismissed in ex-girlfriend's lawsuit, but assault claims against their son remain
Nicolas Cage's ex-girlfriend Christina Fulton dismisses her negligence claims against the actor in her ongoing assault lawsuit against their son Weston.Los Angeles Times - Mar. 11 -
DC drops Proud Boys lawsuit
The Washington, D.C., attorney general’s office has dropped its lawsuit against the Proud Boys and Oath Keepers over the Jan. 6, 2021, attack on the U.S. Capitol. In a court filing, the attorney ...The Hill - Mar. 17 -
Fox News removed from former producer's sexual assault lawsuit against ex-anchor Ed Henry
Jennifer Eckhart, who worked as an associate producer on Fox News Media's Fox Business Network, is suing Henry for sexual assault. Fox News was named in the suit, as Eckhart claimed the network ...Los Angeles Times - Mar. 13 -
Judge dismisses copyright suit against Mariah Carey’s All I Want for Christmas Is You
Country singer Vince Vance had alleged Carey copied his band’s 1988 Christmas tune of the same name. A federal judge has dismissed a copyright lawsuit against Mariah Carey and her smash holiday ...The Guardian - 5d -
Interior, Energy must rehire fired workers, judge says
Click for more from The Hill. {beacon} Energy & Environment Energy & Environment The Big Story Interior, Energy must rehire fired workers, judge says The Trump administration must reinstate ...The Hill - Mar. 13 -
Coosa Christian, AHSAA to meet in court over motion to dismiss lawsuit over violations
Coosa Christian, AHSAA have a court date over motion to dismiss lawsuit that stems from violations that removed Coosa from football playoffsYahoo Sports - Mar. 17 -
MLB players' union, Bad Bunny agency agree to dismiss lawsuit over discipline
Bad Bunny’s sports representation firm and the Major League Baseball Players Association have filed an agreement to dismiss the union’s lawsuit over penalties imposed for making improper inducementsABC News - Mar. 6 -
Battery charge against fighter Diaz dismissed
A misdemeanor battery charge against combat sports star Nate Diaz, which stem from an altercation with a nightclub bouncer in Las Vegas last year, has been dismissed.ESPN - 5d -
Los Angeles prosecutors say no charges against movie producer David Guillod
The Los Angeles County district attorney says his office will not file sexual assault charges against movie producer David GuillodABC News - 3d -
Fusion energy: Unlocking the power of the stars
Scientists are conducting experiments to generate clean energy through fusion, the same sub-atomic reaction that powers our Sun, with the aim of constructing plants that produce more energy than ...CBS News - Mar. 16 -
‘Drake lost a rap battle’: Universal files motion to dismiss rapper’s ‘misguided’ lawsuit
Drake’s attorneys accuse Universal of being ‘a greedy company’ that is ‘finally being held responsible for profiting from dangerous misinformation’.. Universal Music Group have moved to dismiss ...The Guardian - Mar. 18 -
Family of student Riley Strain files wrongful death lawsuit against fraternity
The family of student Riley Strain has filed a lawsuit against his fraternity, accusing Delta Chi of instilling a code that taught brothers “to abandon one another.”NBC News - 1d -
Paramount says Trump's CBS '60 Minutes' lawsuit seeks to 'punish' network
Paramount on Thursday asked a federal judge in Texas to dismiss the $20-billion lawsuit. The media company separately has agreed to have a mediator look at the case.Los Angeles Times - Mar. 6 -
Greenpeace ordered to pay $660 million over pipeline protests
Energy Transfer claimed in a lawsuit that Greenpeace was responsible for defamation, disruption and property damage for protests against the Dakota Access Pipeline.CBS News - 5d -
Universal Music Group moves to dismiss Drake's lawsuit over Kendrick Lamar diss track
Universal Music Group is asking a judge to throw out Drake's defamation lawsuit over Kendrick Lamar's hit song "Not Like Us." The label's court filing uses strong language to defend Lamar's lyrics, ...CBS News - Mar. 18 -
Half of UK oil and gas demand can be produced at home, says industry body
North Sea could produce an extra 2bn to 3bn barrels with ‘right’ levers, forecasts Offshore Energies UKFinancial Times - 1d -
Supreme Court turns away bid to block state climate change lawsuits
A group of Republican-led states sought to block lawsuits brought by a group of Democratic-led states that seek to hold energy companies accountable for climate change.CBS News - Mar. 10 -
Bellingham ‘must be more disciplined to save energy’, says Thomas Tuchel
England head coach wants midfielder to have more impact Tuchel unsure why wingers didn’t ‘dare to take the risk’ Thomas Tuchel believes Jude Bellingham tried to do too much at Euro 2024 and must ...The Guardian - 3d -
Djokovic 'does not agree' with parts of union's lawsuit
Novak Djokovic says he does not agree with parts of the lawsuit brought against tennis' governing bodies by the players' union he co-founded.Yahoo Sports - 5d -
Supreme Court Rejects an Effort to Block States From Suing Oil Giants
The justices declined to hear unusual arguments from Republican-led states that sought to end lawsuits against energy companies over their role in global warming.The New York Times - Mar. 10 -
Netanyahu says he will seek to dismiss head of Israel’s internal security service
Prime minister's move against Shin Bet’s Ronen Bar will prompt further accusations of authoritarianism. Benjamin Netanyahu has announced he will seek to dismiss the director of Shin Bet, Israel’s ...The Guardian - Mar. 16 -
Alcaraz says 'doesn't support' Djokovic-backed lawsuit
Wimbledon champion Carlos Alcaraz pushed back on a lawsuit against the ATP Tour filed by the Novak Djokovic-led tennis players union on Wednesday, saying he does not support the move.The PTPA ...Yahoo Sports - 6d -
Woman drops lawsuit accusing boxing champion Mike Tyson of 1991 rape
A woman who accused Mike Tyson of raping her in a limousine in 1991 is dropping her lawsuit against the former heavyweight boxing championABC News - Mar. 11 -
Nearly two-thirds of players in lawsuit 'show CTE symptoms'
Almost two-thirds of the claimants in a concussion lawsuit against rugby league authorities showed symptoms of chronic traumatic encephalopathy, according to documents seen by the BBC.BBC News - 1d -
Trump targets lawyers who he says file 'frivolous' lawsuits against his administration
A new memo from Trump authorizes the attorney general and the homeland security secretary to sanction law firms that file lawsuits they deem “frivolous."NBC News - 1d -
Drake's record label files motion to dismiss his lawsuit over Kendrick Lamar's 'Not Like Us'
In a court filing Monday, Universal Music Group stated that Drake “lost a rap battle that he provoked and in which he willingly participated.”NBC News - Mar. 17 -
Energy Secretary Chris Wright says Trump push to produce more oil is driving down prices
The Trump administration has promised to increase leases on federal lands and waters and expedite the permitting process.CNBC - 5d -
Google agrees to pay $28m in racial bias lawsuit
The tech giant confirmed it had "reached a resolution" but rejected the allegations made against it.BBC News - 6d -
EPA to steer environmental enforcement officers away from energy companies
The Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) indicated this week that it will steer its environmental enforcement officers away from energy companies. The EPA can pursue civil or criminal cases ...The Hill - Mar. 13 -
Blue State Lawsuits Against Oil Companies Can Move Forward
Blue states are suing Exxon Mobil and other oil companies. The U.S. Supreme Court rejected a bid by red states to block the suits.Inc. - Mar. 10 -
SCOTUS rejects Republican-led effort to halt climate lawsuits in Dem-led states
The Supreme Court has rejected a lawsuit from Republican attorneys general in 19 states aimed at blocking climate change suits against the oil and gas industry from Democratic-led statesABC News - Mar. 10 -
CBS' '60 Minutes' is unflinching in its White House coverage in the shadow of Trump's $20B lawsuit
As CBS' parent company considers settlement of President Donald Trump's lawsuit against “60 Minutes,” America’s storied newsmagazine is pulling no punches in its coverage of the new administrationABC News - 6d -
Carlos Alcaraz doesn't support the lawsuit from the tennis players' group Novak Djokovic founded
Four-time Grand Slam champion Carlos Alcaraz was unaware that there would be a class-action lawsuit filed in U.S. federal court against some of the groups that run tennis and made clear Wednesday ...Yahoo Sports - 6d -
Carlos Alcaraz doesn't support the lawsuit from the tennis players' group Novak Djokovic founded
Four-time Grand Slam champion Carlos Alcaraz says he was unaware there would be a class-action lawsuit filed in U.S. federal court against some of the groups that run tennis and made clear that he ...ABC News - 6d -
XRP surges after Ripple CEO Brad Garlinghouse says SEC is dropping its lawsuit against the company
Ripple CEO Brad Garlinghouse said Wednesday that the SEC is no longer pursuing its appeal in the case against the payments company.CNBC - 6d -
Greenpeace Is Ordered to Pay Energy Transfer, a Pipeline Company, $660 Million
The environmental group had said the lawsuit, over its role in a protest movement, could mean an end to its operations in the United States.The New York Times - 6d -
NFL star Odell Beckham Jr denies allegations in Sean ‘Diddy’ Combs lawsuit
Woman claims player was involved in assault Beckham says he was not in California at time NFL star Odell Beckham Jr has denied any wrongdoing after saying he was named in a lawsuit that alleges ...The Guardian - Mar. 11
More from The Hill
-
Trump signs order targeting mail-in ballots, proof of citizenship in federal elections
President Trump on Tuesday signed an executive order that would dramatically overhaul how federal elections are run, a move that follows years of exaggerated claims from Trump about mail ballots ...The Hill - 40m -
GOP rallies behind debt limit hike in Trump tax bill, speedy timeline
Top Republican lawmakers emerged from a meeting at the Treasury Department on Tuesday saying the House and Senate are moving closer together on key aspects of how to unlock President Trump’s ...The Hill - 44m -
Moulton rips Hegseth for chat that 'cheapens' work of military, intelligence
Rep. Seth Moulton (D-Mass.) hammered Secretary of Defense Pete Hegseth for using a Signal group chat to communicate about strikes on the Houthi rebel group in Yemen. “This put American lives at ...The Hill - 53m -
How the Signal 'group chat' furor has affected the 5 biggest players
The furor over a headline-making group chat consumed Washington for a second day on Tuesday. President Trump spoke to reporters from the White House about the matter, and it was also the focus of a ...The Hill - 57m -
Senate confirms Michael Kratsios to lead White House science, tech office
The Senate confirmed Michael Kratsios to head the White House’s Office of Science and Technology Policy (OSTP) with bipartisan support. Kratsios, who was Trump’s chief technology officer during ...The Hill - 1h
More in Politics
-
Trump signs order targeting mail-in ballots, proof of citizenship in federal elections
President Trump on Tuesday signed an executive order that would dramatically overhaul how federal elections are run, a move that follows years of exaggerated claims from Trump about mail ballots ...The Hill - 40m -
GOP rallies behind debt limit hike in Trump tax bill, speedy timeline
Top Republican lawmakers emerged from a meeting at the Treasury Department on Tuesday saying the House and Senate are moving closer together on key aspects of how to unlock President Trump’s ...The Hill - 44m -
Moulton rips Hegseth for chat that 'cheapens' work of military, intelligence
Rep. Seth Moulton (D-Mass.) hammered Secretary of Defense Pete Hegseth for using a Signal group chat to communicate about strikes on the Houthi rebel group in Yemen. “This put American lives at ...The Hill - 53m -
How the Signal 'group chat' furor has affected the 5 biggest players
The furor over a headline-making group chat consumed Washington for a second day on Tuesday. President Trump spoke to reporters from the White House about the matter, and it was also the focus of a ...The Hill - 57m -
Senate confirms Michael Kratsios to lead White House science, tech office
The Senate confirmed Michael Kratsios to head the White House’s Office of Science and Technology Policy (OSTP) with bipartisan support. Kratsios, who was Trump’s chief technology officer during ...The Hill - 1h