Cut climate emissions by ticketing the worst offenders, like speeding drivers
Starting this year, companies importing fuel into the European Union will be asked to provide comprehensive data on the quantity of methane emitted during the fuel’s production. In two years’ time, any failure to meet the bloc’s criteria will trigger a “system of penalties” that could (and is likely to) include “penalty payments or fines” for importers.
This legislation, which my colleagues at Kayrros helped make possible due to our expertise in methane monitoring, will benefit the climate and should be viewed by companies as an opportunity not just to reduce their carbon footprints, but to gain a greater understanding of their operations. That in turn will help them identify inefficiencies and areas for improvement, and ultimately extend their license to operate and outcompete dirtier suppliers.
Elsewhere, however, the climate has fallen down the political agenda.
The United States is now considering abolishing methane emission rules put in place by the previous administration, which had sought to align U.S. methane regulations with European standards to facilitate trade in liquified natural gas. If those regulations are scrapped or watered down, European importers may struggle to meet the EU’s stringent reporting and emissions standards. This conundrum is made all the more difficult by President Trump’s recent statement that if the EU doesn’t want to face crippling tariffs on trade, “the one thing they can do quickly is buy our oil and gas.”
Methane, it’s worth reminding ourselves, frequently leaks during fossil fuel production and delivery and is particularly damaging to the environment. Over 20 years, it heats the atmosphere 84 times more powerfully than carbon dioxide. On current trends, it is projected to account for half of global warming in the next two decades. If the EU, keen to avoid a trade war, rolls over on methane regulations, we’ll need to change tack to bring down methane quickly.
The best way to do this is to narrow the scope of the regulations and target so-called “super-emitters” — intermittent sources of methane and other greenhouse gases that release disproportionately large amounts of emissions compared to typical sources.
These emissions are so large that, thanks to recent scientific advances, they can easily be seen from space. Exact definitions vary, but most agree that super-emitters refer to emission events of several tons of methane per hour, and include sources like oil and gas facilities, landfills and large agricultural operations. In the oil and gas industry, large amounts of methane emissions are often the result of leaks, equipment failures or inefficient and outdated operational practices.
This makes super-emitters, as opposed to more diffuse and smaller leaks, also remarkably easy and cost-effective to fix. And because they account for a large share of overall emissions and are so hugely concentrated, the cost-benefit of tackling them is a no-brainer — the payoff in terms of overall climate benefits and avoided greenhouse gases is phenomenal.
Indeed, holding methane super-emitters to account, as opposed to scrutinizing the entire lifecycle emissions of fossil fuels, would be a much more straightforward and effective policy — and a much less burdensome one for both industry and government — than the more arcane rules that the United States is set to tear up, and that the EU aims to implement.
While the EU has set lofty and commendable climate targets, its current approach to methane regulations is overly complicated. Under the current plans, it is the EU that bears the responsibility of identifying, locating and penalizing companies responsible for imported methane emissions. That is inefficient and laborious, perhaps to the point of elusiveness.
Instead, businesses themselves should be required to make sure they do not cause any super-emitter event. If they fail to do this, then they should be subject to fines, just as individual drivers who break the speed limit are legally bound to pay a financial penalty. If for one reason or another a driver disagrees with the charge that they’ve broken the speed limit, then they’re within their rights to contest the fine and provide evidence that no wrongdoing has occurred. Likewise, businesses fined for super-emitters should have the right to argue that they didn’t break any rules and present their reasons for thinking that.
This behooves those companies eligible for the EU’s methane laws to monitor their emissions closely on an ongoing basis, for fear of falling foul of the rules and being slapped with a hefty fine. The data they need to do that can be effectively, cheaply and unobtrusively gathered using Earth Observation technology, which combines satellite imagery with artificial intelligence, machine learning and geoanalytics, to provide a comprehensive view of what’s happening on the ground across a business’s operations — and then, ideally, interpreted by environmental intelligence professionals, who can recommend sustainable and effective changes informed by that business’s baseline emissions.
The European Space Agency showed last year that the elimination only of super-emitters detected from space — something eminently practicable and cost-efficient — would be equivalent in emissions terms to the annual carbon sequestered by 11 billion tree seedlings grown for 10 years. Put differently, it would be like removing 160 million cars from the road or the equivalent of France's total carbon footprint. That’s the opportunity that lies in wait.
If the EU is going to relax its rules around methane to preserve good relations with the U.S., then another effective strategy is needed to tackle harmful methane emissions. The simplest and the best is to take an approach that has worked brilliantly to improve road safety around the world: slap the negligent emitters with a fine.
Antoine Rostand is president and co-founder of global climate technology company Kayrros.
Topics
-
NASCAR drivers divided on new rule that could guarantee Helio Castroneves a spot in the Daytona 500
A controversial new NASCAR rule designed for “world-class drivers” could give Helio Castroneves an automatic berth into the Daytona 500ABC News - 1d -
NASCAR's new 'world-class driver' rule makes Daytona 500 qualifying more complicated than ever
The Daytona 500 has NASCAR’s most unique — and complicated — qualifying formatABC News - 1d -
Fast break AI: How Databricks helped the Pacers slash ML costs 12,000X% while speeding up insights
The jaw-dropping decrease is a credit not only to Databricks, but PS&E's ability to reduce ML compute to near-infinitesimal amounts.VentureBeat - 1d -
Biogen beats estimates on cost cuts and new drugs like Leqembi, but profit outlook falls short
Biogen expects Leqembi and new rare disease and depression treatments to help offset revenue lost from multiple sclerosis products.CNBC - 4h -
Flight detours around Ukraine war mean 1% rise in aviation emissions
Yahoo News - 4h -
Report: Climate change one of five major risks to German security
Yahoo News - 5h -
Inflation picks up speed after Trump promised to ‘rapidly’ bring down prices
Consumer price index rose by 3% in January as president has yet to fulfill pledge of tackling high cost of living. New inflation rate at odds with Trump’s promise to lower prices Inflation ...The Guardian - 6h -
Philippines storm survivors join climate protest outside Shell HQ in London
Greenpeace protest draws attention to worsening typhoons and demands accountability from major polluters. For two days and two nights, Ronalyn Carbonel and her four children clung to the roof of ...The Guardian - 7h -
Climate change is threatening cacao crops, researchers say
Rising temperatures and shifting rainfall patterns in West Africa, which supplies around 70% of the world's cacao, are disrupting the crop, affecting both the quantity and quality of beans — and ...CBS News - 9h -
Russia's War Is Driving Up Emissions by Forcing Planes to Reroute
Yahoo News - 10h -
The great climate disconnect
New attempts to prolong the fossil fuel era have come at precisely the wrong timeFinancial Times - 15h -
SEC backs away from climate disclosure rule
Click for more from The Hill. {beacon} Energy & Environment Energy & Environment The Big Story SEC backs away from climate disclosure rule The Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) announced ...The Hill - 20h -
SEC announces it will not defend climate disclosure rule
The Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) announced Tuesday that it will not defend a year-old rule requiring publicly held companies to disclose climate-related risks and in some cases the ...The Hill - 1d -
As Trump hits delete, the race is on to save LGBTQ and climate data
The race is on to try to stop vital information from being rewritten or scrubbed from U.S. government websites, with researchers warning that the loss of key data could create risks for the ...NBC News - 1d -
Corruption survey gives many nations worst scores in over a decade
Many countries had their worst showing in more than a decade in the annual Corruption Perceptions Index that serves as a barometer of public sector corruption worldwide.NBC News - 1d -
BYD shares hit record high after EV maker rolls out driver assistance tech with DeepSeek's AI help
Advanced smart driving will become a standard safety feature similar to seatbelts and air bags, BYD's founder and chairman Wang Chuanfu said.CNBC - 1d -
McDonald's revenue disappoints, as U.S. sales see worst drop since pandemic
Shares of McDonald's have risen just 2% over the past year.CNBC - 1d -
McDonald's revenue disappoints, as U.S. sales see worst drop since pandemic
McDonald’s on Monday reported disappointing quarterly revenue, dragged down by weaker-than-expected sales at its U.S. restaurants following an E. coli outbreak just weeks into the quarter.NBC News - 2d -
Super Bowl is over! Let's get you up to speed on the NBA season
In case you missed it, we now join the 2024-25 NBA season, already in progress. Here's everything you need to know.Yahoo Sports - 2d -
Is full coverage car insurance necessary? Pros and cons drivers should know
Dropping comprehensive and collision coverage can cut costs — but is it an option for you? And should you do it?CBS News - 2d -
The Best and Worst Super Bowl Commercials, Ranked
Here is our critic’s survey of this year’s Super Bowl commercials, from best to worst.The New York Times - 2d -
Fed Rate Cuts Are Looking Less and Less Likely for 2025
The January jobs report and inflation concerns have pushed back bets for lower borrowing costs.Inc. - 2d -
Upcoming California Super Bowls Confront Climate Risks
New Orleans’ Super Bowl has wrapped—the Philadelphia Eagles denied the Chiefs their third straight NFL title in a 40-22 win—and the NFL’s big game moves back out west, with the league’s next two ...Yahoo Sports - 2d -
The best and worst Super Bowl commercials of 2025
Super Bowl 59's ad lineup had some winners and plenty of losers among its crop of new commercials. Read what the experts say.CBS News - 2d -
Greens: Climate change ignored in German election TV debate
Yahoo News - 2d -
'Support' needed for NI drivers to switch to EV
Support is needed to encourage Northern Ireland drivers to switch to electric vehicles, an EV driver said.BBC News - 2d -
'Losing the Super Bowl is the worst feeling in the world' - Mahomes
Kansas City Chiefs quarterback Patrick Mahomes says losing the Super Bowl is "the worst feeling in the world" after his side 40-22 to the Philadelphia Eagles in New Orleans.BBC News - 2d -
Driver cut free after crash with highways vehicle
Firefighters say the highways vehicle was stationary within a closed work zone when it was hit.BBC News - 3d -
U.S.A.I.D. Workers Brace for the Worst
A judge halted parts of the Trump administration’s plan to shut down the agency. A verdict might not come for weeks or even longer as thousands are left in limbo.The New York Times - 3d -
Dreams ‘crushed’ as Ticketmaster cancels fans’ Oasis ’25 tickets
Those affected were accused of being bots and asked to fill out a form for the tour’s promoters to review. Oasis fans have said their “dreams have been crushed” after Ticketmaster cancelled their ...The Guardian - 3d -
The end of insurance: Climate change is destroying homeowners and insurers
Traditional insurance models aren’t able to handle escalating natural disaster risks.MarketWatch - 3d -
Oasis fans see tickets cancelled over 'bots' claim
Fans say they have been wrongly accused of using bots to buy their tickets for the comeback shows.BBC News - 4d -
WATCH: Deserving superfans surprised with tickets to Super Bowl
“GMA” surprised Toya Mathis, a colon cancer survivor and now volunteer with the American Cancer Society, with tickets to Super Bowl LIX.ABC News - 4d -
Gutting USAID Will Have a Monumental Effect on Combating Climate Change
The agency was a key player in renewable energy and disaster protection around the world—until Elon Musk showed up.Wired - 4d -
‘Backsliding’: most countries to miss vital climate deadline as Cop30 nears
Developing countries urge biggest polluters to act as Trump’s return to the White House heightens geopolitical turmoil. The vast majority of governments are likely to miss a looming deadline to ...The Guardian - 4d -
Doctor fears "vaccine hesitancy" is contributing to worst flu season in 15 years
This year is shaping up as the worst flu season in more than 15 years. Flu cases are in every state, but the virus is most active in 43, including Indiana and Kentucky. Janet Shamlian reports from ...CBS News - 4d -
Deion Sanders: Shedeur wouldn't be the quarterback he is if he had inherited my speed
Deion Sanders was an all-time great athlete.Yahoo Sports - 5d -
Elon Musk’s journey from climate champion to backing EV-bashing Trump
Musk believes Tesla’s rivals are more vulnerable to Trump’s moves against electric vehicles. Donald Trump ’s attempts to slash incentives for electric cars would cause sales of the vehicles to ...The Guardian - 5d
More from The Hill
-
Senate Democrats could be locked out of power for a very long time
Senate Democrats face significant challenges in regaining control of the chamber, as Republican gains in the 2024 elections have given the party a 53-47 majority, making it difficult for Democrats ...The Hill - 24m -
Trump's FCC probing Comcast, NBC over DEI policies
The Federal Communications Commission (FCC) is planning to open an investigation into Comcast, the parent company of NBCUniversal, over its diversity, equity and inclusion (DEI) policies. In a ...The Hill - 44m -
White House acknowledges disagreement with Jordan over relocating Palestinians
The White House on Wednesday acknowledged disagreement between President Trump and King Abdullah II of Jordon over Trump's pitch to relocate Palestinians from the Gaza Strip while the U.S. takes ...The Hill - 44m -
Businessman says he won't wait for McConnell retirement if he decides to run for Senate seat
Kentucky businessman Nate Morris said Wednesday that he is not waiting for Sen. Mitch McConnell (R-Ky.) to decide if he will run for reelection next year, announcing his interest in launching a ...The Hill - 47m -
The Trump administration needs a Turkish-Syria policy right now
Turkish President Erdogan and his administration are negotiating with Syria's interim president to solidify its influence and control over the new Syrian government, potentially threatening ...The Hill - 54m
More in Politics
-
Senate Democrats could be locked out of power for a very long time
Senate Democrats face significant challenges in regaining control of the chamber, as Republican gains in the 2024 elections have given the party a 53-47 majority, making it difficult for Democrats ...The Hill - 24m -
AP says White House banned its reporter over Gulf of America name
The White House on Tuesday demanded the AP alter its style guidance of the Gulf of Mexico, which President Trump renamed last month.CBS News - 40m -
Trump's FCC probing Comcast, NBC over DEI policies
The Federal Communications Commission (FCC) is planning to open an investigation into Comcast, the parent company of NBCUniversal, over its diversity, equity and inclusion (DEI) policies. In a ...The Hill - 44m -
White House acknowledges disagreement with Jordan over relocating Palestinians
The White House on Wednesday acknowledged disagreement between President Trump and King Abdullah II of Jordon over Trump's pitch to relocate Palestinians from the Gaza Strip while the U.S. takes ...The Hill - 44m -
Businessman says he won't wait for McConnell retirement if he decides to run for Senate seat
Kentucky businessman Nate Morris said Wednesday that he is not waiting for Sen. Mitch McConnell (R-Ky.) to decide if he will run for reelection next year, announcing his interest in launching a ...The Hill - 47m