Could Stephen A. Smith save the Democratic Party?
I have long been a fan of ESPN personality Stephen A. Smith. I believe he has the best sports mind in the business. But more than that, I believe he has an exceptional mind — period.
He loves talking about a host of issues, politics being one of them. He’s also made a living out of talking smack from time to time, when he believes someone has messed up or not lived up to expectations. Politics is obviously a target-rich environment.
While I’m not sure of his political leanings, I have always believed him to be a Democrat when he has waded into at least the shallow end of the political pool. And nothing at all wrong with that.
Recently, while on “Real Time With Bill Maher,” StephenA — as he is often called — ripped into the campaign of former Vice President Kamala Harris. Said Smith: “Kamala Harris, who didn’t resonate during the primaries in 2020, couldn’t even get to Iowa, suddenly is the Democratic nominee, then you roll up to the convention in Chicago and everybody is like ‘She’s a rockstar!’ So it’s like ‘How’d that happen?”
Smith then added, “Yes I voted for her, a lot of people voted for her, but in the end, we end up feeling like damnfools, because we supported it, we fell for the okiedoke as they say. If you had a primary, the likelihood is she would not have been the Democratic nominee.”
To be sure, myself and a great many people I know — including some very influential Democrats — share that same belief. That said, those influential Democrats have only shared that belief with me in private. StephenA is more than happy to say it to millions of people. Repeatedly.
More than that, he is willing to state that President Donald Trump was more in-tune with the American voter — including the Black community — than Harris or the Democrats. Quite relevantly, he says that as one who came out of “real America.” Meaning a middle- to lower-middle-class upbringing in the Bronx, where he was the youngest of six children supported by a father who managed a hardware store.
I would have been happy to trade childhoods with him. As a white child, I grew up in abject poverty which saw me homeless and living in a car often. By the time I was 17 years old, we had been evicted from 34 homes. One of the only silver linings of those evictions being that we occasionally ended up in majority-Black housing projects.
As that child in those projects, I also got to witness the very personification of heroism in single Black moms who often worked two or more jobs and sacrificed their own happiness to provide for their children, strong and courageous women who became my earliest and most enduring role models. Heroes who taught me that “Black America” was a great America.
But, that part of America — most especially those struggling to survive in our inner cities — has been all but abandoned by the entrenched elites from both political parties. An America all but voiceless, looking for an authentic champion. Could Stephen A. Smith be that champion?
Why not? And if so, why not the champion of the disenfranchised from every community in America. And if the disenfranchised, why not the working-class as well?
Trump has broken a great many molds over his lifetime, the most critical and lasting being the political mold. He shattered it. He has become the ultimate “un-politician.” He did so because of his business experience and success coupled with that all but unattainable “It Factor.”
One could argue that Smith has that “It Factor” as well, which allows him quite a bit of leeway to speak his mind or call out failure.
Going back to the Democratic Party and the loss by Harris, Smith said to Fox News Channel’s Sean Hannity, “I think that in light of those results we have to look at this election as a referendum on the Democratic Party. And America’s saying we’re not feeling where you are, we’re not feeling where you tried to go, we want no part of it, we’re not having it…”
Smith has continually called out the Democrats for focusing on name-calling, fringe issues and DEI rather than the ones the voters most cared about — such as immigration, the economy, education, crime and health care. While on Chris Cuomo’s program on NewsNation this week, StephenA once again called the Democratic Party “tone deaf” and “leaderless.” Many believe him to be correct on both counts — including Democrats.
If I were part of the Democratic Party brain trust in search of a winning presidential candidate, I might be seeking an “un-politician” with a backstory that connects with “real America”; has a massive platform; is independently wealthy and can tell the entrenched elites to stuff their “special interests”; has that all-elusive “It Factor”; and is not afraid to trash talk or call out failure. Trump won two elections checking those boxes.
If I were part of the Democratic brain trust, I would be reaching out to Stephen A. Smith.
Douglas MacKinnon is a former White House and Pentagon official.
-
McCarthy: Fetterman 'should be leader of the Democratic Party'
Former Speaker Kevin McCarthy (R-Calif.) said Democrats should follow the lead of Sen. John Fetterman (D-Pa.), who has openly supported some of the GOP rhetoric on immigration. “Listen to ...The Hill - Jan. 17 -
Stephen A. Smith: Obama chat with Trump not a 'good look'
Sports media personality Stephen A. Smith said former President Obama’s chat with President-elect Trump at former President Carter's funeral was not “a good look.” “It wasn't a good look, but it ...The Hill - Jan. 16 -
Can Democrats Be the Party of the Future Again?
Ro Khanna, a progressive from Silicon Valley, on Big Tech’s rightward lurch.The New York Times - Jan. 10 -
Democrats have become the party of war. Americans are tired of it
In defending the militarist status quo, Democrats ceded the anti-war lane to Republicans. As they enter the political wilderness, it’s time to reckon with what they got so wrong. The most ...The Guardian - Jan. 9 -
Democrats are the party of religious freedom, not obligatory faith-talk
Democrats are advised to connect with voters by expressing their faith in an authentic way, but not to impose their religious beliefs on others, and to respect religious freedom and separation of ...The Hill - Jan. 8 -
Stephen A. Smith: Americans 'relate' to Trump's view on Canada
Sports media personality Stephen A. Smith says Americans feel a connection with President-elect Trump's rhetoric on Canada and Greenland. "This kind of language, no matter how frivolous we may ...The Hill - Jan. 8 -
How Deep Is the Wound to the Democratic Party?
Is liberalism actually dead this time?The New York Times - Jan. 7 -
The first step for the Democrats to win again: A party overhaul
The playbook we’ve used for decades must be discarded, and power brokers who haven’t had a big win since 2012 should not be who we look to for solutions.The Hill - Jan. 7 -
Congestion Pricing Shows the Future of the Democratic Party
A model for how to deliver for voters without getting stuck in a traffic jam — political or otherwise.The New York Times - Jan. 5
More from The Hill
-
The Age of Fear: How fear is suffocating America
Fear is suffocating America, contributing to its spiritual and moral disintegration, and contributing to tribalism, where individuals are judged by their identity rather than their actions.The Hill - 53m -
Michigan priest has license revoked after imitating Musk's gesture at Pro-Life Summit
A Michigan priest had his license rescinded by the Anglican Catholic Church after imitating a cross-body gesture that tech billionaire Elon Musk made at an event following President Trump's ...The Hill - 1h -
Live updates: Trump tariff threats materialize; Minnesota's Ken Martin to lead Democrats
President Trump is slated to make good on his campaign promise and enact steep tariffs on the country’s top three trading partners Saturday. For months, Trump has threatened Canada and Mexico with ...The Hill - 1h -
As DEI falters, Black Americans should revisit the vision of Marcus Garvey
Marcus Garvey ignited one of the most phenomenal social movements in modern history and was admired around the world. Yet few today understand his quest to promote the economic and cultural ...The Hill - 1h -
Ken Martin elected next DNC chair
Minnesota state party chair Ken Martin was elected on Saturday as the next leader of the Democratic National Committee (DNC) after securing more than 246 votes out of the 428 members who voted, ...The Hill - 1h
More in Politics
-
The Age of Fear: How fear is suffocating America
Fear is suffocating America, contributing to its spiritual and moral disintegration, and contributing to tribalism, where individuals are judged by their identity rather than their actions.The Hill - 53m -
Michigan priest has license revoked after imitating Musk's gesture at Pro-Life Summit
A Michigan priest had his license rescinded by the Anglican Catholic Church after imitating a cross-body gesture that tech billionaire Elon Musk made at an event following President Trump's ...The Hill - 1h -
New York doctor indicted for prescribing abortion pill in Louisiana
A New York doctor was indicted by a Louisiana grand jury for allegedly prescribing an abortion pill online in a state with one of the strictest abortion bans.CBS News - 1h -
Live updates: Trump tariff threats materialize; Minnesota's Ken Martin to lead Democrats
President Trump is slated to make good on his campaign promise and enact steep tariffs on the country’s top three trading partners Saturday. For months, Trump has threatened Canada and Mexico with ...The Hill - 1h -
Ken Martin elected next DNC chair
Minnesota state party chair Ken Martin was elected on Saturday as the next leader of the Democratic National Committee (DNC) after securing more than 246 votes out of the 428 members who voted, ...The Hill - 1h