Could a network approach help NATO deal with generative AI?
Last month, President Biden signed a $95 billion national security package that provided funding to Ukraine, Taiwan and Israel. For Ukrainians, this aid is vital relief. Absent U.S. support, Ukraine’s shortages of ammunition would likely yield Russia long-lasting victories. Alongside much-needed military aid, the supplemental package provides reassurance to Ukrainians that the United States — and NATO — remain committed to support their continued defense against Russia’s aggression.
However, NATO’s struggle is not only on the battlefield. Online, the war in Ukraine has led to increases in disinformation campaigns aimed at the U.S. and its NATO allies. And with the advent of generative AI, this problem is bound to get even more severe. Through deepfakes and other AI-generated synthetic media that appear highly realistic, NATO is likely to find itself on the receiving end of a barrage of AI-generated content whose veracity is difficult to ascertain.
How should NATO respond to AI-generated media? Various approaches have been proposed, from new content verification systems to launching new public media literacy campaigns. However, there is one approach that NATO should consider more broadly: a “network approach,” a term coined by Tyler McBrian in a paper for the Innovations for Successful Societies program at Princeton University. Applying a “network approach” to generative AI would start from the premise that international organizations and national governments are unlikely to identify all relevant pieces of AI-generated content alone. Thus, under a network approach, NATO would partner with civil society, non-government organizations (NGOs) and other private actors across the alliance’s member states. In the case of AI-generated content, these civic and private partners would help identify AI-generated synthetic media that purports to be authentic and notify NATO, who would then coordinate a response with national governments within member states.
This network approach could offer two major strengths. First, it would help NATO more effectively address the challenge of generative AI, given its limited resources. Given NATO’s growing set of commitments, from Ukraine aid to building new partnerships with Argentina, South Korea, Japan and a variety of other tasks, the organization could benefit from ways to use its limited resources more efficiently to achieve all its goals. Through a network approach, NATO could partially delegate some of its efforts to identify malicious AI-generated content to civic organizations in its member states, freeing up important staffing and economic resources for other tasks in the cyber theatre.
Second, and more importantly, it would serve as a form of much-needed public diplomacy. Through NATO’s engagement with local civil society organizations and private groups to verify AI-generated content, the alliance would be able to build working relationships that would foster trust, legitimacy and credibility within these communities. As some in the transatlantic alliance are increasingly skeptical toward NATO, public diplomacy efforts could help ease negative perceptions of NATO among critics and shore up support for the alliance within member states.
Furthermore, there is already empirical evidence of this solution’s efficacy. The first country to pioneer this “network approach” was a NATO member: Estonia. Given reports of misinformation in the United States and the United Kingdom, the Estonian government envisioned the first network approach to disinformation to protect the integrity of the country’s elections. The government formed an interagency task force in cooperation with NGOs, firms and other groups who helped the government identify false information and adapt its public messaging to counter it. Thanks to this network approach, Estonia ranked among the top European countries for its population’s media literacy and disinformation strategy in 2021 (Media Literacy Index by the Bulgarian Open Society Institute).
Though it offers benefits, the network approach does also face significant limitations. First, as generative AI models improve, it may soon be difficult for local partners to verify if content is AI-generated — indeed, the efficacy of detectors today is far from perfect. This limitation would be difficult to overcome unless AI-detection technology improves alongside with AI content generation. This means that the use of this network approach may be more short-term and not as viable in the future. To move around this problem, actors in NATO member states should invest more in efforts to improve content provenance and verification systems.
Second, there is likely substantial heterogeneity in the efficacy of different partners under this approach. Indeed, some civil society organizations are likely to be more familiar with identifying AI-generated content, while others may be less familiar, leading to the overrepresentation of input from certain partners versus others and biasing the AI-generated content that NATO sees and chooses to address. Resolving this challenge would require NATO to selectively choose its partner organizations to be a non-biased and representative sample across the alliance. This constraint may also require the network approach to be used sparingly, only in limited cases where AI-generated content is particularly persistent and widespread such that multiple partners detect it.
Third, more evidence from new countries is needed to verify this approach’s efficacy. Estonia is a relatively small country with high levels of public trust in government and heavy investment in digital literacy. Therefore, it is not clear how effective it would be in countries with lower levels of trust in state institutions or less investment in media literacy. For example, in countries with lower levels of trust in government, civil society organizations may be less willing to partner with government actors, limiting the ability to establish the partnerships that are central to this approach’s success.
Given these limitations, NATO may benefit from testing the network approach to elucidate its benefits prior to scaling it. First, NATO could launch pilot programs in member countries with high levels of digital literacy and public trust, working with local civil society organizations and firms to flag AI-generated content in these regions. Then, through these pilot programs, NATO could assess the efficacy of the approach and, if deemed successful, scale it up to counter AI-generated misinformation in Ukraine and Western Europe. Together, this solution could help better prepare us for our AI future.
Sergio Imparato is a lecturer in government and assistant director of Undergraduate Studies in the Government Department at Harvard University. Sarosh Nagar is a Marshall Scholar and researcher at Harvard. His work has previously been published by The United Nations, The Hill, JAMA and Nature Biotechnology.
Date: |
Filter
-
Activist Corvex could take an amicable approach to help create value at Vestis. How it may unfold
Corvex reveals a stake in uniform supplier Vestis. The firm is suggesting that it’s here for the long term.CNBC - Business -
IBM and Palo Alto Networks Deal Prompts Questions Over Appetite for CybersecurityPlatforms
Palo Alto Networks is betting businesses will continue buying security software as a platform, rather than individual tools. But there are signs not all enterprises are on board.The Wall Street Journal - World -
Ukraine war briefing: Kharkiv campaign won’t deliver major Russian breakthrough – Nato general
Ukraine accuses invaders of killing civilians and setting up human shields; sanctions over North Korean arms supply to Russia. What we know on day 814. Russia does not have sufficient forces on the ground to make a major breakthrough in Ukraine ...The Guardian - World - Ukraine -
Baidu Posts Quarterly Beat, Helped by AI Pursuits
Chinese search-engine giant Baidu reported a drop in quarterly profit, but beat top- and bottom-line estimates, helped by stable online marketing revenue and rising sales from its AI Cloud business.The Wall Street Journal - Business -
Grab Sees Generative AI Boosting Cost-Cutting Drive
Southeast Asian ride-hailing and delivery specialist Grab Holdings is using generative artificial intelligence to trim expenses and boost a cost-cutting drive in its continuing bid to achieve profitability.The Wall Street Journal - World -
Lawmakers Fear a Wave of Election Threats Tied to the Rise of Generative AI
Some small businesses are stepping up to help protect ballot boxes and preserve faith in the electoral process.Inc. - Business -
Grab Sees Generative AI Boosting Cost-Cutting Drive
Southeast Asian ride-hailing and delivery specialist Grab Holdings is using generative artificial intelligence to trim expenses and boost a cost-cutting drive in its continuing bid to achieve profitability.The Wall Street Journal - Business -
New blood test for strokes could help tackle a $2 trillion problem, researchers say
A new blood test can quickly detect a particularly severe type of stroke, according to new research published Friday, dramatically improving patients’ odds of getting lifesaving treatment before it’s too late.MarketWatch - Business -
Alleged ‘deal’ offer from Trump to big oil could save industry $110bn, study finds
Ex-president at Mar-a-Lago last month hosted more than 20 executives, including from Chevron, Exxon and Occidental. A “deal” allegedly offered by Donald Trump to big-oil executives as he sought $1bn in campaign donations could save the industry ...The Guardian - World - Donald Trump -
Voxel51 secures $30M to help gen AI understand visual input more accurately
Voxel51 has secured $30M in new funding for its visual AI platform, helping companies refine their models around images and video data.VentureBeat - Tech
More from The Hill
-
White House presses Senate Democrats to support border security bill
White House press secretary Karine Jean-Pierre on Monday urged senators to pass a border security bill expected to come up for a vote this week after Republicans blocked the measure earlier this year. "This bipartisan border legislation would ...The Hill - Politics -
Democrats’ fight against hate crimes vanishes in the face of antisemitism
The Democratic Party has an antisemitism problem on its left flank.The Hill - Politics -
Senate Republicans introduce legislation to legalize IVF treatment nationally
Republican Sens. Ted Cruz (Texas) and Katie Britt (Ala.) announced Monday that they are introducing legislation to protect legal access to in vitro fertilization (IVF) nationwide in the wake of an Alabama Supreme Court ruling that embryos created ...The Hill - Politics - Republican Party -
Republicans must offer a bold ObamaCare alternative to put patients in control
Republicans can no longer afford to kick the can down the road and tinker around the edges of ObamaCare while the whole system falls apart and our fellow citizens suffer. The time for excuses is over. The time for health care freedom is now.The Hill - Politics - Republican Party -
Federal judge in Texas blocks Biden rule expanding gun background checks
A federal judge in Texas on Sunday blocked a Biden administration rule that expanded the requirements for background checks when selling a firearm. Judge Matthew Kacsmaryk granted an injunction against the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco and Firearms ...The Hill - Politics - Joe Biden