Consumed by his own conspiracy theories: The downfall of Donald Trump
Pundits spent the days in the run-up to Donald Trump’s first debate with Kamala Harris trying their best to predict which Trump would show up on Tuesday night. Few could have predicted the dizzying variety of unhinged rants the former president would put on display — including one very memorable line about cats.
In one of the most humiliating moments of his political career, Trump amplified a debunked conspiracy theory that Haitian migrants in Springfield, Ohio, had been caught stealing and eating local pets.
When moderator David Muir fact-checked this lie with a statement from Springfield city officials, Trump went into full-on meltdown mode. “I’ve seen people on television! The people on television saying ‘my dog has been taken and used for food!’” he barked.
That moment was a victory for the small circle of right-wing Internet weirdos who first advanced Trump’s pet-eating hoax. For the millions of Americans who don’t live their lives online, it seemed like the former president had finally lost his mind.
Trump’s very public breakdown on the debate stage is just the latest example of how the far-right social media influencer sphere has permeated every part of the Republican political machine. It’s easy to trace the growth of the cat-eating hoax from terminally online provocateurs like Ian Miles Cheong directly to campaign speeches by Republican vice presidential candidate JD Vance. But playing to such a small base of Trump’s online superfans comes at the cost of alienating swing-state voters who aren’t plugged in to the right’s constant stream of online grievances.
It’s no secret that Team Trump often takes its cues from the social media trolls who churn out pro-Trump propaganda on a nearly hourly basis. In recent weeks Trump has openly courted right-wing social media influencers through multiple podcast and streaming appearances, including YouTuber Adin Ross and bro-culture comedian Theo Von. But those audiences are already in the tank for Trump — it’s hard to imagine many Harris-curious voters listening to Von or turning to Cheong or to alleged Russian asset Tim Pool.
In a sense, Trump’s recent pivot to cater almost exclusively to his very online right-wing base is a safety blanket for a campaign deeply rattled by the departure of Joe Biden from the race and the fast rise of Harris in his place. Trump knows he won’t face tough questions from his most loyal fans, and the softball interviews and fawning praise provide him with the comforting illusion of hitting a grand slam with every half-baked response.
But there’s no doubt that steeping in viral right-wing slop has turned Trump’s campaign into something of a niche experience.
Instead of using his 90 minutes of debate time to hammer Harris on, say, inflation, Trump dedicated multiple viral moments to such conspiracy theories. Trump’s rant about cat-eating won’t do anything to dispel Tim Walz’s viral claim that Republicans are simply too weird to govern. But what Americans saw on the debate stage last night might even be too weird for some of Trump’s biggest supporters. When Bulwark podcaster Tim Miller asked South Carolina Sen. Lindsey Graham about Trump’s performance, Graham described the debate as a “disaster” and called for all of Trump’s debate preppers to be summarily fired.
Firing up his online base may have been an effective strategy back in June, when Trump was coasting to victory over Biden. It’s an exercise in terrible strategy now that Trump is trailing Harris in key swing states and quickly losing ground in once-safe Republican strongholds like North Carolina, where Quinnipiac has Harris leading by 3 points.
If Trump hoped to show voters that he understood their most fundamental concerns, Tuesday’s debate was an embarrassing flop. Instead, most people will remember last night’s matchup as the night when Donald Trump said people were eating pets. In an election where most voters cite economic issues as their top priority, it’s tough to say where that kind of thing ranks.
Judging by Republicans’ frantic post-debate spin room work, Trump’s conspiracy mongering wasn’t the message they’d hoped to close on — but it was certainly classic Trump. Too bad it was also incoherent to anyone outside the right-wing echo chamber.
Max Burns is a veteran Democratic strategist and founder of Third Degree Strategies.
An earlier version of this piece suggested, mistakenly, that Kamala Harris had not supported gender transition surgeries for federal prisoners. She did support this, according to reporting by CNN.
Date: | |
Tag: | Donald Trump |
-
The Hill - Politics
America’s story is bigger than Trump’s hateful conspiracy theories
The presidential debate is over, but the people of Springfield, Ohio, are only beginning to face its fallout.3 hours ago - Donald Trump -
ABC News - Tech
Donald Trump doesn't share details about his family's cryptocurrency venture during X launch event
Republican presidential nominee Donald Trump has launched his family’s cryptocurrency venture, World Liberty Financial, with an interview on the X social media platform3 hours ago - Donald Trump -
The Guardian - World
Far-right conspiracies abound after second apparent Trump assassination attempt
Baseless theories about suspect Ryan Wesley Routh and his alleged ties to US military spread online after his arrest. US politics live – latest updates After a man who appears to be obsessive ...5 hours ago - Donald Trump -
The New York Times - Business
Donald Trump Rolls Out World Liberty Financial, a New Crypto Venture
In a livestream, Donald Trump formally introduced World Liberty Financial, a crypto venture led by two digital currency entrepreneurs with little experience running high-profile businesses.11 hours ago - Donald Trump -
The Guardian - World
Republican House speaker announces vote on government funding bill paired with non-citizen voting ban – live
Mike Johnson announces he will tomorrow hold a vote on legislation to head off a partial government shutdown that would begin 1 October. As far as the election campaign is concerned, this week the ...9 minutes ago -
NBC News - Politics
Suspected gunman camped out at golf course for 12 hours, didn't have Trump in line of sight
The man arrested in connection with an apparent attempt to assassinate Donald Trump is a former supporter who turned against the former president in part for foreign policy reasons and later ...13 hours ago - Donald Trump -
ABC News - Top stories
US retail sales ticked up last month in sign of ongoing consumer resilience
Americans spent a bit more at retailers last month, providing a small boost to the economy just as the Federal Reserve considers how much to cut its key interest rate1 hour ago -
Politico - Politics
Senate Dems balk at Johnson's spending bill, but wait to release their own plan
6 days ago -
Inc. - Business
Not Sure What to Focus on in Life? Richard Branson and Beyoncé Both Suggest the Theory of Circles
When you're not sure how to invest your time and energy, the theory of circles can guide you.6 hours ago
More from The Hill
-
The Hill - Politics
Five things to know about the Sean Combs indictment
Sean “Diddy” Combs is expected to appear before a federal judge on Tuesday after being charged with abusing, threatening, and coercing women and others around him to “fulfill his sexual desires, ...34 minutes ago -
The Hill - Politics
Arrests at southern border rose slightly in August
Arrests at the southern border ticked up last month for the first time since the rollout of a new Biden administration policy limiting access to asylum. The Border Patrol made about 58,000 arrests ...35 minutes ago -
The Hill - Politics
DeSantis: Florida authorities launching criminal probe of Trump assassination attempt
Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis (R) said Tuesday that the state is launching a criminal probe into the apparent assassination attempt on former President Trump at his golf course in West Palm Beach, ...40 minutes ago - Florida -
The Hill - Politics
Corporate greed doesn’t need a boost from ‘anti-ESG’ politicians
Republicans are attempting to demonize environmental, social and governance practices in investing.51 minutes ago -
The Hill - Politics
Meta bans Russian state media outlets, citing 'foreign interference activity'
Meta has banned Russian state media from its social media platforms in the wake of the outlets' “foreign interference activity,” the company announced late Monday. “After careful consideration, we ...55 minutes ago - Russia