Conservatives aren’t the only ones calling for school choice
From Nebraska to Tennessee to Oregon and beyond, this year has brought another round of school-choice debates, often portrayed as a “right-wing” issue. But if you think right-of-center policymakers own the movement, think again.
Yes, Republican governors are more likely to promote charter schools and public funds for private school attendance while the pro-charter, pro-accountability Democrats for Education Reform have no apparent influence in President Biden’s White House.
And yes, the teacher unions’ financial alliance with Democrats limits what’s politically possible in solidly blue states. Just last year, Democrats ended Illinois’ only tax credit program, which passed in 2017 with bipartisan support and gave low-income students scholarships to attend private schools.
But a closer look at recent history shows the crucial role that progressives have played since the 1960s in making the case for school choice. I explore their and other arguments in the soon-to-be-released Cardus study, "The Progressive Case for Educational Pluralism."
Pro-education reform progressives in America, it turns out, simply represent the normal practices of democracies around the world — most of which fund a wide variety of schools equally and hold them equally accountable for academic results.
From University of California, Berkeley law professors John E. Coons and Stephen D. Sugarman, to journalists like Joe Williams and civil rights leaders like Martin Luther King III, a small but vocal set of progressives have objected to the district-school-only model on multiple grounds. Here are three.
First, some progressives saw the need for school choice through both negative and positive data. The inability of urban districts to serve students of color led Milwaukee’s then-superintendent Howard Fuller to launch the country’s first voucher program in 1990. Fuller still views the program as a clear continuation of the civil rights agenda of which he has been a part.
Sol Stern, a journalist for Ramparts Magazine, came to support school choice after years of encountering abusive teachers who could not be fired and administrators unwilling to rock the boat in New York City while Catholic schools offered academic rigor at a fraction of the cost.
James Coleman, the sociologist who authored the groundbreaking “Equality of Educational Opportunity Report” in 1966, found that in the aggregate, district schools did not change the academic trajectory predicted by family background. Coleman also found that Catholic high schools did change these trajectories, closing achievement gaps between low- and high-income students in four years.
Second, other progressives rejected the ethos of the district school. Sugarman and Coons argued against district schools’ search for moral neutrality, which resulted only in “riskless noncommitment” and “ethical detachment” — both of which they cited as bad for psychological development and adult citizenship.
Jonathon Kozol and Paul Goodman objected to the effects of school districts’ “depersonalized, unresponsive bureaucracy,” which bred conformity rather than creative expression. They called for alternative schools that were small, organic and responsive to communities’ needs.
Third, all of the above argued in favor of the inherent right of marginalized communities to exercise agency over their children’s educations.
Why did the government’s public housing and public food benefits allow participants to choose their meals or homes, but its public education benefit did not allow a choice for schools? Why were wealthy American parents able to choose schools by choosing to own or rent in “good” school districts, but low-income parents had to take what they were assigned? This seemed a violation of justice.
At the same time, these progressives argued for public assurances of quality — first and foremost, for a high academic bar. Coons, Sugarman and philosophy professor Harry Brighouse emphasized the role the liberal arts curriculum could play, with its exposure to specific historical, scientific and literary knowledge and diverse philosophical and religious perspectives, to build students’ autonomy and academic success.
The left-right binary to which we’ve become sadly accustomed is simply inaccurate. Correcting this narrative is the first step in finding cross-partisan ways to create a more generous, equitable, and academically excellent path for the next generation.
Milton Friedman wasn’t the only one calling for vouchers. James Coleman did, too.
Ashley Rogers Berneris the director and an associate professor with the Johns Hopkins Institute for Education Policy and a fellow with the Mercatus Center’s Program on Pluralism and Civil Discourse.
Date: |
Filter
-
Hogan backs codifying Roe v. Wade, calls himself 'pro-choice'
Former Maryland Gov. Larry Hogan (R) said he would back codifying Roe v. Wade abortion protections and called himself “pro-choice” in a new interview, as he seeks Democratic support in his match-up against Prince George’s County Executive Angela ...The Hill - Politics -
Enviable Men's Watches Under $600 (Psst: One Is Only $16)
Here are six good-looking, great-value designs.The Wall Street Journal - World -
From Deep Positional Recap: Jordan Poole not only one of the biggest misses at SG, but the whole fantasy year
Fantasy basketball analyst Dan Titus continues his positional exit interviews with the shooting guards.Yahoo Sports - Sports -
Campus protests have called for schools to divest from Israel. Here's how that would actually work
Protesters on campuses nationwide have called on universities to divest from Israel due to the war in Gaza. Here's how divestment would actually work.CNBC - Business - Israel -
Ex-NBA referee calls Chris Paul 'one of the biggest a--holes' in the league while defending Scott Foster
Paul and Foster, a longtime NBA official, have been feuding for yearsCBS Sports - Sports -
Microsoft plans a shake-up of its videogame sales strategy by releasing the next "Call of Duty" to its subscription service instead of the lucrative approach of only selling it a la carte.
Microsoft plans a shake-up of its videogame sales strategy by releasing the next “Call of Duty” to its subscription service instead of the lucrative approach of only selling it a la carte.The Wall Street Journal - World -
Iran’s Next Leaders Face a Choice: Aggression or Caution
The question is whether the successors to the president and foreign minister will take a similar path by keeping slivers of communication open, and avoiding direct conflict with the United States.The New York Times - Top stories - Iran -
Rishi Sunak’s scare tactics aren’t going to work against a soothing Keir Starmer | Andrew Rawnsley
As he demonstrated at the launch of his pledge cards, the Labour leader has succeeded in de-risking perceptions of his party . Who scares wins. That has been the motto of many, often successful Conservative election campaigns. Fear may not be an ...The Guardian - World -
Gorsuch, Alito break from conservatives on CFPB ruling
Two of the Supreme Court’s most conservative justices broke away from other right-leaning members of the nation’s high court in a decision to preserve the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) — but a third led the majority opinion that ...The Hill - Politics -
Nashville fires Smith, only coach in team history
Nashville SC has fired Gary Smith, the only head coach in franchise history.ESPN - Sports - Tennessee
More from The Hill
-
Trump hush money trial turns to defense: Live updates
Star witness Michael Cohen completed hours of testimony on Monday before the prosecution rested its case, handing former President Trump's hush money trial over to his defense team. Trump's defense strategy is largely unknown, including whether ...The Hill - Politics - Donald Trump -
Minnesota GOP endorses former NBA player to take on Klobuchar
The Minnesota Republican Party unexpectedly endorsed Royce White to take on Sen. Amy Klobuchar (D-Minn.) on Saturday, backing with the former NBA player-turned-activist who has embraced right-wing conspiracy theories. White, who was viewed as an ...The Hill - Politics - NBA -
House Dems outraise House GOP with record April fundraising month
The House Democrats’ campaign arm outraised their Republican counterpart in April with a record $12.4 million brought in during the month. The Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee’s (DCCC) total is the highest ever in the month of April ...The Hill - Politics -
Prosecution rests in whirlwind Trump hush money trial
Prosecutors with the Manhattan district attorney’s office have rested their case against former President Trump, bringing the first criminal trial of a U.S. president in the country’s history nearer to a close. Over four weeks of sometimes ...The Hill - Politics - Donald Trump -
From Biden to Butker, the biggest graduation speeches so far this year
The tumultuous academic year is coming to a fittingly high-profile end for the college class of 2024, though thus far, the commencement speech that raised the most eyebrows had nothing to do with Israel's war in Gaza. From the pro-Palestinian ...The Hill - Politics - Joe Biden