Congress should restore the rights SCOTUS stripped from patent owners
The "right to useful inventions ... belong[s] to the inventors."
James Madison articulated this core principle in the Federalist Papers and embedded it into our Constitution more than two centuries ago. In the years since, the U.S. patent system has been a driving force behind continued economic growth and innovation.
Today, however, that system is under threat. Fortunately, Congress is responding with a bipartisan bill aimed at restoring that right — and boosting our economy in the process.
The essence of James Madison's idea was that if those using a patented invention without permission should have to stop. This principle guided patent law for most of American history. But in 2006, following the Supreme Court's decision in eBay v. MercExchange, that began to change.
Lower courts focused on a three-paragraph concurrence in that case by then-Justice Anthony Kennedy, which suggested that monetary compensation should suffice for many patent holders. As a result, even when a patent holder proves infringement and successfully defends the validity of his or her patent in court, the infringer is often allowed to continue utilizing the patented invention, with only a "reasonable" payment ordered.
This approach is a radical departure from both history and ordinary legal principles. Courts don't usually let polluters keep polluting or trespassers keep trespassing in exchange for a payment. Typically, wrongdoers pay a fine or provide compensation for past misconduct but also are not allowed to continue their harmful actions.
For almost all of American history, courts routinely issue anti-infringement orders after trial. The eBay decision effectively defied this precedent, posing a significant risk to small innovators and startups.
The result has been the rise of "efficient infringement," where infringers see no downside to infringing and no upside to negotiating a license with the patent holder.
A simple analogy illustrates the problem: Imagine a hotel owner discovers someone occupying a room without checking in or paying. In a normal situation, the court would promptly evict the squatter. But if eviction isn't an option, the squatter gets to stay, and the court — not the hotel — decides what a "reasonable" price is for the room.
If this were how the law worked for hotels, trespassers would get free rooms any time they could avoid detection. Even if caught, they might get a better deal than if they had paid at the front desk. Pursuing squatters in court is expensive, and the court-ordered "reasonable" payment might be less than the hotel's standard rates.
Some hotel owners might accept lower payments to avoid litigation costs and hassle. Others might leave the business altogether, leaving honest travelers with fewer options.
A similar dynamic is plaguing America's technology economy. Large tech companies may see this as an opportunity to ignore the patent rights of smaller inventors. If they are never sued for infringement, the large companies could continue illegally using their rival's invention for free.
But even if they are sued, it may not be much of a problem. If the legal costs don't drive the patent owner out of business or the courtroom, the infringer will likely only have to pay a "reasonable" price to its exhausted adversary.
The eBay decision contributed to the decades-long dominance of a few tech giants. A "reasonable" payment cannot account for the full extent of the profits a company will earn on an infringed technology. And when small companies and startups struggle to protect their innovations against infringement by larger, better-resourced companies, they will find it difficult to carve out a place in the market.
Fortunately, members of Congress just proposed a timely solution. A bipartisan group of legislators led by Sens. Chris Coons (D-Del.) and Tom Cotton (R-Ark.) recently introduced a new bill called the RESTORE Patent Rights Act, which would reestablish injunctive relief as the default remedy for patent infringement.
If this bill becomes law, inventors will once again have full ownership of their creations, and patent infringers will no longer be able to steal technology with impunity.
Congress should pass the RESTORE Act to deliver justice to inventors and reinvigorate American innovation.
Nick Matich, a patent litigator in private practice, served as acting general counsel at the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office.
Date: |
-
Yahoo Sports - Sports
Week 2 Care/Don't Care: Fantasy football managers should stay away from the Bears for now
Week 2 of the fantasy football season brought more chaos. Matt Harmon sifts through the noise to find the signal.16 minutes ago - Fantasy Football -
The Guardian - World
Starmer under pressure to distance UK from Italy’s hard-right immigration plans
Backbenchers and NGOs criticise decision to explore how country has cut migrant numbers at Rome talks. Keir Starmer is under pressure from Labour backbenchers and NGOs to distance his government ...7 hours ago - United Kingdom -
BBC News - Top stories
'There should be outrage' over violence against women
A strategy to end violence against women and girls in Northern Ireland is set to be launched on Monday.5 hours ago -
Politico - Politics
Congress returns to Washington for a 3-week preelection sprint
6 days ago -
ESPN - Sports
Lawrence on Jags' offense: 'We suck right now'
Jaguars quarterback Trevor Lawrence was quick and to the point about his team's offense the first two weeks of the season. "We suck right now," he said.2 hours ago -
GameSpot - Tech
iPads Are Super Cheap Right Now At Amazon And Best Buy
Apple iPad 10.2-Inch (9th Gen) $199 (was ...7 hours ago -
Yahoo Sports - Sports
Watch Ramos crush first-ever right-handed Splash Hit homer
San Francisco Giants outfielder Heliot Ramos did something every right-handed hitter who has stepped foot in Oracle Park has wanted to do.2 hours ago -
ABC News - Sports
Heliot Ramos becomes first right-handed batter to hit Splash Homer at Oracle Park
The Giants’ Heliot Ramos became the first right-handed batter in the 25-season history of Oracle Park to hit a Splash Homer into McCovey Cove, achieving the feat in a 4-3 loss to the San Diego Padres3 hours ago -
Los Angeles Times - Entertainment
Emmys 2024 red carpet: See all the best fashion
The best looks from the 2024 Emmys Awards, including Selena Gomez, Jennifer Aniston, Sofia Vergara and Laverne Cox.6 hours ago -
The Guardian - World
Typhoon Yagi: scores dead from flooding in Myanmar
At least 320,000 people have been displaced and 64 were still missing after the strongest storm to hit Asia this year. Myanmar’s death toll from floods rose to at least 113, the country’s military ...5 hours ago
More from The Hill
-
The Hill - Politics
Over half of Americans say Harris won debate against Trump: Poll
More than half of Americans believe Vice President Harris won last week's presidential debate against former President Trump, according to a new poll. An ABC/Ipsos poll, released Sunday, found 58 ...1 hour ago - Kamala Harris -
The Hill - Politics
John Leguizamo makes Emmys call for greater representation in Hollywood
John Leguizamo says he's a "DEI hire," as he made an appeal at the Emmy Awards for greater diversity and representation in Hollywood. "I'm John Leguizamo and I'm one of Hollywood's DEI hires," ...1 hour ago -
The Hill - Politics
FBI investigates second Trump assassination attempt: Five things to know
Former President Trump was the target of another apparent assassination attempt while golfing in Florida on Sunday, marking the second attempt on his life in as many months. The incident adds to ...2 hours ago - Donald Trump -
The Hill - Politics
DeSantis says FL will conduct its own investigation of assassination attempt
Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis (R) said the state will conduct its own investigation into the apparent assassination attempt against former President Trump at his golf club Sunday in West Palm Beach. ...2 hours ago -
The Hill - Politics
Trump apparent assassination suspect identified: Reports
The man accused of pointing an AK-style rifle through the fence at Trump International Golf Club, where former President Trump was playing, has been identified as Ryan Wesley Routh, multiple media ...3 hours ago - Donald Trump