Columbia officials dodge pitfalls that caught Harvard, Penn
A quartet of Columbia University officials largely avoided a viral breakout moment in a Wednesday House hearing on antisemitism, but they still struggled in multiple areas when peppered with questions from Republican lawmakers.
The viral question that last year stumped the presidents of Harvard University, the University of Pennsylvania and the Massachusetts Institute of Technology was asked early of the Columbia officials.
Rep. Suzanne Bonamici (D-Ore.) asked all four witnesses if calls for the genocide of Jewish people would violate the school’s Code of Conduct.
The president of the school, two members of the board of trustees, and a professor all answered in the affirmative.
“Yes, it does,” said David Greenwald, co-chair of the board.
Their willingness to more directly condemn antisemitism and to recognize its pervasiveness on campus was celebrated by multiple lawmakers.
“My thoughts are that you are right that we have a moral crisis on our campus,” said Claire Shipman, the other co-chair for the board of trustees, adding “you're probably tired of hearing that I find the behavior of some of our students, some of our faculty, unacceptable.”
The hearing was not all smooth sailing, however, as Columbia President Nemat Shafik struggled in some of her answers relating to defining antisemitism and if chants such as “From the river to the sea, Palestine would be free” are antisemitic.
David Schizer, a professor at the law school and chair of the antisemitism taskforce, said that chant was antisemitic.
Shafik initially said it depends, as some individuals, even Jewish people, are not offended by the chant, but later when pushed by Rep. Elise Stefanik (R-N.Y.) Shafik said the school was “looking at” disciplinary actions for students who use the phrase.
“When I hear those terms, I find them very upsetting,” Shafik said when first asked about the chant. When pushed again if it's antisemitic, the president continued, “I hear them as such, some people don’t.”
Much of the hearing focused on disciplinary actions taken against professors or students who have engaged in controversial or antisemitic behavior on campus.
Columbia professor Joseph Andoni Massad received a lot of attention after he celebrated Hamas’s attack on Oct. 7. Shafik originally said the professor was already terminated but then later told Stefanik she would commit to firing Massad from his position as chair of an academic review committee.
Democrats decried during the hearing that other forms of discrimination have not been a priority of the committee.
“I think the Office of Civil Rights had indicated that they get a lot more complaints from racism, homophobia, Islamophobia and trans students and those also need to be addressed,” ranking member Bobby Scott (D-Va.) said.
While the hearing was more successful for Columbia, Education Committee Chair Virginia Foxx (R-N.C.) indicated the school was not out of the hot seat.
“While some changes have begun on campus, there is still a significant amount of work to be done,” Foxx said.
“We will be looking for answers to the questions that have been raised today in a very timely fashion and we are prepared to bring you back if we don’t see more tangible progress,” she added.
Date: |
Filter
-
Penn State Scandal Fast Facts
Read CNN's Fast Facts about the Penn State scandal.CNN - Top stories -
Harvard’s Taylor Swift Scholars Have Thoughts on ‘Tortured Poets’
The students taking Harvard University’s class on the singer are studying up. Their final papers are due at the end of the month.The New York Times - Lifestyle -
Johnson temporarily dodges ouster vote as House passes foreign aid
Conservative rebels are hoping the week-long recess will build support for their pending effort to boot the speaker.Politico - Politics -
Johnson temporarily dodges ouster vote as House passes foreign aid
Conservative rebels are hoping the week-long recess will build support for their pending effort to boot the speaker.Politico - Politics -
Johnson temporarily dodges ouster vote as House passes foreign aid
Conservative rebels are hoping the week-long recess will build support for their pending effort to boot the speaker.Politico - Politics -
Hamas and Fatah Officials, Longtime Rivals, Met in China
The Chinese government did not say when the talks between the main Palestinian factions were held. Expectations for progress were low.The New York Times - World - China -
Federal Officials Find No Live Bird Flu Virus in Initial Milk Tests
The early results suggest that pasteurization is killing the H5N1 virus in milk, something that regulators were not certain of.The New York Times - Business -
New Orleans archdiocese is target of child sex-trafficking inquiry, officials say
Louisiana state police recently served sweeping and unprecedented search warrant . The Roman Catholic archdiocese of New Orleans is the target of an active child sex-trafficking investigation, according to a sweeping and unprecedented search ...The Guardian - World -
China Moving Forced Laborers Amid U.S. Crackdown, Biden Official Says
Coerced laborers are being moved out of Xinjiang as China makes efforts to frustrate supply-chain due diligence, a Labor Department official says.The Wall Street Journal - World - Joe Biden -
Federal Officials Find No Live Bird Flu Virus in Initial Milk Tests
The early results suggest that pasteurization is killing the H5N1 virus in milk, something that regulators were not certain of.The New York Times - Health
More from The Hill
-
Trump claims ‘paid agitators’ part of Columbia pro-Palestine protests
Former President Trump made unfounded claims Tuesday that pro-Palestine protests at Columbia University contained "paid agitators" as nationwide college campus protests escalate. Hundreds of New York Police Department officers, many with batons ...The Hill - Politics - Donald Trump -
Police in riot gear enter Columbia University to break up pro-Palestine protests
Hundreds of New York Police Department officers, many with batons and in riot gear, moved onto Columbia University’s campus on Tuesday evening as student protesters continued a largely peaceful occupation of a campus building in protest of the ...The Hill - Politics -
White House considers admitting some Palestinians from Gaza as refugees
The Biden administration is considering admitting certain Palestinians to the U.S. as refugees, a report by CBS News found. Senior officials in several U.S. agencies have discussed the idea of resettling Palestinians from Gaza who have immediate ...The Hill - Politics -
Biden campaign hits Trump for saying he would close pandemic preparedness office
President Biden’s reelection campaign criticized former President Trump on Tuesday after Trump said he would get rid of the Office of Pandemic Preparedness and Response Policy (OPPR). The OPPR was founded in 2022 over failures in government ...The Hill - Politics - Joe Biden -
GOP senator calls for deporting certain foreign student protesters
Sen. Marsha Blackburn (R-Tenn.) called for the U.S. government to revoke the visas given to international students who are Hamas sympathizers and deport them as college protests continue nationwide. “You cannot go around yelling ‘I am Hamas’ or ...The Hill - Politics