Colorado Supreme Court dismisses suit against baker who refused to bake cake for transgender woman
Colorado’s Supreme Court on Tuesday dismissed a case involving a Christian baker who refused to provide a cake for a transgender woman’s celebration.
Attorney Autumn Scardina sued Jack Phillips, owner of Masterpiece Cakeshop based outside Denver, after he refused to provide a cake for her gender transition celebration. Phillips said it violated his religion.
The court in a 6-3 ruling did not consider the merits of the claims but determined Scardina had not exhausted her options to seek redress from another court before filing her lawsuit.
Phillips gained national attention in 2012 after his refusal to bake a cake for a same-sex couple's wedding was brought before the U.S. Supreme Court.
On the same day the U.S. Supreme Court announced it would hear Phillips’s case, Scardina allegedly called requesting a custom cake to celebrate her gender transition. She then called again to request another custom cake, one depicting Satan smoking marijuana, according to Phillips’s attorney.
When Phillips declined, Scardina filed an antidiscrimination claim with the Colorado Civil Rights Division and Colorado Civil Rights Commission.
Phillips then sued both the division and the commission in federal court, arguing that providing Scardina with a cake would violate his religion, according to court documents.
Scardina tried to become involved with the federal proceedings, but the district court denied her motion. Instead, both groups dismissed her administrative complaint through a confidential settlement but failed to issue the required order explaining its reasoning.
Phillips's attorney, Jake Warner of the Arizona-based firm Alliance for Defending Freedom, said Phillips is an artist who cannot be forced to comply with what he does not "believe." He noted Phillips has been under legal scrutiny for 10 years.
“Enough is enough. Jack has been dragged through courts for over a decade. It’s time to leave him alone,” Warner released in a statement.
Scardina’s attorney expressed disappointment with Tuesday's ruling.
“The Colorado Supreme Court decided to avoid the merits of this issue by inventing an argument no party raised,” John McHugh said, according to The Associated Press.
The minority dissent agreed with McHugh, saying the ruling adopts an “unprecedented administrative regime.”
“The ramifications of the majority’s ruling are troubling on many levels," the dissent reads. "Procedurally, the majority adopts an unprecedented administrative regime under which, once a merits hearing is set, a district court can never hear the matter; and an administrative agency may never settle the matter over a claimant’s objection, no matter how unreasonable that objection may be, but instead must litigate the matter to its conclusion. In my view, neither law nor sound policy supports such a conclusion.”
Date: |
-
Politics - The Hill
Supreme Court appears split on Oklahoma death row inmate’s fate
The Supreme Court appeared split over an Oklahoma death row inmate’s latest bid for freedom during arguments Wednesday, leaving his fate uncertain. Richard Glossip was convicted and sentenced to ...1 hour ago -
World - The Guardian
More than 100 raccoons besiege house of woman who had been feeding them
The woman, who has not been named, near Poulsbo, Washington, called the county sheriff, who sent deputies. Feeding wild raccoons around her home had seemed harmless enough, if odd, for one woman in ...1 hour ago -
Top stories - NBC News
Supreme Court weighs testimony from witness 'exposed as a liar' in Oklahoma death row case
The Supreme Court weighs whether inmate Richard Glossip's murder conviction should be thrown out — an unusual death penalty case in which the attorney general of Oklahoma has sided with a defendant.2 hours ago -
Lifestyle - The New York Times
The Politics of a Boring Suit
A night of few fireworks between the candidates was also a night of little sartorial flair. And that was the goal.October 2 -
Politics - The Hill
3 percent of high schoolers identify as transgender: Research
A new study from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) found 3.3 percent of high schoolers identify as transgender and another 2.2 percent identify as questioning. Among the ...5 hours ago -
Politics - The Hill
Lara Trump dismisses change candidate polling, citing 'beverage napkins'
Republican National Committee co-Chair Lara Trump dismissed polling showing that more voters view Vice President Harris as the presidential candidate representing change, citing "beverage napkins" ...5 hours ago - Donald Trump -
World - Financial Times
Starmer refuses to rule out raising employer National Insurance rate
Chancellor Rachel Reeves could raise billions of pounds by introducing levy on employer pension contributions6 hours ago -
Lifestyle - The New York Times
Tessa Tookes and Joey Kirchner Marry in a “Bachelor in Paradise Canada” Success Story
Tessa Tookes and Joey Kirchner were both feeling down on love. Then they were cast on “Bachelor in Paradise Canada,” and had a change of heart (with the help of producers).2 days ago -
Business - Financial Times
Starmer refuses to rule out raising employer national insurance rate
Chancellor Rachel Reeves could raise billions of pounds by introducing levy on employer pension contributions2 hours ago
More from The Hill
-
Politics - The Hill
Trump Florida resort hosts linemen before Hurricane Milton response
The Trump Organization extended an invitation to more than 200 power linemen to stay at their golf resort in Miami Wednesday, as Florida's Gulf Coast prepares for Hurricane Milton to make landfall ...33 minutes ago - Donald Trump -
Politics - The Hill
Slotkin, Rogers tied in Michigan Senate survey
Michigan Rep. Elissa Slotkin (D) and former Rep. Mike Rogers (R) are tied in a new survey as they vie for retiring Sen. Debbie Stabenow’s (D) seat in the upper chamber. The Quinnipiac University ...36 minutes ago -
Politics - The Hill
Harris makes impromptu call into CNN, says Trump’s hurricane comments 'dangerous'
Vice President Harris called into CNN on Wednesday to talk about Hurricane Milton as it approaches Florida, bashing former President Trump for his comments about the federal government's response ...43 minutes ago -
Politics - The Hill
Trump 'God Bless the USA' Bibles printed in China, records show
Thousands of copies of former President Trump's "God Bless the USA" Bible were printed in China, according to trade records reviewed by The Associated Press. According to AP, the records showed ...48 minutes ago - Donald Trump -
Politics - The Hill
Senate Democrat: Trump White House controlled ‘flawed and incomplete’ FBI Kavanaugh investigation
Democratic Sen. Sheldon Whitehouse (R.I.) released a report Wednesday that accused the Trump administration’s FBI of conducting a “flawed and incomplete” investigation into the allegations of ...52 minutes ago - Donald Trump