CNN anchor presses Trump lawyer on Kagan military coup questioning
CNN anchor Kaitlan Collins pressed an attorney for former President Trump on a line of questioning by Supreme Court Justice Elena Kagan in the former president’s presidential immunity case at the Supreme Court Thursday.
“What are the circumstances where ordering a military coup is an official act of the presidency?” Collins said, referring to a back-and-forth between Kagan and Trump lawyer D. John Sauer in which she questioned him on presidential immunity in the case of a president ordering the military to stage a coup.
“When you’re talking about official acts, you don't look to intent, you don't look to purpose, you look to their underlying character,” Scharf responded. “So if that were — if that sort of situation were to unfold using the official powers of the president, you could see there being an aspect of officialness to that.”
The two went back and forth, and Collins later remarked that Sharf was making “a pretty brazen argument, that military coups could potentially be official acts.”
Sharf retorted that the argument is not meant to justify such things, but to define the scope of immunity presidents have been acting in office.
"Just because a military coup or any of these sort of parade of horribles could constitute an official act doesn't mean that they're right, doesn't mean that they would be allowed under a constitutional system and doesn't mean that we're in any way shape or form justifying that," he said. "What we're talking about here, though, is the scope of immunity that presidents need to be able to rely on to discharge their core article to responsibilities as president."
When asked about if a president ordering “the military to stage a coup” is an “official act” by Kagan on Thursday as the Supreme Court held a hearing on Trump’s claims of immunity, Sauer responded that “it could well be.”
On the same day of the Supreme Court hearing, the former president was in court in New York for his hush money case, which began last week. The case marks the first criminal trial of a former American president. He has been charged with 34 counts of falsifying business records in relation to reimbursements to his attorney at the time, Michael Cohen, who paid an adult film actor $130,000 prior to the 2016 election to keep quiet about an alleged affair with Trump, which he denies.
Date: | |
Tag: | Donald Trump |
Filter
-
White House holds press briefing
Watch live coverage as White House Press Secretary Karine Jean-Pierre holds a press briefing.NBC News - Top stories -
Trump trial: Hope Hicks faces her ex-boss on 'Access Hollywood' tape, Daniels payment
Follow the latest developments in former President Donald Trump's criminal hush money trial in New York.ABC News - Top stories - Donald Trump -
Burgum sidesteps question on political violence if Trump loses election
North Dakota Gov. Doug Burgum (R) dodged a question Sunday on whether he is concerned about political violence if former President Trump loses the presidential election in November. Co-host Jake Tapper pressed Burgum on "State of the Union" ...The Hill - Politics - Donald Trump -
States doing less to support press freedom: watchdog
Yahoo News - World -
Fox anchor pushes back on Mace's claim of George Soros funding student protests
Fox News anchor Neil Cavuto pushed back on a claim by Rep. Nancy Mace (R-S.C.) that progressive billionaire George Soros has funded groups involved in pro-Palestinian protests on college campuses. “There's a push right now on the part of some of ...The Hill - Politics -
Attacks on press freedom around the world are intensifying, index reveals
In the past year, in virtually every region, journalists and independent media outlets faced increasing repression. Political attacks on press freedom, including the detention of journalists, suppression of independent media outlets and widespread ...The Guardian - World -
Press Freedom Is Under Attack in Much of World, U.N. Ambassador Says
The detention of WSJ reporter Evan Gershkovich is called an example of increasing hostility toward an independent press.The Wall Street Journal - World -
A tornado hit an Oklahoma newsroom built in the 1920s. The damage isn’t stopping the presses
SULPHUR, Okla. — When Oklahoma and national officials held a press conference Monday to discuss the scale of devastation following tornadoes two days earlier, Kathy John did what she always does: She showed up to report on it for the town’s weekly ...NBC News - Top stories -
U.S. Presses Qatar on Hamas as Gaza Talks Come Down to the Wire
The U.S. has asked the Persian Gulf state of Qatar to expel Hamas’s political leadership if the group doesn’t agree to a Gaza cease-fire deal in high-stakes talks under way in Cairo, an official from the region said.The Wall Street Journal - World -
Trump trial to continue after vivid testimony from Stormy Daniels lawyer
Court hears that Keith Davidson texted National Enquirer editor on night of Trump’s 2016 victory to say ‘What have we done?’. Donald Trump’s Manhattan criminal trial enters its 11th day following raucous testimony about his increasingly unhinged ...The Guardian - World - Donald Trump
More from The Hill
-
RNC lawyer Charlie Spies resigns just 2 months after taking the job
Republican National Committee (RNC) head counsel Charlie Spies is leaving the role after just two months on the job, the RNC confirmed Sunday. Spies was “pushed out,” NBC News reported, citing a source familiar with the situation. "Charlie ...The Hill - Politics -
Trump spotted at Miami Formula One Grand Prix
Former President Trump attended the Formula One Miami Grand Prix on Sunday, spotted at Hard Rock Stadium. Photos from the event showed the GOP presidential candidate walking around the paddock, visiting the McLaren team garage and waving at ...The Hill - Politics - Donald Trump -
NYC Mayor Eric Adams defends police response to campus protests
New York City Mayor Eric Adams defended the actions taken by the NYPD in response to campus protests, in an interview Sunday. “We want to ensure we protect democracy and the right to protest,” Adams said in an interview on ABC News’s “This Week.” ...The Hill - Politics -
Here's how much the average American has in their retirement savings by age
While many Americans want to retire comfortably, it's a goal that may seem out of reach for some struggling to save due to the rising costs of housing and everyday expenses.The Hill - Politics -
Ole Miss opens conduct investigation after counterprotesters taunted Black woman
The University of Mississippi opened a conduct investigation Saturday into at least one student after a video went viral showing a group of students harassing a pro-Palestine protester on the campus last week. Chancellor Glenn Boyce said the ...The Hill - Politics