China won't rule out AI-controlled nuclear weapons
![China won't rule out AI-controlled nuclear weapons](https://thehill.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2024/06/china_nuclear_weapons_dongfeng_10012019_GettyImages-1172703513.jpg?w=900)
This month, the White House disclosed that China has rejected American proposals to limit the use of artificial intelligence for controlling the launch of nuclear weapons.
Beijing’s quick rejection, occurring in talks in Geneva in May between U.S. and Chinese officials, is a setback for Washington’s efforts to find areas of agreement with China. President Biden raised this issue with Xi Jinping in California last November and announced that AI was one of the areas where the two countries would hold further discussions.
Tarun Chhabra, director of technology at the National Security Council, revealed China’s rejection and said the White House will soon issue a memorandum on the use of AI by, among other federal agencies, the Department of Defense.
“Our position has been publicly clear for a very long time: We don’t think that autonomous systems should be getting near any decision to launch a nuclear weapon,” Chhabra declared. “That’s long-stated U.S. policy.”
“We think all countries around the world should sign up to that,” he added. “We think that makes a lot of sense to do.”
“Nobody wants to see AI-controlled nuclear weapons, right?” asked, Joe Wang, a National Security Council staffer at the Arlington-based Special Competitive Studies Project, which specializes in AI and emerging technologies. “Like, even the craziest dictator can probably agree.”
Whether Xi is the craziest dictator or not, it’s no surprise he is spurning any agreement on AI with America.
“The Chinese Communist Party has advocated nuclear arms control only for other nuclear powers,” Richard Fisher, Jr. of the International Assessment and Strategy Center told me this month. “For China, the [party] seeks nuclear arms superiority.”
“China is taking its nuclear arsenal to the next level by, among other things, marrying nuclear-tipped missiles to powerful artificial intelligence capabilities,” Brandon Weichert, author of “Winning Space: How America Remains a Superpower,” wrote to me this week.
“AI-controlled nukes would be far more devastating than your ordinary ones. The Chinese are behaving foolishly, though, because the chance for unintended consequences is high. Frankly, AI could easily lead to a nightmare scenario where China loses control of its nuclear weapons arsenal to a rabid artificial intelligence system.”
Will reality mirror fiction? Everyone remembers “WarGames,” the 1983 movie in which an American military computer, on its own, simulated an all-out Soviet attack and almost launched a U.S. counterstrike. In the “Terminator” franchise, a super AI network known as Skynet detonates nuclear weapons to eliminate humankind.
What is the real risk when machines make decisions?
The world almost ended in the early hours of Sept. 26, 1983, when Lt. Col. Stanislav Petrov was the duty officer at the Serpukhov-15 early-warning center south of Moscow. Successive alarms indicated that America had launched five Minuteman missiles from Montana toward the Soviet Union. More than 30 reliability checks in Serpukhov-15 confirmed the attack. Procedures required Petrov to authorize a retaliatory launch.
The Soviet officer, however, ignored procedure. “A feeling inside me told me something was wrong,” he said in an interview.
Petrov was right: Sensors aboard satellite Kosmos 1382 had misinterpreted sunlight bouncing off the tops of clouds as incoming American missiles.
His instinct — what Petrov later called “a funny feeling in my gut”— led him to the right decision. But an AI-controlled system in this situation would almost certainly have launched a first strike on America, which would have been followed by a retaliatory launch, which in turn would have been followed by additional Soviet attacks.
AI technology, if it had controlled the Soviet arsenal that day, would have resulted in the deaths of tens or hundreds of millions of people.
Russia, with its “Dead Hand,” or “Perimeter” system, has already put nuclear weapons under autonomous control. China’s refusal to discuss a ban on AI in these circumstances suggests that it, too, will employ AI for this purpose.
As Fisher told me, there is a “new nuclear arms race with China, Russia, North Korea and Iran.” The race will involve not only numbers of warheads, as it did in the Cold War, but also the automation of launch decisions.
The Chinese appear to believe that AI makes their nuclear arsenal more fearsome. If they do adopt this view, they will be right. For instance, decapitation strikes by adversaries would no longer make sense, because killing China’s national leaders could lead to an automated nuclear strike.
Moreover, China, which routinely has made threats to launch nuclear weapons first, could use AI to improve those initial attacks.
There is, unfortunately, more than an arms race going on here. China is preparing for war with the U.S.
“This war will involve strategic surprise,” Weichert wrote. “AI will help China determine when best to strike, where to strike and what weapons to strike with, perhaps nukes.”
Gordon G. Chang is the author of “The Coming Collapse of China” and “China Is Going to War.”
Date: | |
Tag: | China |
Filter
-
Yahoo News - World
Hezbollah has the weapons to carry out its threat against Cyprus
-
The Wall Street Journal - World
Tech Industry Wants to Lock Up Nuclear Power for AI
The largest tech companies are looking to buy nuclear power directly from plants, which could meet their huge needs but sap the grid of critical resources. -
The Hill - Politics
China is militarizing AI, and that's the AI threat we should worry about
Congress and the Biden administration are focusing on potential AI harms, while China is militarizing AI technology and seeking to access American data through technology companies, prompting the need for more funding for the FCC to remove Chinese ...China -
Inc. - Business
The Biggest Problem With Apple Intelligence Is That It Won't Run on the Best AI Device Ever Made
The Apple Watch is the perfect AI device form factor. It just won't be getting any of Apple's new features.Apple -
ABC News - World
China expels 2 former defense ministers from its ruling Communist Party over graft allegations
Chin has expelled two former defense ministers from the ruling Communist Party over accusations of corruption that are likely to lead to sentences of life in prisonChina -
The Wall Street Journal - World
Joe Biden and America's Out-of-Control Spooks
The president should step aside rather than find out how the deep state would save his candidacy.Joe Biden -
Financial Times - World
Germany’s AfD hopes for far-right victory in France
Alice Weidel says she has her ‘fingers crossed’ for Marine Le Pen despite strained ties between their parties -
NBC News - Politics
Trump speaks out after SCOTUS's immunity ruling: ‘Big win’
After the Supreme Court ruled that Donald Trump has immunity for his official acts while in office, the former president spoke out on his social media platform. “Big win for our constitution and democracy. Proud to be an American,” he posted.Donald Trump -
BBC News - Top stories
North Korea says it fired a new weapon - is it lying?
North Korea says it succeeded in testing a multiple warhead missile, but the South and others are not convinced.North Korea
More from The Hill
-
The Hill - Politics
Psaki defends debate prep team: 'Biden was bad'
MSNBC anchor Jen Psaki, who once served as President Biden's press secretary, defended his campaign amid criticism of the president's debate performance last week, instead pinning the blame on the president. Psaki said it is “absurd” to blame ...Joe Biden -
The Hill - Politics
Head of Trump PAC predicts 'cannibalistic chaos' if Dems replace Biden
The head of the primary super PAC supporting former President Trump said the potential replacement of President Biden as the Democratic Party’s presidential nominee would be “impossible” to carry out and essentially spell defeat for the party in ...Joe Biden -
The Hill - Politics
Doubts have grown over Biden's mental fitness: Poll
Voters' doubts about President Biden’s fitness to serve in the Oval Office have grown over the past few months, according to a new poll released Monday amid the fallout from his shaky debate performance last week. The latest Harvard CAPS-Harris ...Joe Biden -
The Hill - Politics
Trump lead over Biden unchanged since debate: Poll
Former President Trump’s lead over President Biden in national polling is unchanged following the debate between the candidates last week, according to a new survey. The Harvard CAPS/Harris poll released Monday, which was conducted after the ...Joe Biden -
The Hill - Politics
Luttig: Trump, other presidents now 'above the law'
Retired federal judge J. Michael Luttig said former President Trump and other U.S. presidents can now be considered "above the law" after the Supreme Court ruled Monday that core presidential powers are immune from prosecution. “It can never again ...Donald Trump