Canceling student debt may be legal but it’s theft
Despite a $34.0 trillion national debt, President Joseph Biden is planning on canceling some, or all, of $158 billion of student debt of an estimated 30 million persons. This may be good politics for the Democratic Party, but this debt cancelation is unfair to most Americans.
Maybe this debt forgiveness is unconstitutional because it is done by executive order rather than congressional action; the Supreme Court will have to make that decision. But even if the court determines that student debt cancelation is legal, it will still be unfair since it treats Americans in similar situations differently.
First, it is unfair to Americans who never went to college. Student debt is not really canceled, rather it is shifted to another group in American society as revenue lost by debt cancelation must be replaced by new taxes or increased borrowing. These new taxes and the burden of increased debt will fall on many persons who never had the opportunity of going to college. The mechanic in the local garage ends up paying for the college student who decided to major in mass media.
Second, it is unfair to students and families who made sacrifices to pay for college. There are many families that saved for college, that worked multiple jobs, that chose colleges based on affordability, and that carefully researched the best majors. They made these sacrifices and compromises to ensure that neither they nor their children would face a substantial debt burden after graduation. In retrospect, were they foolish? If only they had known that Biden would cancel college debt, they could have gone on annual vacations, bought a new car every other year, let their children choose any college regardless of the tuition expense, and study any major regardless of earning potential — no sacrifices would be necessary.
Third, it is unfair to enlisted veterans. When I enlisted near the end of the Vietnam War era, one of the motivations was to earn the GI bill to pay for college. In return for three years of active-duty service with the Marines, the GI bill paid for my Penn State degree. Although the original GI bill has gone through many revisions, its purpose is the same. It motivates smart young men and women to enlist. However, Biden’s college debt cancelation initiatives have the same effect as the GI bill without requiring military service. Do young people now believe that it was foolish to join the military to pay for college if the government was going to cancel college debt for everyone?
Fourth, it is unfair to persons who borrow for other reasons. Why only cancel the debt of college students who made bad choices in their college and major or were unlucky? Hundreds of thousands of young people borrow to create or expand small businesses which are major sources of innovation and employment in the U.S. economy. However, about half the time, due to either bad luck or poor management, these businesses fail leaving their owners in debt or bankrupt. Why do we bail out college students who make bad choices or are unlucky while not providing similar debt relief for young people whose businesses fail? Are young people who go to college more worthy than those who don’t?
Finally, it is unfair to future generations. It is unlikely that this will be a one-time debt forgiveness. People expect that Biden, or his White House successor, will propose extended or new student debt cancelations. This will lead to further increases in the already unsupportable national debt. Students and their parents will rationally respond to student debt cancelation in ways that lead to increased debt. The military services are currently struggling to recruit enough quality young men and women. Extended debt cancelation means that the current version of the GI bill will cease to motivate these men and women to enlist. The inequity of canceling student debt but no other types of debt will become more glaring. And, in the unlikely event that Biden can credibly commit that this is a one-time cancelation that won’t be repeated, why does this generation of students get their loans canceled while earlier and later generations are stuck with paying theirs?
Recipients of college debt forgiveness may argue that, even if canceling college debts is unfair, it is the government that is acting unjustly, not the beneficiaries of the cancelations. They are just taking advantage of the programs. In other words, these beneficiaries of debt cancelation are not themselves thieves but only receivers of stolen goods. And President Biden hopes that these receivers of what rightfully belongs to others will be so grateful that they will vote Democratic.
Frank R. Gunter is a Professor of Economics at Lehigh University. Views expressed are of the author, not the university. For better or worse, ChatGPT or equivalent was NOT used at any stage in the creation of this editorial.
Date: |
Topics
Filter
-
Zelensky cancels trips outside Ukraine amid new Russian offensive
Yahoo News - World - Ukraine -
Volodymyr Zelenskyy cancels foreign visits amid Russian offensive
Ukraine president’s decision to stay in Kyiv indicates growing concern over Moscow’s actions in Kharkiv regionFinancial Times - World - Ukraine -
Android Update: Theft Detection Lock Knows When Your Phone Is Stolen
Google is introducing new AI-powered safety tools in Android 15 that can lock down your phone if thieves nab it.Wired - Tech -
Google turns to AI to protect users from mobile phone thefts
Feature that automatically locks screen when device is snatched comes amid reports of rise in the crimeFinancial Times - World - Google -
Russia’s War on Ukraine Is Hitting Debt Costs for EU’s East
Yahoo News - World - Ukraine -
Bridgewater founder Dalio warns of danger of US debt on Treasury market
Billionaire investor has concerns about rising financial burden, global conflict and growing possibility of ‘civil war’Financial Times - Business -
China’s biggest banks launch first sales of special loss-absorbing debt
TLAC bonds are part of push from international regulators to shore up balance sheetsFinancial Times - Business - China -
Justice Department charges MIT brothers with $25 million crypto theft that took 12 seconds
The brothers plotted the "first-of-its-kind" cryptocurrency fraud involving Ethereum blockchain over several months, the DOJ said.CNBC - Business -
Everything you need to know about student loans
How do they work across the UK, what can I borrow and when do I have to start paying it back?BBC News - Top stories -
Biden administration extends key deadline for student loan forgiveness
Student loan borrowers hoping for a one-time payment count adjustment now have until June 30, after the U.S. Department of Education extended the deadline.CNBC - Business - Joe Biden
More from The Hill
-
Biden has become detached from economic reality
The vast majority of Americans recognize Bidenomics as a disaster for the nation.The Hill - Politics - Joe Biden -
Oversight delays Garland contempt hearing for members to attend Trump trial
The House Oversight Committee shuffled its schedule, bumping a hearing to hold Merrick Garland in contempt of Congress so some of its members could instead attend former President Trump's hush money trial. The panel was set to meet early Thursday, ...The Hill - Politics - Donald Trump -
Eric Adams says comment about migrants being ‘excellent swimmers’ based on past conversations with them
Talking about the city’s shortage of lifeguards, New York City Mayor Eric Adams said migrants could fill the openings because they are “excellent swimmers.” He later noted that his comment was based on past conversations with migrants. Adams was ...The Hill - Politics -
Dean Phillips says RFK Jr. should be included in Trump, Biden debates
Rep. Dean Phillips (D-Minn.) praised former President Trump and President Biden's decision to debate one another but said he thinks independent candidate Robert F. Kennedy Jr. should also be included. Asked by Fox News’s Bret Baier what he makes ...The Hill - Politics - Joe Biden -
Johnson defends decision to attend Trump trial, calling the case ‘an atrocity’
Speaker Mike Johnson (R-La.) defended his decision to attend former President Trump’s hush money trial in New York earlier this week, calling the case an “atrocity.” In an interview with NBC News, Johnson said he rode in the car with the former ...The Hill - Politics - Donald Trump