California's anti-Jewish education law needs to be thrown out
A group of Los Angeles Jewish parents, children and two schools were in court this week challenging a California law that explicitly bans religious schools from becoming state-certified special needs schools, all the while allowing other private schools the ability to apply for the same state-certification.
The consequences of this law have long been devastating, preventing the Jewish community from accessing the necessary funds to build and operate educational institutions that can meet the needs of its special-needs community.
But California’s unlawful exclusion has taken on greater urgency in recent months as allegations of rampant antisemitism have plagued California educational institutions from public schools to college campuses. Now, California’s rules put Jews in a damned-if-you-do, damned-if-you-don’t dilemma: You can’t have your own schools, and when you come to our schools, be prepared for an environment hostile to your Jewish identity and practices. California cannot allow this state of affairs to continue.
The core of the case against California, Loffman v. California Department of Education, is relatively straightforward. Under the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act, the federal government provides states with funds to support students with disabilities. But to remain eligible for those funds, each state must ensure that every child receives a “free appropriate public education.”
The problem with satisfying this requirement is that there are some children whose special needs cannot be met by the states' public schools. In such circumstances, the IDEA considers that states will place those special needs children — and, importantly, provide funds for tuition and disability-related services — in certified private schools that can meet the needs the state cannot. This is precisely what California does, with one exception: it bans religious schools from becoming certified special needs schools, even if they can satisfy all the relevant rules and meet the very needs the state cannot.
The impact of this discrimination has been two-fold. First, it has prevented religious schools, and, in turn, religious families, from annually accessing millions of dollars that could provide their special-needs children with an education to which they are lawfully entitled. Second, it has forced some of the parents in this case to keep their children in public schools that ignore their religious requirements. Allegations against the public schools include feeding the Jewish special needs children non-kosher food against the requests of the parents and accusing parents of neglecting their children because they kept them out of school for Jewish holidays.
On three occasions, the Supreme Court has emphasized that states cannot exclude religious institutions from government funding programs that are generally available to private schools. So, if California is willing to contract with private schools, it cannot exclude religious schools that are willing to follow all the same requirements.
California has tried every which way to re-describe its discriminatory exclusion, so as to extricate itself from its constitutional obligations. But even though a federal district court bought some of the state’s arguments this past August, the Supreme Court has repeatedly rejected these sorts of legal maneuvers.
Indeed, given the constitutional problems with California’s law, an avalanche of organizations has filed briefs supporting our Jewish parents, children and schools, including a friend-of-the-court brief filed by 22 other states, stating, “No matter how a government describes it, generally available funding cannot be withheld from schools just because they are religious.”
Amazingly, though, the picture has gotten even worse over the past six months. The war in Gaza has unleashed an explosion of antisemitic incidents across the country in public schools. Since October 7, the Department of Education has opened half-a-dozen investigations into California public school districts for antisemitism, including allegations of pervasive bullying and harassment. And these are only part of the wave of antisemitism investigations pending before the Department of Education, which also include allegations against many of California’s state-run universities.
In this way, it isn’t just that Jewish families are alleging that the public schools are ignoring their kosher needs and recasting Jewish holidays as forms of parental neglect; it is that their religious commitments are being ignored and twisted against a backdrop of antisemitic harassment and bullying.
Yet California persists. It excludes the Jewish community from vital programs necessary to build and operate special needs schools, and then refuses to do an adequate job integrating — or even protecting — Jewish children in public schools. In California, other communities have the luxury of either finding a place in the public school system, or when they can’t, operating their own schools in partnership with the state of California. For the Jewish community, California has chosen to provide neither.
California’s discriminatory policy is unlawful and shameful. And maybe once California’s Jews are allowed, like everyone else, to operate their own special-needs schools, the public schools will get a good look at what it means to provide an environment that their Jewish citizens, like all other citizens, deserve.
Michael Helfand is the Brenden Mann Foundation Chair in Law and Religion at Pepperdine Caruso School of Law. Florence Rogatz is a visiting professor at Yale Law School. Maury Litwack is CEO of Teach Coalition.
Date: | |
Tag: | California |
Topics
Filter
-
These California college students live in RVs to afford cost of education
"I don't feel homeless, but I am legally homeless," said one of the dozens of students at Cal Poly Humboldt who call an RV or other vehicle home.CBS News - Top stories - California -
California college students experiencing homelessness speak out
College can be stressful with studying and meeting deadlines, but some students are struggling with a different issue: housing. Federal data shows more than 1.5 million U.S. college students are homeless. CBS News producer Sarah Svoboda shows how ...CBS News - Top stories - California -
Nepal's top cricket star has his 8-year sentence for rape thrown out and is cleared of all charges
A high court in Nepal has overturned an eight-year prison sentence for rape for the country’s star cricket player and former captain of the national team, and cleared him of all chargesABC News - World -
Bill Gates: 'You need to read' this new book about AI and education
Bill Gates' latest book recommendation focuses on the future of artificial intelligence and AI. Here's why the Microsoft co-founder wants you to read it.CNBC - Business -
We need a ‘national tutoring corps’ to fix gaps in our children’s education before college
Flooding elementary schools with college-educated young people will also inspire the next generation of students with the possibilities of education.The Hill - Politics -
California bill that would have banned selling anti-aging skin products to young kids fails to advance
A bill in California that sought to ban the sale of anti-aging skin products to young kids failed to advance through the California State Assembly on Thursday. The bill, introduced by Assemblymember Alex Lee, prohibited kids under 13 from buying ...The Hill - Politics - California -
Xavi hits out at anti-Laporta chants: We're 'family'
Barcelona coach Xavi Hernández condemned the chanting against club president Joan Laporta during Sunday's 3-0 win over Rayo Vallecano at the Olympic Stadium.ESPN - Sports -
Need A PS5 Or Xbox For EA Sports College Football? Check Out These Great Deals
EA Sports College Football 25 is due to hit this summer, but that comes with a caveat for fans: It's not going to be available on older consoles or PC. So while you can preorder College Football 25 on PlayStation 5 and on Xbox Series X from Amazon ...GameSpot - Tech -
Business Education: Executive Education 2024
The FT’s latest rankings of custom and open-enrolment programmes. Plus: focus on AI; development for female leaders; managing multigenerational workforces; alternative providersFinancial Times - Business -
The plan for a new California city
A group backed by some of California's richest has purchased some 60,000 acres of farmland in Northern California, as part of an ambitious plan to build a brand-new, walkable city in the nation's most car-centric state, for as many as 400,000 ...CBS News - Top stories - California
More from The Hill
-
Colorado tackles discrimination in AI
Welcome to The Hill's Technology newsletter {beacon} Technology Technology The Big Story Colorado governor signs AI law Colorado will require developers of artificial intelligence (AI) to avoid discrimination in high-risk systems as part of a ...The Hill - Politics -
What is the ICC?
The International Criminal Court (ICC) was in the global spotlight Monday after its prosecutor requested arrest warrants for two Hamas leaders, along with Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and his defense minister, claiming the court has ...The Hill - Politics -
US lashes out after Israeli officials targeted with arrest warrants
U.S. officials went on the offensive Monday after the International Criminal Court (ICC) filed arrest warrants against two top Israeli leaders over the war in Gaza, a move that Congress and the White House slammed for equating Israel's conduct ...The Hill - Politics - Israel -
Evening Report — Prosecution rests after tough day on the stand for Michael Cohen
A quick recap of the day and what to look forward to tomorrow {beacon} Evening Report Monday, May 20 © Angela Weiss/Pool Photo via AP/Andres Kudacki Prosecution rests after a tough day on the stand for Michael Cohen Prosecutors for the ...The Hill - Politics -
FDIC chair says he'll resign once successor is confirmed
Federal Deposit Insurance Corp. (FDIC) Chair Martin Gruenberg announced Monday he will resign once his successor is confirmed by the Senate after several reports documented a culture of sexual harassment, misconduct and retaliation at the agency ...The Hill - Politics