Breaking Iran’s Axis of Resistance, one proxy at a time
This week Israel attacked Lebanon, Yemen, the West Bank and Gaza, but the real target was Tehran. Israel blames Iran for instigating the Hamas Oct. 7 attack last year and sponsoring Hezbollah, Houthi and Iraqi strikes into Israeli territory. Indeed, many in the United States and around the region attribute the Middle East’s instability to Iran and the so-called Axis of Resistance, the network of Iranian-allied militant groups and outcast governments.
Israel aims both to disable its enemies and to warn any and all that “there is nowhere in the Middle East Israel cannot reach.” But force alone is unlikely to break the Axis or neutralize Iran. Instead, military measures must come alongside diplomatic initiatives that draw these groups away from Iran’s orbit.
The Axis was key to Iran’s expanded influence in the Middle East over the last quarter century. Tehran, wary of confronting Israel or the U.S. directly, found ways to frustrate and disrupt its adversaries. Proxies came cheaply. With paltry subventions and a bit of ideological indoctrination, these acolytes could be trained in improvised weaponry and guerrilla tactics. Many fought and died in places where Iran feared to tread, such as the defense of the Assad regime in Syria. Meanwhile, Iran retained enough plausible deniability to escape recriminations and avoid escalation.
Israel’s attacks puncture this confidence — at least momentarily. Iran has fired ballistic missiles at Israel, but hints at reluctance to employ its own forces to defend its junior allies. Hezbollah, meanwhile, is staggering and Hamas is in hiding. But all these groups have managed to rebuild and recover after intensive bombing and military setbacks in the past. Maximum pressure, including decapitation strikes, has rarely proven sustainable or effective.
The military approach must come with efforts to counter the political inertia that makes the Axis spin. Thomas Schelling, the pioneering game theorist and strategic thinker, pointed out that the kind of proxy war which Iran is waging is rife with principal-agent problems. Iran is eager to transfer risk on its proxies. But are the proxies willing to do the principal's bidding?
Hamas, Hezbollah and the Houthis no doubt sympathize with Iran’s larger geostrategic vision, but their key interests are more parochial, and their politics are local. These groups share similar origin stories, emerging in periods of civil war and domestic strife, championing constituency like the Shi’is of Lebanon, the Zaydis of Yemen and the Palestinian people, that had suffered repression and exclusions. Their demands for representation and self-determination were ignored, both in the domestic arena and the larger international community. These groups were never just terror cells. Rather, they integrated fighting forces, political parties and social service organizations in one.
Iran slotted easily into the role of foreign sponsor, especially since these groups’ primary domestic antagonists were seen as American stooges. Hamas, Hezbollah and the Houthis each grew more robust with Iranian support, but also thuggish and politically uncompromising. Still, these groups also guarded their own autonomy, attempting to apply Iranian resources to their own pursuits.
There were frictions between serving Iran as sponsor, and meeting the demands of domestic constituencies for protection, representation and social support. Iranian support has cost these groups both in military exposure and in reputation. Some have tried a more independent line. Hamas, for instance, rebuffed Iran’s effort to enlist it in the Syria campaign in 2011. Yet, with no other foreign suitor available, reconciliation eventually ensued.
Proxy wars are hard to stop because sponsors shift the costs of battle to others, postponing the arrival of hurtful stalemate that could bring parties to negotiate.
An alternative approach is to focus on peeling away the proxies. If the people that currently back Hamas, the Houthis and Hezbollah see that their political demands for equitable representation and self-determination are achievable through a political process, Iran’s instigations will be less compelling.
The carnage of the Gaza war has diverted attention and energy from peace processes in other countries. United Nations-brokered plans for Yemen and Lebanon, which outline plans for inclusive political space that address the interests of these rejectionist groups, languish. Likewise, the urgent need for humanitarian ceasefires in Gaza have outstripped the issue of a large scale land-for-peace deal between Israelis and Palestinians.
Now is the time, while fighting is ongoing and the military momentum disfavors Iran, for the U.S. and its key regional partners, like Saudi Arabia, Turkey and the Emirates, to revive these discussions and offer real inducements for the Axis’s junior partners to set aside their proxy yokes.
Ariel I. Ahram is professor in the Virginia Tech School of Public and International Affairs and author of “War and Conflict in the Middle East and North Africa” (Polity, 2020). From 2017 to 2020 he was the primary investigator for the Proxy Wars Initiative, sponsored by the Carnegie Corporation of New York.
Date: | |
Tag: | Iran |
Topics
-
Lifestyle - The New York Times
A Welcome Break on ‘One of the Hardest Days’ of Her Life
Mary Kathryn Burke was ready for a drink after her mother was admitted to the hospital. Jonathan King messaged her at the right time.2 days ago -
World - The Guardian
‘Time stopped here on 7 October’: life in kibbutz that endured unimaginable loss one year ago
Nir Oz, a ‘paradise’ now inhabited by just two people, sustained the most damage and bloodshed per capita in Hamas attack. Post is no longer delivered to Nir Oz kibbutz; the lights in the mailroom ...2 days ago -
Top stories - NBC News
JD Vance addresses Melania Trump's comments on abortion
Trump to make appearance alongside one-time opponent Georgia Gov. Brian Kemp2 days ago - Abortion -
Sports - CBS Sports
Reds hire Terry Francona as manager one year after two-time World Series champ stepped down from Guardians
Francona played for the Reds in 19872 days ago - MLB -
Tech - GameSpot
Documentary Shows Stalker 2 Is "An Element Of Resistance" Amid Russian Invasion Of Ukraine
When Russia invaded Ukraine on February 24, 2022, it threw the entire country into chaos. Missiles fell on Ukrainian cities and Russian soldiers pushed over its borders. For developers at Ukrainian ...3 days ago - Ukraine -
Top stories - BBC News
PSNI chief contradicts Sinn Féin prejudice claim over ex-press officer
Jon Boutcher said he did not want the police to get involved in a political 'tit-for-tat'.3 days ago -
Politics - The Hill
Defeating Iran's push for Armageddon
Iran's ballistic missile attack against Israel on the eve of Rosh Hashanah was a stark reminder of the growing nuclear threat in the Middle East, and Israel is preparing to respond with a strategic ...3 days ago - Iran -
World - Financial Times
Pension tax breaks: what’s in the Budget firing line?
Analysts lay out the range of options at the chancellor’s disposal as Starmer warns of ‘decisions’ on the horizon2 days ago
More from The Hill
-
Politics - The Hill
Trump says he needs a ‘mandate’ victory from country in presidential race
Former President Trump said he needs a “mandate” from the American electorate this year as Election Day is just under a month away. Trump said at a rally in Juneau, Wis., on Sunday that he needs ...46 minutes ago - Donald Trump -
Politics - The Hill
Harris is pressed on support for Netanyahu in '60 Minutes' preview
Vice President Harris was pressed on the U.S.’s support for Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu in an upcoming interview on CBS News’s “60 Minutes.” “We supply Israel with billions of dollars ...1 hour ago - Israel -
Politics - The Hill
Threat to Florida's west coast increased with Hurricane Milton
Milton strengthened from a tropical storm into a hurricane on Sunday, increasing the threat to Florida's west coast, according to the National Hurricane Center (NHC). “While it is too soon to ...1 hour ago -
Politics - The Hill
GOP looks to avoid disaster in Nebraska Senate race
Republicans are looking to avoid a disaster in the Nebraska Senate race amid signs that an independent candidate could be giving Sen. Deb Fischer (R-Neb.) a run for her money. Independent Senate ...1 hour ago -
Politics - The Hill
Biden orders 500 more active-duty troops to North Carolina to aid in Helene recovery
President Biden ordered the Department of Defense to move an additional 500 active-duty troops into western North Carolina to aid in the recovery efforts following Hurricane Helene, the White House ...1 hour ago - Joe Biden