Bipartisan report urges rethink of America’s Russia strategy
The bipartisan committee charged with supporting democracy and human rights in post-Soviet states is pushing for the United States to dump the post-Cold War status quo in its relations with Russia and label Moscow as a “persistent” threat to global security.
The report from the Helsinki Commission, which was obtained by The Hill ahead of publication, argues that Washington must reframe its thinking in how it approaches Russia, as it has with China over the past few years, and allocate resources accordingly.
A priority focus of the report’s strategy is to ensure Ukraine’s victory in its defensive war against Russia, calling for “massive” military and humanitarian assistance for Kyiv and allowing Ukraine’s armed forces to strike deep into Russia with U.S. provided weapons.
The report’s policy proposals go further than the Biden administration’s commitments to Ukraine and clash with positions held by former President Trump, the Republican presidential nominee, and his allies in Congress.
Trump has long argued the U.S. is spending too much on European security. And he is campaigning on making a deal between Ukraine and Russia through direct negotiations with their leaders, including Russian President Vladimir Putin.
However, the Helsinki committee’s Republican chair, Rep. Joe Wilson (S.C.), dismissed the potential of Trump striking a deal with Putin.
“No question to me that Donald Trump is going to see the insincerity of war criminal Putin,” Wilson told The Hill in a brief conversation about the report.
“Putin is not anybody that you can reach an agreement with, that would be substantive, that would hold.”
Vice President Harris, the Democratic presidential nominee, has largely outlined a continuation of President Biden’s policy for Ukraine. Ukraine hawks in both parties say the administration has been too slow in supplying Kyiv with the weapons it needs to repel Russia.
But while the presidential race will surely factor into U.S. policy toward Ukraine and Russia in the years ahead, attitudes in Congress will also be crucial to setting priorities globally.
Even as there is growing opposition to providing military and economic support to Ukraine in the Republican Party, GOP leaders focused on foreign policy are largely bullish on supporting Ukraine, ensuring commitments to NATO and bolstering democracy in post-Soviet states.
This includes Wilson, but also the chair of the House Foreign Affairs Committee, Rep. Michael McCaul (R-Texas); chair of the House Select Committee on Intelligence, Mike Turner (R-Ohio); Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell (R-Ky); and ranking member of the Senate Foreign Relations Committee James E. Risch (R-Idaho), to name a few.
These lawmakers are likely to embrace the report's conclusions that “the United States must prepare for long-term contestation, understanding that Russia has a centuries-long history of violent imperialism toward its neighbors, Europe, and the world more broadly.”
The conclusions seem obvious given the scope of Moscow’s violations of international laws and norms: seizing Crimea and occupying the Donbas in 2014; the full-scale invasion of Ukraine in 2022; its invasion and occupation of Georgia in 2008; the Kremlin’s attack on political dissidents at home and abroad; its interference in U.S. and other democratic elections; the ransoming of Americans jailed in Russia.
Yet foreign policy orthodoxy changes slowly, and the prevailing wisdom since the end of the Cold War has been that cooperation with Russia and economic incentives would moderate its behavior. The Helsinki report seeks to bury that thinking.
“I think the fundamental message is that we are breaking from 30 years of flawed policy,” said a congressional aid familiar with the report.
“One doesn't need to look far to see that every single president within the first few months of their administration, goes and meets with Putin.”
The U.S. and its allies in Europe are still figuring out how to deal with Russia more than 2 1/2 years since it launched its full-scale invasion of Ukraine. The Biden administration has generally shunned Russia diplomatically and sought to isolate it economically while maintaining some channels of communication to avoid escalations and deal with issues of mutual interest, such as negotiations to free prisoners.
Some Republicans, frustrated by nearly three years of war and some $175 billion in U.S. support, have called for the U.S. to directly intervene in negotiations to end the war. And they warn against dismissing Russia’s nuclear threats as Ukraine takes the fight across the border.
The Biden administration has delivered military support to Ukraine in small increments as a way to probe Russia’s redlines and guard against triggering Putin to follow through on his threats to deploy nuclear weapons.
But Trump-aligned isolationists don’t want the U.S. involved at all. In an op-ed by former independent presidential contender-turned-Trump supporter Robert F. Kennedy Jr. and Donald Trump Jr., the two argue that direct negotiations with Putin will end the war in Ukraine and “prevent nuclear devastation.”
The Ukrainians and Kyiv’s most stalwart supporters have criticized this line of thinking, saying that Ukraine has repeatedly crossed what Russia has laid out as their “red lines” without spurring nuclear war.
They further argue that Putin is a disingenuous negotiator and any deal that concedes Ukrainian territory to Russia will embolden the Russian leader to relaunch an expansionist war in Ukraine, further pursue aggression in neighboring, post-Soviet states and potentially attack NATO member states in which Moscow is already carrying out hybrid-warfare.
The Helsinki report’s recommendations are that Russia’s nuclear saber-rattling “cannot simply be dismissed” but that the solution to this brinkmanship is to address it with “sound reasoning.”
“We can't let fear dominate how we think about this kind of stuff,” the congressional aide explained about the report’s recommendations — calling for laying out a plan to address and respond to possible nuclear threats and attacks.
The report wants to shift Washington’s thinking away from viewing Russia as a superpower and near-peer of the U.S. just because it holds nuclear weapons.
And overall, the report argues for a U.S. that is fully engaged with allies across the world, in particular those countries on the front lines of Russian efforts at aggression, manipulation and coercion — an argument that pushes back against growing trends of isolationism, particularly in the GOP.
This includes calls for increased military support, economic investment, development support and focus on soft power such as education and people-to-people exchanges. The U.S. should have a long-term strategy to support democratic governance and rule of law in countries vulnerable to threats from Russia, the report states.
“Through persistent efforts geared towards fostering prosperity and democracy and countering Russia’s authoritarian influence, we can minimize Russia’s ability to threaten free societies,” the report states.
“This report will provide a roadmap for minimizing and containing Russia’s destructive behavior until the emergence of internal forces necessary to fundamentally change Russia emerge.”
Date: | |
Tag: | Russia |
Topics
-
Financial Times - World
Trump’s miracle cure for America
Former president’s tariff agenda is more like a poison pill for the very voters he seeks to charm20 hours ago - Donald Trump -
Inc. - Business
This Brilliant Growth Strategy Makes Everyone a Sales Rep
Urban Skin RX founder Rachel Roff has found innovative ways to turn everyone, from celebrities to her receptionist, into a sales rep. Here's how she does it.3 days ago -
Financial Times - Business
America’s gridlock election: ‘they are fighting for inches’
With just over a month until polling day, the race between Harris and Trump is too close to call. Is there anything that could shift voters’ views?19 hours ago -
The New York Times - Top stories
The True Costs of America’s Gun Obsession
It’s not just murders and mass shootings. Guns play a role in many of the country’s biggest problems.4 hours ago -
The Hill - Politics
Bipartisan border bill would help the economy, bring migrants into the workforce
Gradually opening possibilities for more authorized immigrant workers to fill holes in the labor market ultimately serves American citizens.Yesterday -
The Hill - Politics
On immigration, Harris needs to broker a border deal and revive bipartisan consensus
Vice President Harris has proposed a plan to streamline legal immigration and address the border crisis, while the Trump campaign and MAGA allies have proposed over 200 proposals to choke off ...19 hours ago -
Politico - Politics
House clears bipartisan spending patch, punting fights into December
2 days ago -
ABC News - World
AP Week in Pictures: Latin America and Caribbean
Sept. 20-26, 2024 Rio de Janeiro hosted its annual rock music festival. Mexicans protested on the 10th anniversary of the disappearance of 43 students. Argentina’s poverty rate jumped to 53% and ...Yesterday -
The Guardian - World
Anti-immigration mood sweeping EU threatens its new asylum strategy
The bloc’s migration pact, finally agreed after a decade of talks, is already in peril as states outdo each other in efforts to get tough. In 2015, when more than 1.3 million people headed to ...Yesterday - European Union
More from The Hill
-
The Hill - Politics
Campaign says Robinson in 'good spirits' after being hospitalized, treated for burns
North Carolina Lt. Gov Mark Robinson (R) was hospitalized and treated for burns Friday after a campaign incident, according to the gubernatorial candidate's campaign. “This evening following an ...1 hour ago -
The Hill - Politics
DNC to run mobile ads highlighting Trump-Robinson ties during NC football games
North Carolina Democrats plan to use college football games to remind the Tar Heel State of former President Trump’s affiliation with Republican gubernatorial candidate Mark Robinson. ...1 hour ago -
The Hill - Politics
Stop letting our schools cover up deadly hazing practices
To end hazing for good, it’s time for the institutions that permit and perpetuate toxic hazing culture to come clean.1 hour ago -
The Hill - Politics
Hezbollah confirms chief killed in Israeli strike on Beirut
Hezbollah confirmed Saturday that the Lebanese militant group's leader, Hassan Nasrallah, was killed in a deadly strike in Beirut and pledged that it will continue its fight against Israel. Israel ...1 hour ago - Israel -
The Hill - Politics
Harris, Walz to take Pennsylvania bus tour
Vice President Harris and her running mate, Minnesota Gov. Tim Walz (D), are set to take a bus tour through central Pennsylvania next week, her campaign announced Saturday. The visit Wednesday to ...2 hours ago - Kamala Harris