Biden’s last-minute family pardons are indefensible
In one of his last official acts, former President Joe Biden gave us a pardon-palooza on Monday. He issued protective, or “preemptive,” pardons for Dr. Anthony Fauci and Gen. Mark A. Milley, and amnesty for members of Congress who served on the Jan. 6 select committee, their staff and D.C. and U.S. Capitol police officers who testified before the committee.
Then, to the dismay of pretty much everyone, he pardoned five family members, including his brother James B. Biden and his wife, Sara Jones Biden; his sister, Valerie Biden Owens and her husband, John T. Owens; and his brother, Francis W. Biden.
The Fauci, Milley and Jan. 6 pardons are reasonable and predictable. The White House has signaled for weeks that they might be coming. As with the Hunter Biden pardon, these responded to what is unprecedented in American history: a winning presidential candidate running on a platform of promising to use the Justice Department, and the powers of the Oval Office in general, to take revenge on his perceived enemies.
Hunter Biden had already undergone criminal investigation by a U.S. Attorney in Delaware on President Trump’s watch during his first term. After his father became president, Attorney General Merrick Garland named a special counsel to pick up that probe, which produced indictments in two jurisdictions, one jury verdict and one guilty plea. Prosecutors determined that the most serious crimes they could prove beyond a reasonable doubt were the illegal non-payment of taxes (later repaid with interest), lying on a gun application about his drug addiction and criminally owning the gun for a few days afterwards.
The president’s pardon of his son recognized that any further investigation into Hunter Biden would amount to retributive harassment, as Trump’s own Justice Department had found nothing else to charge him with already. Given that these crimes occurred during his relapse into addiction after the tragic death of his brother Beau from brain cancer, and given that these relatively picayune charges would never have been brought against an ordinary defendant not the president's son, the younger Biden pardon also arguably qualified within the traditional, historical justification for pardons: mercy.
The other Biden family pardons, however, are far less defensible.
The family pardons are “for any nonviolent offenses against the United States which they may have committed or taken part of during the period of January 1, 2014, through the date of this pardon.” In an accompanying statement, Biden said that the family pardons derived from concerns about “baseless and politically motivated investigations wreak havoc on the lives, safety, and financial security of targeted individuals and their families.”
Biden acted well within Supreme Court and historical precedent in issuing pardons for crimes that had not yet been indicted or even investigated. President Gerald Ford famously pardoned President Richard Nixon for any crimes he may have committed while in office, without specifying any crimes in particular, even though Nixon had been under criminal investigation and an indictment was reportedly ready to go.
But beyond that, the family pardons are disturbing.
Biden was undoubtedly concerned that his brother James had been looped into the failed House Republican impeachment probe. Although Republicans found no impeachable conduct by Biden, the effort produced a recommendation to the Justice Department that James Biden be charged criminally for making false statements to Congress about the former president’s meeting with a business associate, Tony Bobulinski, while James and Hunter Biden were pursuing a deal with a Chinese company.
James Biden testified that his brother Joe never met Bobulinski. Congressional Republicans say that was a lie. Hunter Biden testified, “My dad went and shook hands with Tony,” and said that they talked about a relative of Bobulinski who had cancer. Bobulinski also reportedly produced text messages indicating that Joe Biden had joined him at a May 3, 2017 meeting at the Beverly Hills Hilton while he was in Los Angeles for a conference.
House Republicans also seized upon two interest-free loans that James Biden got from his brother — one for $40,000 and another for $200,000. Both were repaid, but Republicans found the lack of documentation fishy, especially as James received $200,000 from a health care company he worked with between his brother’s terms as vice president and president; the money came around the same time as the loan.
If James Biden committed perjury, that is serious business. If there were other crimes in this mix, they were not identified by Republicans in Congress.
Biden’s preemptive pardon to cover up for potential misconduct involving himself is a totally different ballgame from the others. It puts him in the company of Trump at the end of his first term. At that time, Trump was roundly assailed for pardoning such cronies as Michael Flynn, Paul Manafort and Roger Stone, who had been implicated in Special Counsel Robert Mueller’s investigation into Russian influence in the 2016 election — possibly to take away incentives for them to testify against him. Far worse, it paves the way for a future, criminally-minded criminal president to preemptively pardon people in his orbit who are willing to commit crimes for him, knowing the Supreme Court already immunized his own criminal conduct.
There is no publicly apparent reason for Biden’s pardon of the four other family members. But the fact that he protected his own while snubbing countless people involved in the Trump probes — other Jan. 6 committee witnesses, as well as the Manhattan judges, witnesses, jurors and their families who produced successful investigations and verdicts against Trump — is an insult to those who upheld the rule of law at their own risk.
The pardon power has always been susceptible to gross abuse. The Framers of the Constitution knew this, having witnessed the corruption of English kings. They included it in the Constitution anyway, on the theory that, as Alexander Hamilton argued, a president would use the power as the “dispenser of the mercy of government.”
That Biden ignored this central tenet of the pardon power in his waning moments as president is a sad footnote to an already faltering legacy.
Kimberly Wehle is author of the new book “Pardon Power: How the Pardon System Works — and Why.”
Topics
-
Top Republican blasts Raskin for Biden pardon
Politico - 2d -
Sanders says ‘don’t equate’ Trump, Biden pardons
Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-Vt.) said Americans should not be equating the pardons issued by President Trump and former President Biden. Sanders joined CNN’s “The Source” on Tuesday evening, where he ...The Hill - 13h -
Behind Biden's shocking family pardons
Former President Joe Biden issued preemptive pardons on the day he left office for some family members. Lawmakers and legal experts are questioning the moves. CBS News' Major Garrett reports.CBS News - 22h -
Thune on Jan. 6 pardons: 'Biden opened the door'
Senate Majority Leader John Thune (R-S.D.) said "Biden opened the door on this” when asked Tuesday about President Trump’s sweeping pardons of Jan. 6 protesters, including those convicted of ...The Hill - 1d -
Raskin knocks Trump pardons for Jan. 6 rioters after receiving Biden pardon
Rep. Jamie Raskin (D-Md.), a former member of the Jan. 6 committee, sought to distinguish between the pardon he received from former President Biden compared to those President Trump gave to those ...The Hill - 1d -
Trump: Biden family pardons make 'him look very guilty'
President Trump criticized former President Biden for pardoning several members of his family during his last moments as commander in chief, with Trump arguing the actions make “him look very ...The Hill - 1d -
Biden pardons family members in final minutes of presidency
President Joe Biden issued pardons to several close family members Monday in the final minutes of his presidency.ABC News - 1d -
Biden grants last-minute pardons to family and Trump critics
Before leaving office, President Biden issued a series of pardons to people who could be targeted with President-elect Donald Trump's return to the White House, including members of his family, Dr. ...CBS News - 1d -
CNN's John King: Biden's last-minute pardons of family 'unseemly'
CNN’s John King criticized former President Biden’s last-minute pardons of his family members on his way out of the White House as “unseemly” in remarks Monday. In voiceover commentary on CNN, the ...The Hill - 1d -
Pardoned Biden Family Members Were Targets of Republicans
The relatives who were granted clemency in the final minutes of Joseph R. Biden Jr.’s presidency had not been charged with wrongdoing, but some had drawn scrutiny.The New York Times - 1d -
Schiff calls Jan. 6 Biden pardons ‘unwise’
Sen. Adam Schiff (D-Calif.) called his preemptive pardon from former President Biden, announced Monday for all past members of the now-defunct House. Jan. 6 committee in the final moments of his ...The Hill - 1d -
Why Biden pardoned Milley, Fauci and family members before Trump took office
Former President Joe Biden issued a series of preemptive pardons to shield members of his family as well as Dr. Anthony Fauci, General Mark A. Milley and members of the House Jan. 6 committee and ...CBS News - 1d -
Biden issues pre-emptive pardons for members of his family in one of his final acts as president
Just minutes before he left office, Joe Biden announced a set of sweeping pre-emptive pardons for members of his family, including his two brothers and his sister, after some on the right suggested ...NBC News - 1d -
Biden pardons his family in final minutes in office
President Joe Biden previously had pardoned his son Hunter Biden, who had been convicted in a criminal gun case and pleaded guilty in a tax case.CNBC - 1d -
Biden pardons civil rights leader on last day
Garvey, one of the earliest internationally-known Black civil rights leaders, was convicted of mail fraud in 1923.ABC News - 1d -
Biden pardons family members and Trump foes in effort to guard against potential ‘revenge’
Decision by Biden comes after Trump warned of enemies list, including people who investigated Capitol attack. Donald Trump inauguration – live updates Joe Biden used the last day of his ...The Guardian - 1d -
Biden Pardons 5 Members of His Family in Final Minutes in Office
Mr. Biden emphasized that he did not believe his family did anything wrong, but he feared political attacks by Donald J. Trump.The New York Times - 1d -
Biden pardons family members minutes before Trump sworn in
Minutes before his term is set to end, Biden announced that he was pardoning several members of his family, including his brother James Biden, sister-in-law Sara Biden, sister Valerie Biden Owens, ...NBC News - 1d -
Trump responds to Biden’s last-minute pardons: ‘Disgraceful’
Donald Trump responds to the pardons Joe Biden issued in the last hours of his presidency in a text message to NBC’s Kristen Welker. “It is disgraceful. Many are guilty of major crimes,” he wrote.NBC News - 2d -
McCarthy on Biden pardons: 'It raises doubt on what they did'
Former Speaker Kevin McCarthy (R-Calif.) criticized President Biden's decision to pardon Anthony Fauci, Gen. Mark Milley, former Rep. Liz Cheney (R-Wy.) and other members of the House panel that ...The Hill - 2d -
Sen. John Thune reacts to Biden pardons, enacting Trump agenda
Sen. John Thune, the new Senate majority leader from South Dakota, joins TODAY to weigh in on the flurry of pardons issued by Joe Biden in the last hours of his presidency and how he plans to work ...NBC News - 2d -
Biden posthumously pardons Black nationalist Marcus Garvey
President Joe Biden has posthumously pardoned Black nationalist Marcus Garvey, who influenced Malcolm X and other Black civil rights leaders and was convicted of mail fraud in the 1920sABC News - 2d -
Biden posthumously pardons Black nationalist Marcus Garvey
WASHINGTON — President Joe Biden on Sunday posthumously pardoned Black nationalist Marcus Garvey, who influenced Malcolm X and other civil rights leaders and was convicted of mail fraud in the 1920s.NBC News - 2d -
Biden pardons 5, including late civil rights activist and Virginia Speaker
President Biden on Sunday announced pardons for five individuals, including multiple civil rights advocates, and commuted the sentences of two others. “America is a country built on the promise of ...The Hill - 3d -
Rebuffed by Biden, former Sen. Bob Menendez seeks a pardon from Trump
WASHINGTON — Allies of former Sen.NBC News - 4d -
Biden is expected to issue more pardons before leaving office on Monday
The timing of the clemency actions, should Biden decide to grant them, is likely to be during his final hours in office and could include preemptive pardons.NBC News - 4d -
Biden pardons nearly 2,500 nonviolent drug offenders
"With this action, I have now issued more individual pardons and commutations than any president in U.S. history," President Joe Biden wrote in his announcement Friday.ABC News - 5d -
Biden sets presidential pardons, commutations record with alost 2,500 more
President Biden says he's commuting the sentences of almost 2,500 people convicted of nonviolent drug offenses. That gives him the presidential record for most individual pardons and commutations ...CBS News - 5d -
Biden sets pardons and commutations record with new clemency for nonviolent drug offenders
The president said that with Friday's action he has "now issued more individual pardons and commutations than any president in U.S. history."NBC News - 5d -
Hunter Biden special counsel dings President Joe Biden over pardon
The Department of Justice is expected to release a final report Monday from the special counsel who charged Hunter Biden with gun and tax crimes before President Joe Biden pardoned his last ...NBC News - Jan. 14 -
Biden Says He’s Considering Pre-emptive Pardons For Trump’s Potential Targets
The president hasn’t yet decided what he will do, he said, acknowledging that the makeup of Trump’s new administration could influence his decision.The New York Times - Jan. 8 -
Biden says he hasn't decided on preemptive pardons for Trump critics
President Biden said in a new interview that he had not yet decided whether to issue preemptive pardons to critics of President-elect Trump, such as former Rep. Liz Cheney (R-Wyo.) or Anthony ...The Hill - Jan. 8 -
An Indefensible Decision Has Left the Giants Adrift
Owner John Mara was lost in a sea of contradictions as he tried to explain keeping Brian Daboll and Joe Schoen, a columnist for The Athletic writes.The New York Times - Jan. 7 -
President Biden Meets With Families of New Orleans Attack Victims
President Biden and the first lady joined a city already exhausted by disaster to remember the victims of a Jan. 1 terror attack on Bourbon Street.The New York Times - Jan. 7 -
Biden meets with families of victims of New Orleans attack
President Joe Biden and first lady Jill Biden met with families, survivors and local law enforcement affected by the New Year's Day attack in New Orleans that killed 14 people and wounded dozens of ...NBC News - Jan. 7 -
Biden Visits New Orleans Monday to Mourn With Grieving Families
Mr. Biden’s trip to New Orleans, his latest as “consoler in chief,” joins a lengthy history of presidential visits to a city that has seen more than its share of tragedies and disasters.The New York Times - Jan. 6 -
Last hope for Indian nurse on death row in Yemen: pardon from victim's family
Time is running out for Nimisha Priya, who was convicted for the murder of a Yemeni man in 2017.BBC News - Jan. 4 -
Climate group calls for Biden to pardon activists for museum demonstrations
An international climate advocacy organization called on President Biden to pardon four activists charged with felonies in connection with climate demonstrations before leaving office. Two of the ...The Hill - Jan. 3 -
Biden to travel to New Orleans to meet with families following terror attack
President Joe Biden and first lady Jill Biden will head to New Orleans on Monday, the site of a New Year's Day terror attack that killed 14 people and wounded dozens more, the White House announced ...NBC News - Jan. 3
More from The Hill
-
Trump threatens Russia with taxes, tariffs, sanctions if 'ridiculous' Ukraine war not ended
President Trump on Wednesday threatened to impose tariffs and sanctions on Russia if there is no deal to stop the fighting in Ukraine "soon." "I’m not looking to hurt Russia. I love the Russian ...The Hill - 17m -
3 possible explanations for Putin’s bravado
Does Russia’s president know that his “special military operation” against Ukraine has turned into disaster for Russia? Or does he really think that he’s winning?The Hill - 25m -
Oversight Dems seek out role protecting whistleblowers, IGs
House Oversight ranking member Rep. Gerry Connolly (D-Va.) encouraged agencies to protect whistleblowers and uphold inspector general independence — noting past interference under the first Trump ...The Hill - 34m -
Satisfaction with democracy ticks up from record low: Gallup
The number of Americans who are satisfied with how democracy is working in the U.S. has ticked up from record-low numbers recorded just a year ago, according to a new Gallup survey released on ...The Hill - 38m -
Trump Jr. on poll showing him top 2028 GOP candidate: ‘Don’t get me in trouble’
Donald Trump Jr., the adult son of President Trump, weighed in on a survey that showed him as a leading 2028 Republican presidential candidate, telling the crowd not to get him “in trouble.” Asked ...The Hill - 38m
More in Politics
-
Trump threatens Russia with taxes, tariffs, sanctions if 'ridiculous' Ukraine war not ended
President Trump on Wednesday threatened to impose tariffs and sanctions on Russia if there is no deal to stop the fighting in Ukraine "soon." "I’m not looking to hurt Russia. I love the Russian ...The Hill - 17m -
3 possible explanations for Putin’s bravado
Does Russia’s president know that his “special military operation” against Ukraine has turned into disaster for Russia? Or does he really think that he’s winning?The Hill - 25m -
Oversight Dems seek out role protecting whistleblowers, IGs
House Oversight ranking member Rep. Gerry Connolly (D-Va.) encouraged agencies to protect whistleblowers and uphold inspector general independence — noting past interference under the first Trump ...The Hill - 34m -
Satisfaction with democracy ticks up from record low: Gallup
The number of Americans who are satisfied with how democracy is working in the U.S. has ticked up from record-low numbers recorded just a year ago, according to a new Gallup survey released on ...The Hill - 38m -
Trump Jr. on poll showing him top 2028 GOP candidate: ‘Don’t get me in trouble’
Donald Trump Jr., the adult son of President Trump, weighed in on a survey that showed him as a leading 2028 Republican presidential candidate, telling the crowd not to get him “in trouble.” Asked ...The Hill - 38m