Biden is letting Israel and Ukraine call the shots
Secretary of State Antony Blinken recently wrote a long piece for “Foreign Affairs” arguing that the Biden administration has put the U.S. back on the map as the guardian of the rules-based international order. This is a theme President Joe Biden has run with since his first month in office, when he gave a speech extolling the U.S. as the “indispensable nation” and promising stronger American leadership abroad.
Yet for all the talk about reasserting its leadership in the world, the U.S. is often remarkably hesitant to exhibit those leadership qualities when dealing with friendly states. In what is one of the most blatant paradoxes in international relations today, the strongest country in the world frequently finds itself being led by smaller powers whose interests and agendas contrast with its own.
The U.S. is a superpower seemingly stripped of agency, and American policy on Israel and Ukraine demonstrates this well.
The U.S. has taken on the role of Israel’s big brother, ensuring the Israel Defense Forces has what it needs to defend itself and deepening its already strong intelligence partnership as Israel seeks to destroy the command structures of both Hamas and Hezbollah. Less than two weeks after the Oct. 7 attack, Biden traveled to Israel to show his personal support. Washington has sent Israel nearly $18 billion in military aid over the last year, which the Israeli military has used to prosecute its military campaigns in Gaza and Lebanon. At the United Nations, the U.S. vetoed three resolutions that sought an immediate cease-fire in the Gaza war.
But if Washington’s unconditional support was designed to give America influence to restrain Israeli policy, that gamble has not paid off, in large part because the U.S. has refused to use that leverage. As a result, Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has taken American aid but neglected to take American reservations seriously.
Although the U.S. managed to get Israel to allow some humanitarian aid into Gaza after it became clear that a massive catastrophe would ensue without it, this was a low bar. Netanyahu is executing his war strategy despite knowing full well that a regional war in the Middle East is the last thing the U.S. wants.
Israel has crossed so many of Washington’s “red lines” that one wonders whether the Biden administration was sincere about them to begin with.
American defense officials counseled Israel early on to take a discriminatory approach during its counterterrorism operations in Gaza; instead, Israel bombed the entire enclave into an uninhabitable wasteland. Biden warned that an Israeli invasion of Rafah was a personal red line for him; Israel invaded nonetheless. When Biden presented his three-phase Gaza cease-fire plan in May, he claimed Israel accepted it; months later, that proposal is all but dead thanks in part to Netanyahu’s additional demands. The U.S. repeatedly stated that it didn’t want to see the war extended to Lebanon; Israel invaded anyway. Last month, less than a day after the U.S. insisted Israel accept a three-week cease-fire with Hezbollah, Netanyahu ordered the assassination of Hassan Nasrallah, the militant group’s leader.
Through it all, American officials have conveyed their disapproval behind closed doors and leaked their frustrations to the media, but have otherwise done little to make Israel think twice. Weapons continue to flow, diplomatic support remains ironclad and whatever annoyances policymakers register are dismissed.
America has demonstrated a similar lack of leadership on Ukraine, even if it comes in a different context. Ever since Russia’s 2022 invasion, the American message has been consistent: Russian President Vladimir Putin can’t win the war and Washington and its allies in Europe will do all they can to ensure Ukraine will remain a sovereign, independent state.
American defense aid to Kyiv has reached more than $61 billion. The U.S. organized a multi-country sanctions regime against Russian oil at considerable risk to supply disruptions. After initial resistance, Washington provided the Ukrainians with the kind of weapons systems — F-16s, to name one — that treaty allies are lucky to get.
As with Israel, the U.S. seems all too comfortable outsourcing its foreign policy to Ukraine, a junior partner. Instead of spelling out reasonable, attainable objectives, American officials vocally perpetuate the delusion that Ukrainian forces will ever liberate all of their land from the Russian occupiers. Instead of conditioning Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky into accepting the compromises required to end the war diplomatically — even if they may include territorial concessions — the Biden administration equates those concessions to surrender. And rather than being brutally honest with Ukraine about the low odds of winning a war of attrition against a much larger power with greater manpower and resources, Washington avoids having a difficult conversation.
Leadership in the true sense of the word is all about sizing up benefits and costs, making hard choices and being brave enough to evolve when those choices aren’t working. With Israel, this translates into putting more conditionality into the relationship. With Ukraine, it means dropping the maximalist rhetoric and basing policy on a realistic assessment of what is and isn’t possible on the battlefield.
The U.S. prides itself as the world’s most powerful nation. It’s time for reality to catch up to the rhetoric.
Daniel R. DePetris is a fellow at Defense Priorities and a syndicated foreign affairs columnist for the Chicago Tribune.
Date: | |
Tag: | Joe Biden |
-
Top stories - BBC News
How much food is Israel letting into northern Gaza?
Israel has been accused of deliberately withholding food aid from people in northern Gaza.3 hours ago - Israel -
Top stories - The New York Times
Biden Announces $425 Million in Aid to Ukraine
President Biden spoke by telephone to President Volodymyr Zelensky of Ukraine about the security package, which includes munitions, armored vehicles and other weapons.23 hours ago - Joe Biden -
Top stories - NBC News
Biden heading to Berlin for talks on defense, trade and Ukraine
President Joe Biden left Washington for Germany early Thursday for talks on defense, trade and Ukraine.9 hours ago - Joe Biden -
Top stories - CBS News
IDF resumes strikes in Lebanon as U.S. warns Israel to let aid into Gaza
Israeli jets resumed strikes over Beirut's southern suburbs Wednesday morning amid warnings from the White House that Israel needs to increase the amount of aid entering Gaza or risk losing access ...Yesterday - Israel -
World - Yahoo News
Ukraine calls for international support in demining effort
10 hours ago - Ukraine -
World - ABC News
NATO shows no sign of letting Ukraine join soon and wants more details about its 'victory plan'
NATO is showing no sign it would be willing to invite Ukraine to join its ranks anytime soon16 hours ago - Ukraine -
World - The Guardian
Joe Biden set to visit Germany to discuss Ukraine and Middle East
US president likely to meet Chancellor Olaf Scholz within next week during rescheduled trip, say sources in Berlin. Joe Biden will visit Germany this week, government sources in Berlin said, after ...4 days ago - Joe Biden -
Politics - The Hill
Biden announces $425 million security aid package for Ukraine
President Biden on Wednesday discussed U.S. support for Ukraine in its defense against Russian aggression during a call with Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky and announced a new $425 million ...Yesterday - Joe Biden
More from The Hill
-
Politics - The Hill
Harris: Israeli killing of Sinwar an opportunity to end war in Gaza
Vice President Harris on Thursday praised Israel's killing of Hamas leader Yahya Sinwar, calling for it to be an opportunity for the Israel-Hamas war in Gaza to end after more than a year of ...24 minutes ago - Israel -
Politics - The Hill
Man pleads guilty to spraying wasp killer at police, assaulting journalists on Jan. 6
A 60-year-old New York man has pleaded guilty to assaulting police officers using a wasp-killer spray, as well as assaulting journalists during the Jan. 6, 2021, attack on the Capitol, the ...28 minutes ago -
Politics - The Hill
Trump calls CNN's Van Jones 'total sleazebag'
Former President Trump went on a rant against CNN commentator Van Jones, citing his efforts on criminal justice reform as the root of his dislike for the lawyer-turned-political analyst, and ...35 minutes ago - Donald Trump -
Politics - The Hill
Johnson: Slain Hamas leader's life was 'embodiment of evil and marked by hatred'
House Speaker Mike Johnson (R-La.) on Thursday marked the death of Hamas leader Yahya Sinwar by calling him "the embodiment of evil," adding his life was "marked by hatred for all that is good in ...37 minutes ago -
Politics - The Hill
Chris Cuomo to host NewsNation town hall with JD Vance
Sen. JD Vance (R-Ohio) is slated to participate in a town hall on cable channel NewsNation that will be moderated by anchor Chris Cuomo and streamed exclusively on the social platform X. The ...38 minutes ago