Before Elon Musk and DOGE, there was Jimmy Carter
The connection is not at all obvious between Jimmy Carter’s presidency and the investigation of the 2016 election that was sharply critical of the FBI’s role in it and how it may have wrongly harmed Donald Trump.
The official Department of Justice report that concluded that “that senior FBI employees would be willing to take official action to impact a presidential candidate’s electoral prospects to be deeply troubling and antithetical to the core values of the FBI and the Department of Justice.” And this report never would never have been issued, absent a Carter initiative — the Inspector General Act of 1978.
Through that law, Carter introduced a system that now includes 70 officials charged with reviewing the actions of specific agencies and issuing probing reports. There were, in other words, no inspectors general or “IGs” — including Justice Department IG Michael Horowitz — before Carter.
The idea that a department insider would be looking over the shoulders of employees and would routinely be critical should be appreciated as a deeply American innovation. One cannot imagine this happening in China, where it is certainly needed.
Yet thanks to Carter, Americans take for granted the idea that an outsider-insider observer should have access to the details of actions taken by departments to which they are assigned in order to “promote economy and efficiency” and ferret out “waste, fraud and abuse.” Recent IG reports found at Oversight.Gov include those on pandemic IRS tax credit fraud, the “performance challenges” of the Department of Homeland Security and such nitty-gritty reviews as that of travel expenses at the Nuclear Regulatory Commission.
Who knew that Carter anticipated Elon Musk and Vivek Ramaswamy?
The IG system, moreover, is just one example of Carter’s focus on the details of government operations — reflecting what is often derided as a technocrat’s belief that improved systems will improve government. It’s a world view associated with “goo-goos” — the good government progressives historically derided as naïve by big city bosses.
Carter was a goo-goo, to a fault, believing that specific policy areas should have their own Cabinet agencies, overlooking the likelihood that they would create more red tape and seek increasing roles (aka mission creep). That led to the departments of Energy and of Education — the latter now a Trump target, his having noticed that educational achievement has not improved since the advent of the department (although it does well measuring the decline).
But even goo-goos are right sometimes. Just as the Inspector General system was an important improvement, so too was Carter’s idea that it’s important to attract the capable and talented to key government leadership roles by paying them competitive salaries and ensuring their hiring based on merit. The result was the Senior Executive Service, established by the Civil Service Reform Act of 1978 to create a thin layer (some 8,000 today) of nonpolitical agency leaders charged with effectively implementing the ideas of the political appointees — not their own ideas but the ideas of those appointed by the president.
It is facile to describe such officials as creatures of the swamp. But a list of “SES” positions currently advertised on USA Jobs reminds us that there are a great many government roles for which the public expects and demands competent officials. They include Deputy Director of the National Transportation Safety Board; FEMA director for Washington, D.C.; Chief Artificial Intelligence Officer for the Department of Transportation and Chief Technology Officer for the Treasury’s Financial Crimes Enforcement Network.
There are other positions that might not seem as attractive, such as that of an IRS procurement officer. But even as the incoming administration readies as scalpel for the federal government, such positions remind us that there is actually little controversy about a great many government agencies — from airline and food safety to disaster response. Indeed, Americans tend to take their competence for granted.
Carter didn’t — and it was that concern that led to the Inspectors General and the Senior Executive Service.
It is altogether healthy for the country to debate which functions are appropriate for government. But it’s crucial to keep in mind that there are a great many functions about which there is no debate, nor should there be.
We want an FBI that can ferret out terrorists before they strike. We want an FAA that can keep the planes running on time. To the extent they do so — not always as well as they should — Jimmy Carter, whatever his flaws and limitations, deserves some credit.
Howard Husock is a senior fellow at the American Enterprise Institute.
Topics
-
Musk says DOGE might not be able to cut $2 trillion, actually
Politico - 9h -
Why Elon Musk had to drop his ‘DOGE’ pledge to cut $2 trillion from the federal budget
We told you he would months ago, when he made the promise.MarketWatch - 5h -
Musk: Cutting $2T through DOGE ‘best-case outcome’
Tesla CEO Elon Musk said Wednesday that the best-case scenario would be to make $2 trillion in cuts to federal spending through the "Department of Government Efficiency" (DOGE) he is co-leading. “I ...The Hill - 9h -
Elon Musk says DOGE probably won't find $2 trillion in federal budget cuts
Tech billionaire Elon Musk said Wednesday that his budget-cutting effort on behalf of President-elect Donald Trump would most likely not find $2 trillion in savings, backtracking on a goal he set ...NBC News - 17h -
Elon Musk's DOGE says it's hiring. Here are the jobs it wants to fill.
Elon Musk and Vivek Ramaswamy's Department of Government Efficiency says it's now hiring. Here's how to apply.CBS News - 1d -
Americans mourn Jimmy Carter in Georgia before his state funeral
Thousands of mourners honored the life of former President Jimmy Carter at the Carter Center in Atlanta on Monday. CBS News correspondent Skyler Henry reports.CBS News - 2d -
Public continues to pay respects to Jimmy Carter in Atlanta before former president lies in state
Former President Jimmy Carter is lying in repose for a final day at the Carter Center in Atlanta before moving to Washington D.C. to lie in state at the U.S. Capitol. CBS News correspondent Skyler ...CBS News - 3d -
Jimmy Carter lying in repose for final day in Atlanta before services move to Washington
Former President Jimmy Carter is lying in repose at the Carter Center in Atlanta for a final day before traveling to Washington, D.C., Tuesday where he will lie in state at the Capitol. CBS News' ...CBS News - 3d -
Is Elon a Musk-Have for Nigel Farage?
Reform’s former communications director is onBBC News - 4d
More from The Hill
-
Joe Rogan and Mel Gibson blast Newsom over fires: 'You've ruined this state'
Podcaster Joe Rogan and actor Mel Gibson blasted California Gov. Gavin Newsom (D) over recent wildfires in the Golden State. “In 2019, I think Newsom said, ‘You know, I’m gonna take care of the ...The Hill - 13m -
TikTok SCOTUS arguments
Welcome to The Hill's Technology newsletter {beacon} Technology Technology The Big Story TikTok's future hangs in balance at Supreme Court TikTok’s future will hang in the balance Friday when ...The Hill - 17m -
Biden pledges federal support in California for 180 days, well into Trump's term
President Biden on Thursday announced that the federal government will support California’s efforts to fight the raging wildfires for 180 days. “We’re doing literally everything we can at a federal ...The Hill - 20m -
Biden says intentional power outages to prevent more fires led to California water shortages
President Biden on Thursday said that intentional power outages in the Los Angeles area that were administered in order to prevent more fires from starting were partially to blame for water ...The Hill - 31m -
Trudeau: Trump talk of annexing Canada a distraction, won't happen
Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau said Thursday he thinks President-elect Trump’s public musings about annexing the neighbor to the north is a distraction from Trump’s threat to impose steep ...The Hill - 45m
More in Politics
-
Joe Rogan and Mel Gibson blast Newsom over fires: 'You've ruined this state'
Podcaster Joe Rogan and actor Mel Gibson blasted California Gov. Gavin Newsom (D) over recent wildfires in the Golden State. “In 2019, I think Newsom said, ‘You know, I’m gonna take care of the ...The Hill - 13m -
TikTok SCOTUS arguments
Welcome to The Hill's Technology newsletter {beacon} Technology Technology The Big Story TikTok's future hangs in balance at Supreme Court TikTok’s future will hang in the balance Friday when ...The Hill - 17m -
Biden pledges federal support in California for 180 days, well into Trump's term
President Biden on Thursday announced that the federal government will support California’s efforts to fight the raging wildfires for 180 days. “We’re doing literally everything we can at a federal ...The Hill - 20m -
Biden says intentional power outages to prevent more fires led to California water shortages
President Biden on Thursday said that intentional power outages in the Los Angeles area that were administered in order to prevent more fires from starting were partially to blame for water ...The Hill - 31m -
Trudeau: Trump talk of annexing Canada a distraction, won't happen
Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau said Thursday he thinks President-elect Trump’s public musings about annexing the neighbor to the north is a distraction from Trump’s threat to impose steep ...The Hill - 45m