Banning TikTok has nothing to do with the constitutional right to free speech
After President Biden signed a law that requires ByteDance, TikTok’s Chinese parent company, to divest from the app or face a ban in the United States, TikTok CEO Shou Chew vowed to fight in court. A spokesperson for the social media company said that the law is unconstitutional because it “would trample the free speech rights of 170 million Americans.”
This statement betrays a misunderstanding of rights in general and constitutional rights, such as the freedom of speech, in particular. For the most part, the rights enumerated in the Constitution are negative rights. Holders of negative rights are entitled to non-interference; if I have a negative right to something, others have an obligation to not take from me what I have a legitimate claim to.
For instance, the right to freedom of movement, as stated in Article 13 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, is an example of a negative right. The right to freedom of movement means that I am entitled to move freely from one country to another. But no one is obligated to assist me with my travel arrangements, nor am I owed travel accommodations of any sort.
On the other hand, holders of positive rights are entitled to provision of some good or service. That is, if I have a positive right to something, others have an obligation to give me what I have a legitimate claim to. For instance, the right to a nationality, as stated in Article 15 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, is an example of a positive right. The right to a nationality means that I am entitled to have a nationality. The country where I was born is obligated to provide it to me. I am owed a nationality.
Free speech, which is guaranteed by the First Amendment of the Constitution, is an example of a negative right. I am entitled to express myself freely, but no one is obligated to help me express myself. In particular, no one is obligated to give me a platform to express myself. I am not owed a column in The Hill, or any other news outlet for that matter.
That is why the argument that the law requiring ByteDance to divest from TikTok or face a ban violates “the free speech rights” of Americans is misguided. Even if TikTok ends up being banned in the U.S. because ByteDance refuses to divest from the social media app, it would not amount to a violation of the freedom of speech that is guaranteed to Americans by the Constitution. Freedom of speech is a negative right. The right to free speech does not mean that the federal government owes every American a platform from which to broadcast their speech. It simply means that the federal government should not interfere with Americans’ freedom to express themselves.
Having one less digital platform from which to express themselves would not suppress the free speech of Americans, as the social media company alleges. The Constitution gives Americans the freedom to speak freely without interference. It does not guarantee speaking engagements for Americans. As another social media company once said, freedom of speech is not freedom of reach.
Moti Mizrahi is a professor of philosophy at the Florida Institute of Technology in Melbourne, Florida.
Date: | |
Tag: | Tiktok |
Filter
-
TikTok Creators Sue U.S. Government Over Law That Could Ban the Platform
A group of eight content creators who rely on the social media app toreachcustomers and audiences challenge the law requiring Chinese parent ByteDance to sell its U.S. business or be banned.Inc. - Business - Tiktok -
TikTok creators sue U.S. government in a bid to stop potential ban
TikTok creators sued the U.S. government on Tuesday, alleging a new law that could ban the app violates their free speech rights under the 1st Amendment. The legislation is meant to force Chinese owner ByteDance to sell the service.Los Angeles Times - Entertainment - Tiktok -
Free agency: News, buzz and reports
The Lakers and Heat could be the top teams who pursue Mitchell if he doesn't sign an extension with the Cavs.ESPN - Sports -
Why Do People Make Music?
In a new study, researchers found universal features of songs across many cultures, suggesting that music evolved in our distant ancestors.The New York Times - Science -
Manhunt in France for gunmen who staged deadly ambush to free inmate
Yahoo News - World -
Faisal Islam: Is the US economy doing too well?
The US economic boom has consequences for the global balance of power - and for the UK.BBC News - Top stories -
When the customer is not always right
Demographics are squeezing Japan’s ability to deliver the same high levels of service as beforeFinancial Times - Business -
‘We have to do what we have to do’: Israel’s Netanyahu stands firm on Rafah offensive despite U.S. tensions
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu acknowledged tensions with historical ally the U.S. over the military operation in Rafah in the Gaza Strip.CNBC - Business - Israel -
Huge Amazon Book Sale - Free Kindle Unlimited Subscriptions, $2 Ebooks, Ereader Deals, And More
Amazon is running a huge book sale through May 20, giving you a chance to score physical and digital books for some of the lowest prices of the year. Along with books, you'll find a free 3-month trial to Kindle Unlimited, as well as a variety of ...GameSpot - Tech
More from The Hill
-
Biden has become detached from economic reality
The vast majority of Americans recognize Bidenomics as a disaster for the nation.The Hill - Politics - Joe Biden -
Oversight delays Garland contempt hearing for members to attend Trump trial
The House Oversight Committee shuffled its schedule, bumping a hearing to hold Merrick Garland in contempt of Congress so some of its members could instead attend former President Trump's hush money trial. The panel was set to meet early Thursday, ...The Hill - Politics - Donald Trump -
Eric Adams says comment about migrants being ‘excellent swimmers’ based on past conversations with them
Talking about the city’s shortage of lifeguards, New York City Mayor Eric Adams said migrants could fill the openings because they are “excellent swimmers.” He later noted that his comment was based on past conversations with migrants. Adams was ...The Hill - Politics -
Dean Phillips says RFK Jr. should be included in Trump, Biden debates
Rep. Dean Phillips (D-Minn.) praised former President Trump and President Biden's decision to debate one another but said he thinks independent candidate Robert F. Kennedy Jr. should also be included. Asked by Fox News’s Bret Baier what he makes ...The Hill - Politics - Joe Biden -
Johnson defends decision to attend Trump trial, calling the case ‘an atrocity’
Speaker Mike Johnson (R-La.) defended his decision to attend former President Trump’s hush money trial in New York earlier this week, calling the case an “atrocity.” In an interview with NBC News, Johnson said he rode in the car with the former ...The Hill - Politics - Donald Trump