Au pair program is a model for solving our child and elder care problems
America has a caregiver problem. Democrats and Republicans both want the federal government to do something to help families struggling to afford the high costs of child care and elder care. The question, however, is how to help.
How can the federal government expand the supply of child care in urban areas, where waiting lists are long, and in rural areas, where sparse populations make traditional day centers impractical? How can we provide assistance to seniors who need caregiving help without worsening deficits or straining existing underwater entitlement programs like Medicaid and Medicare — as Vice President Harris’s proposed elder care program would do?
The State Department’s successful au pair program provides a model for how policymakers could make it easier for families to engage live-in help.
Currently, the State Department facilitates live-in caregiving arrangements for people coming from outside of the country, who are between the ages of 18 and 26, as a cultural exchange program. Young foreign nationals spend a year or two in the U.S. living with an American family and providing that family with up to 45 hours of child care per week. In addition to room, board and other living expenses, host families pay au pairs about $1,800 a month.
Independent Women’s Forum’s Kristin Shapiro has persuasively argued that the State Department should expand the scope of this program so that America’s senior citizens can engage caregivers in a similar relationship. Seniors, who are even more likely than families with children to have a spare bedroom, could also host an au pair and provide room, board and payment in return for services like driving them to medical appointments, making meals, running errands, and performing other household chores.
Yet why should American caregivers of all ages be denied similar opportunities to get room and board as well as paid work?
The Department of Labor should explore creating a similar program for American citizens and residents who want to work as caregivers to find host families under similar terms. The Department of Labor could designate sponsoring organizations, as the State Department does, to oversee these relationships and protect the interests of both workers and host families.
Domestic caregivers would undergo similar vetting to ensure they are suitable and can safely live with families or the elderly. Host families or individuals would provide similar payments and in-kind support and follow similar rules for documenting hours worked to ensure caregivers have time off, are provided for, and are fairly compensated.
This may sound like a relationship that only wealthy families could afford, but given that regular day care for just one child can cost as much as $1,600 per month, families with multiple children may find such live-in domestic caregivers comparatively affordable. Additionally, this might appeal to working parents who would rather keep their child in their own home rather than at an off-site daycare facility, but cannot afford the $3,250, on average, monthly cost of hiring a nanny.
And it’s not just the families that would benefit from this option; caregivers would as well.
Fair Labor Standards Act regulations governing domestic workers can be burdensome and confusing. Employers are expected to document hours worked in a manner that’s difficult in the often gray world of caregiving, when a child may need five minutes of soothing in the middle of the night or help with a small task. The complexity of complying with regulations leads many families to engage babysitters or caregiving help outside of the official legal and regulatory context. That’s a risk for the employer, but also for workers who can end up without fair compensation or basic protections as well as no lasting employment relationship.
The American Caregiver program would create new options and opportunities for families and workers alike. Among those who might be interested in live-in work opportunities are recent legal immigrants who, like current State Department au pairs, would benefit from housing and help integrating into American culture.
It could also provide opportunities for higher education students to obtain housing and provide for themselves while working toward educational and other goals. Older women who are approaching retirement but feel financially insecure — a growing share of the population — may also be attracted to work opportunities that allow them to save on housing while preparing for retirement.
Congress has an opportunity to create a new paradigm for employment based on an existing, successful federal program. It would cost taxpayers close to nothing and create new, better, safer work opportunities for caregivers, while making it easier for families and seniors to get the help they need. This is an idea that should have bipartisan support.
Carrie Lukas is the president of Independent Women’s Forum. Heather Madden is the policy staff director at Independent Women’s Forum.
Date: |
Topics
-
Top stories - NBC News
Growing cost of elder care an increasing burden for families
The growing cost of elder care is putting an increasing burden on American families. NBC News' Christine Romans profiles one American family dealing with the financial and emotional burdens of ...4 days ago -
Sports - Yahoo Sports
Willy Adames could solve multiple Red Sox problems in free agency
If the Red Sox want to make a splash this offseason, veteran shortstop Willy Adames should be near the top of their list, writes John Tomase.6 days ago - MLB -
World - The Guardian
Cole Palmer cannot solve all of Chelsea’s problems, Enzo Maresca warns
‘We put all the pressure on his shoulders – that is wrong’ Blues face tricky run starting on Sunday at Liverpool Enzo Maresca warned his Chelsea players they cannot rely on Cole Palmer to “solve ...Yesterday -
Top stories - NBC News
Elder care costs are outpacing inflation. Americans want a lifeline.
A recent Kamala Harris campaign proposal targets at-home caregivers struggling with steep out-of-pocket expenses even as consumer prices finally stabilize.4 days ago -
World - The Guardian
Dining across the divide: ‘We have our problems in Scotland, but there’s more belief that society still exists’
One is a self-confessed Nicola Sturgeon fan girl; the other thinks the SNP turned into a personality cult around her. Were they more aligned on how to tackle drug deaths?. Ian, 43, Edinburgh . ...3 days ago -
Top stories - The New York Times
Man Whose Fentanyl Stash Killed Child at Day Care Gets 45-Year Sentence
Felix Herrera Garcia stepped over the boy’s body before fleeing the Bronx day care center, prosecutors said. The same kitchen utensils used for snacks were used to package drugs, they said.3 days ago -
Business - CNBC
S&P 500 eyes another record close — plus, our 2 health-care stocks that defied the group
Every weekday, the Investing Club releases the Homestretch; an actionable afternoon update just in time for the last hour of trading.2 days ago -
Politics - The Hill
How the Navy can solve its submarine shortage
The Navy must supplement its force with non-nuclear alternatives.2 days ago -
Tech - ABC News
October's supermoon pairs with a comet for a special nighttime spectacle
October's supermoon is the closest of the year and it's teaming up with a comet for a rare stargazing two-for-one4 days ago
More from The Hill
-
Politics - The Hill
Here's what to do if you lose an absentee ballot before Election Day
While misplacing a ballot can be stressful, there are still ways to make sure your vote is counted.53 minutes ago -
Politics - The Hill
Republicans head to court in expanding battle about overseas ballots
Overseas voting has become the latest battlefront in Republicans’ legal challenges leading up to the election. Judges in two crucial battleground states, Michigan and Pennsylvania, this week heard ...56 minutes ago - Republican Party -
Politics - The Hill
Lawler: Rhetoric about Trump-related fascism 'needs to stop'
Rep. Mike Lawler (R-N.Y.) said the rhetoric about former President Trump and fascism hurts other Republicans and “needs to stop.” Lawler joined CBS News's “Face the Nation” on Sunday morning to ...1 hour ago - Donald Trump -
Politics - The Hill
Michigan secretary of state says she expects election results to be certified day after Nov. 5
Michigan Secretary of State Jocelyn Benson (D) said she expects her state’s election results to be certified the day after the Nov. 5 general election. “In 2020 we had the results of our highest ...2 hours ago -
Politics - The Hill
Youngkin criticizes DOJ suit against Virginia: 'This is not a purge'
Virginia Gov. Glenn Youngkin (R) criticized a Department of Justice (DOJ) suit against his state over the purging of voter rolls Sunday. “To be clear, this is not a purge,” Youngkin said on “Fox ...2 hours ago
Latest in Politics
-
Politics - The Hill
Here's what to do if you lose an absentee ballot before Election Day
While misplacing a ballot can be stressful, there are still ways to make sure your vote is counted.53 minutes ago -
Politics - The Hill
Republicans head to court in expanding battle about overseas ballots
Overseas voting has become the latest battlefront in Republicans’ legal challenges leading up to the election. Judges in two crucial battleground states, Michigan and Pennsylvania, this week heard ...56 minutes ago - Republican Party -
Politics - NBC News
'What kind of country do we want to live in?' Harris asks congregation
During remarks at New Birth Missionary Baptist Church in Stonecrest, Ga., Vice President Kamala Harris encouraged congregants to vote.1 hour ago -
Politics - The Hill
Lawler: Rhetoric about Trump-related fascism 'needs to stop'
Rep. Mike Lawler (R-N.Y.) said the rhetoric about former President Trump and fascism hurts other Republicans and “needs to stop.” Lawler joined CBS News's “Face the Nation” on Sunday morning to ...1 hour ago - Donald Trump -
Politics - CBS News
Trump works drive-thru at Bucks County McDonald's before town hall in Lancaster
Former President Donald Trump is hosting a town hall in Lancaster Sunday night, and Vice President Kamala Harris will be back in Chester County on Monday.2 hours ago - Donald Trump