Arizona's top court hands victory to backers of open primary push
Arizona’s top court handed a victory Friday to backers of a ballot measure that would amend the state constitution to allow for open primaries, ruling that votes must be counted amid a dispute over signatures.
The ballot measure, Proposition 140, would create an open primary system in which registered voters can cast their ballot for the candidate of their liking, regardless of party affiliation. The top two finishers would then advance to the general election, even if they are from the same party.
Opponents of the measure, dubbed the “Make Arizona Elections Fair Act,” filed challenges, arguing the campaign had too many duplicate signatures and should never have qualified for the ballot.
While election officials found that nearly 40,000 signatures were indeed duplicates, they said the measure still had enough votes to qualify and that there was no legal way to stop the counting of votes once ballots were printed.
Arizona Supreme Court Chief Justice Ann A. Scott Timmer issued an order Friday upholding a trial court decision in September that the measure had enough signatures to move ahead, and dismissed the challenge from opponents.
Maricopa County Superior Court Judge Frank Moskowitz had initially turned down the request to hear evidence about the signatures. But Arizona’s Supreme Court overruled it and ordered Moskowitz to consider the evidence presented by the opponents of Proposition 140.
Arizona’s highest court said in the same order that if Moskowitz discovered enough faulty signatures that would disenfranchise the ballot measure, then election officials should not even count the votes for it. But amid pushback from Arizona Secretary of State Adrian Fontes, who argued that would disenfranchise voters, the high court reevaluated and reversed its decision.
Friday's ruling effectively upheld Moskowitz's decision last month.
“This Court is unable to find any rational or other basis for ‘double counting’ invalid signatures in this case,” Moskowitz said in the Sept. 19 ruling. “Applying the statutorily mandated ‘double counting’ of invalid signatures in this case would unreasonably hinder or restrict the Initiative and unreasonably supplant its purpose.”
Backers of Proposition 140 celebrated Friday’s decision, saying it was a step toward eliminating hyperpartisan primaries in Arizona.
“The Make Elections Fair Commitee is thrilled with our latest victory for Prop. 140 before the Supreme Court. 32 days from now we will celebrate again when all Arizonans are liberated from the grip of partisan primary elections. It’s time to move forward. It’s time for open primaries in Arizona,” said Sarah Smallhouse, the group's chair.
Opponents of the measure were upset by the ruling. Scot Mussi, the president of the Arizona Free Enterprise Club, suggested the proposition's backers intentionally delayed the review of signatures.
“Our organization proved that the special interest groups attempting to hijack Arizona’s elections systems lacked the minimum number to qualify for the ballot to even be considered by voters in November," Mussi said.
Date: | |
Tag: | US Open |
-
World - Yahoo News
Mexico Top Court to Consider Request to Review Judicial Reform
Yesterday -
Business - Financial Times
Fifa rules on player transfers break EU law, says top court
Verdict in favour of Lassana Diarra could disrupt multibillion-dollar transfer market that underpins European game9 hours ago - European Union -
World - ABC News
South Africa's top court will decide if impeachment proceedings against the president can be revived
South Africa’s Constitutional Court says it will hear a case next month brought by two opposition parties to revive impeachment proceedings against President Cyril RamaphosaYesterday -
Sports - ABC News
The European Union's top court says some FIFA rules on international transfers are contrary to EU law
The European Union's top court says some FIFA rules on international transfers are contrary to EU law14 hours ago -
Top stories - BBC News
Diarra v Fifa: Some transfer rules break EU law - top court
After a long-running dispute between ex-Chelsea and Arsenal midfielder Lassana Diarra and Fifa, a court has ruled against the governing body.7 hours ago - European Union -
Sports - ABC News
Landmark ruling from top EU court says some FIFA rules on transfers are contrary to EU law
The European Union’s top court says some FIFA rules on player transfers are contrary to EU legislation relating to competition and freedom of movement6 hours ago - European Union -
World - ABC News
EU fishing and farming deals with Morocco failed to include Western Sahara's consent, top court says
The European Union’s top court says fisheries and agriculture agreements reached between the bloc and Morocco five years ago failed to include consultations with the people of Western Sahara6 hours ago - European Union -
World - Financial Times
Displacement pushes Lebanon to the brink
Over 1mn people have fled their homes, adding to the economic crisis battering the countryYesterday
More from The Hill
-
Politics - The Hill
Most in new survey worried about election fraud in November
More than half of Americans are concerned about voter fraud in the November election, according to a PR/PBS News/Marist poll released Thursday. Fifty-eight percent of Americans say they are either ...48 minutes ago -
Politics - The Hill
South Carolina extends voter registration due to Hurricane Helene impact
South Carolina Judge Daniel Coble extended the voter registration deadline by eight days at a virtual hearing Friday due to Hurricane Helene. In-person, online and mail-in applications will now be ...1 hour ago -
Politics - The Hill
Bipartisan lawmakers urge Biden to seek release of Americans detained in China
Two congressmen asked President Biden to further advocate for the release of wrongfully detained Americans in China in a letter Friday. “American citizens are serving long prison terms in China; ...1 hour ago - Joe Biden -
Politics - The Hill
Iran's supreme leader makes rare speech after attacks on Israel
Iran's leader defended his country’s missile strikes on Israel this week, calling them “correct, logical, and lawful” in a rare public speech in Tehran on Friday. Ayatollah Ali Khamenei told a ...1 hour ago - Israel -
Politics - The Hill
Harris joined ‘Call Her Daddy’ podcast to talk abortion rights
Vice President Harris joined host Alex Cooper on her popular “Call Her Daddy” podcast for a discussion on reproductive rights, the campaign told The Hill. She sat Tuesday for the popular podcast ...2 hours ago - Abortion