America’s trade deficit isn’t about Trump or Biden — it’s about the WTO
As the 2024 election season heats up, America’s $785 billion trade deficit will be a hot topic. But while it’s easy to blame the Trump or Biden administrations, the real culprit is the World Trade Organization. This institution, designed to create a level playing field for international trade, has instead become an obstacle to improving our trade balance.
Since its inception, the WTO has tilted the scales against the U.S. Congress approved our entry into the WTO in 1994, and by 2000, our trade deficit had doubled as a percentage of GDP. Then, we made another fateful decision: granting China Permanent Normalized Trade Relations status upon its WTO admission. This exempted China from annual congressional review, with the expectation was that this would help reduce our trade deficits. Instead, our trade deficit surged another 40 percent before Donald Trump took office in 2017.
The WTO isn’t the sole reason for our deficits, but it’s the biggest one. We do need a rules-based mechanism for global trade, but the current system is far from equitable. The WTO’s flaws are glaring and persistent.
One of the most egregious issues is the self-declaration of “developing country” status, which allows nations to receive special trade benefits. There are no strict criteria for this designation, leading 80 percent of WTO members, including China — the world’s second-largest economy — to claim it. As a result, the U.S. is forced to grant trade concessions to China, even though they are our largest source of trade deficits. This makes no sense, especially when China’s per capita net-worth vastly outstrips that of genuinely developing nations like India.
Our negotiators agreed to these terms decades ago, but what might have made sense then is now deeply problematic. The U.S. ends up making permanent concessions to most other WTO members, which hampers our ability to negotiate bilateral trade agreements. Why would other nations bother negotiating when they already have a deal that favors them? This is why the U.S. has so few bilateral trade agreements compared to countries like Mexico, which has almost 100.
The WTO’s dispute resolution process is another area where the U.S. gets the short end of the stick. Panels are skewed toward countries with positive trade balances, not neutral adjudicators. The U.S. has been the defendant in a quarter of all WTO cases, and we’ve lost 90 percent of them. It’s ludicrous to suggest that the U.S., with the largest trade deficit, is somehow the biggest violator of international trade laws.
The treatment of Value Added Tax (VAT) is particularly troubling. Many countries rebate the full amount of VAT on exported goods, making them cheaper in the U.S. than in their home countries. Meanwhile, U.S. goods face VATs and tariffs abroad, pricing them out of foreign markets. When the U.S. tried to offset this imbalance with new tax rules, the WTO ruled against us, essentially telling us to change our entire tax system. By what authority does the WTO dictate U.S. tax policy?
Even when the WTO rules are clear, its enforcement is sluggish. The organization’s charter requires appellate decisions within 90 days, yet cases often drag on for years. The Boeing-Airbus subsidy case, for instance, took more than 17 years to resolve. Such delays render the dispute resolution process nearly useless, discouraging countries from even filing complaints.
The WTO’s shortcomings don’t end there. It fails to address critical issues like currency manipulation, intellectual property rights and barriers to service industries — all of which disproportionately affect the U.S.
Reforming the WTO should be a top priority, but this will only happen if the majority of members who benefit from the current structure are convinced that the alternative — a U.S. withdrawal — would be far worse. Trump has floated the idea of universal tariffs, which would likely force a U.S. exit from the WTO. For most WTO members, this would be catastrophic. The U.S., as the world’s largest importer, could inflict nearly a trillion dollars in damage on global trade — far more than what we would suffer.
Such a drastic move would be dangerous, but less so for us than for others. Critics cite the Smoot-Hawley tariffs as a precursor to the Great Depression, but they forget that the global depression began a year before those tariffs were enacted.
Trump has indicated a willingness to take a hard line on the WTO. Democratic nominee Kamala Harris has yet to detail her trade policies, but she would be wise to advocate for reforming the WTO. Addressing our trade deficit shouldn’t be a partisan issue; it’s a national imperative.
Wilbur Ross was secretary of Commerce under the Trump Administration from 2017-2021. He is the author of “Risks and Returns: Creating Success in Business and Life.”
Date: | |
Tag: | Joe Biden |
-
Politics - The Hill
Beshear: ‘It hurts’ to see Trump, Vance lie about election, natural disasters
Kentucky Gov. Andy Beshear (D) said in an interview Sunday that “it hurts” to see former President Trump and Sen. JD Vance (R-Ohio), the Republican vice presidential nominee, lie about the results ...Yesterday -
Politics - The Hill
Morning Report — Trump, Harris stir doubts about rival’s fitness
In today’s issue: There are three weeks to go in a presidential contest so close, the result will depend on whether former President Trump or Vice President Harris does the superior job of getting ...11 hours ago -
Top stories - CBS News
New details about arrest near Trump rally in California
Police on Saturday detained a man with two unregistered guns inside a security perimeter for a Trump rally in California. Federal investigators say Trump was not in danger during Saturday's event ...8 hours ago - California -
Top stories - CBS News
What we know about arrest near Trump rally in California
The Secret Service and FBI are investigating an arrest at a security checkpoint near a Trump rally in California over the weekend. The suspect was taken into custody without incident and was later ...7 hours ago - California -
Politics - The Hill
Carville: Trump 'lies about everything except … when he’s going to have a roundup'
Longtime Democratic strategist James Carville said Sunday that former President Trump “lies about everything,” but is telling the truth when he says he will round up his political opponents, if he ...9 hours ago - Donald Trump -
Politics - The Hill
Harris campaign unveils ad featuring ex-aides warning about 'danger' of Trump
Vice President Harris’s campaign on Monday unveiled a new ad that features former aides from President Trump’s administration, warning that another term with him in the White House would be ...1 hour ago - Donald Trump -
Sports - Yahoo Sports
Canadiens: Bergevin's Controversial Call About Jean Béliveau
Marc Bergevin's reign at the helm of the Montreal Canadiens had its ups and downs but one particular call was puzzling to say the least.Yesterday
More from The Hill
-
Politics - The Hill
Ocasio-Cortez criticizes Biden administration over 'unrestrained' Israel government
Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (D-N.Y.) criticized the Biden administration on Monday over what she called an “unrestrained” Israeli government. “The horrors unfolding in northern Gaza are the ...14 minutes ago - Joe Biden -
Politics - The Hill
Why US is sending troops, prized air defense system to Israel
The U.S. announced this week a major new air defense system for Israel, along with the deployment of 100 American troops to operate it in the country, in a development that will bolster Israeli ...20 minutes ago - Israel -
Politics - The Hill
Walz: Trump 'crossed a line' with threat to use military on ‘enemy from within’
Minnesota Gov. Tim Walz (D), the Democratic vice presidential nominee, said former President Trump “crossed a line” by saying he would use the National Guard or military to combat "the enemy ...22 minutes ago - Donald Trump -
Politics - The Hill
SBA disaster loan fund running low
Welcome to The Hill's Business & Economy newsletter {beacon} View Online Business & Economy Business & Economy The Big Story SBA disaster loan fund running low Congress is facing more pressure ...32 minutes ago -
Politics - The Hill
Watch live: Harris campaigns in Pennsylvania
Vice President Harris is scheduled to appear at a campaign event in Erie, Pa., Monday evening. Harris released an economic agenda for Black men early Monday, focusing on helping business owners, ...38 minutes ago