America’s shrinking military is a cultural crisis
![America’s shrinking military is a cultural crisis](https://thehill.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2024/07/GettyImages-1405842411-e1719954759960.jpg?w=900)
Last Thursday’s presidential debate covered a range of issues, but the future of the American military wasn’t one of them.
This might come as a surprise, given certain controversial proposals in the 2025 National Defense Authorization Act. If it becomes law, the document would require women to enroll in selective service and thus become eligible for a military draft. The Pentagon’s recruitment deficits, coupled with escalating tensions around the world, have breathed life into such legislation.
Although the White House is reluctant to embrace the Cold War label, that hasn’t stopped the highest-ranking Republican on the Senate Armed Services Committee, Sen. Roger Wicker (R-Miss.), from calling for a generational investment in defense. Despite the typical election year polarization, there is a consensus in Washington that America is in an exceptionally dangerous moment. There is less harmony, however, regarding what the nation should do about it.
Beyond coming to terms with our defense industrial challenges, the most fashionable idea is to throw more money at researching and developing the latest defense technologies or unmanned systems. These investments could offset the widening gap between America’s global security obligations and the number of humans willing and able to support them.
But some technological solutions face deepening investor skepticism, as the AI boom that appeared imminent now seems on the verge of busting. And even if these measures succeed in narrowing the “valley of death” between prototype and product, they will not answer the question of who will use these devices.
During the Cold War, contradictions between the demand for “warriors” to fill combat positions and tech-savvy troops who could operate the newest gadgets led to recruitment challenges. Segments of President Dwight Eisenhower’s Basic National Security Policy described this paradox in 1953. The problem, however, is more acute today.
The last time America’s active military was this small, President Franklin D. Roosevelt was running for a third term in 1940. These numbers are more startling when viewed as a percentage of the population. As the Cold War accelerated in 1955, there were 161 million people in the U.S. and 3.3 million active troops — about 2 percent of the population. Today there are 340 million Americans and 1.3 million active service members, or 0.4 percent of the population
Some view this contraction as evidence of the Defense Department’s inability to compete with the private sector for compensation. But these reductions are disproportionate across demographics such as gender, race and occupation, so the economic angle alone is an insufficient explanation.
Since 2013, male recruits have plummeted by 38 percent in the Army — the military’s largest service — as female numbers increased slightly during the same period. More than a decade after opening combat positions to women in 2013, men still fill the vast majority of these roles and account for 88 percent of the special operations community. A recent U.S. Army War College study found that America’s frontline troops are shouldering the heaviest burden. The Army, for instance, missed its enlisted infantry recruiting goal by more than 50 percent in 2022.
But gender isn’t the only factor contributing to the decline. The number of white recruits entering the army each year was almost halved between 2018 and 2023, plummeting from 44,000 to 25,000. Other racial demographics held steady. In a military that is 82 percent male and more than two-thirds white, the implications are troubling for frontline units training to withstand the type of 21st-century warfare Ukraine has endured.
There is plenty of blame to go around. Unpopular wars in the Middle East, the Pentagon’s “woke” controversies, a widespread obsession with technology that devalues human labor, poor oversight of government housing and the burdens imposed on military families have gotten headlines lately.
Most of these, though, are not viable explanations for the crisis because they are agnostic to race, gender and occupational specialty. Partisan political reasons are also inadequate, because the downward turn in recruitment was already present under the Trump administration.
Social scientists and historians have documented so-called “crises of masculinity” throughout American history, so the problem is not entirely new. Today’s crisis, however, happens to overlap with intensifying national security threats at a time when attrition and reconstitution are increasingly relevant to strategy. Defense analysts and public officials have danced around the problem for years, even while agreeing that the all-volunteer force is near a breaking point. But the curtain on that performance may be closing.
The sensitive nature of these issues makes them harder to investigate without prejudice toward potential solutions. European nations such as Latvia and Sweden have reinstated or expanded conscription to meet their security needs in the wake of Russia’s latest invasion. Even Germany is entertaining the idea. Despite online misinformation claiming otherwise, President Biden has refrained from commenting on the issue. His challenger, Donald Trump, shot down rumors of plans for a national service requirement earlier this year.
This reluctance aside, a swing in recruitment demographics could eventually force Congress to impose some form of national service, restructure the armed forces or reduce military support overseas at a time when America’s allies need it most. The congressional subcommittees for military personnel and readiness should probe the origins of this crisis and determine the most sensible option going forward.
No matter what President Biden signs into law this year, one thing seems certain: the era of kicking the problem down the road is coming to an end.
Maj. Michael P. Ferguson, U.S. Army, is a Ph.D. student at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill and coauthor of “The Military Legacy of Alexander the Great: Lessons for the Information Age.” His views as expressed here do not necessarily reflect official policies or positions of the Army or the Department of Defense.
Date: |
Filter
-
The New York Times - Top stories
Biden in Crisis
Why the next few days will be pivotal for his candidacy.Joe Biden -
CNBC - Business
China faces economic headwinds as it grapples with an aging — and shrinking — population
Birth rates are falling around the world as women choose to have children later, or not at all.China -
The New York Times - Top stories
Crisis? What Crisis? Biden Rejects Democratic Pessimism.
After last week’s devastating debate performance, the president’s prime-time interview with ABC News was an exercise in not just damage control but reality control.Joe Biden -
Inc. - Business
To Build a Better Company Culture, Accept That People Are Not Expendable Resources
In her new book, writer Samhita Mukhopadhyay breaks down the barriers businesses face to following through on DEI promises. -
ABC News - Entertainment
30th annual Essence Festival of Culture kicks off in New Orleans
The City of New Orleans welcomed thousands of people descending on the Big Easy for the 30th annual celebration of the Essence Festival of Culture -
The Guardian - World
Montella reaps rewards of embracing Turkey’s fan culture pandemonium
Unlike his predecessors, the Italian has the team leaning into their passionate side as fairytale run continues. A train grinds to a halt, mid-journey, in Bakirkoy, Istanbul, in front a giant screen. The conductor and passengers hold their breath, ... -
CBS News - Top stories
What to expect from 30th annual Essence Festival of Culture in New Orleans
The 30th annual Essence Festival of Culture is underway in New Orleans. Janet Jackson, Usher and Birdman are among the headliners with Vice President Kamala Harris also set to make an appearance. Hakeem Holmes, vice president of the festival, ... -
CBS News - Top stories
Support group helps male military spouses
"Macho Spouse" is looking to provide much-needed support and resources for male military spouses, helping them overcome isolation and build meaningful connections within the military community. -
Financial Times - Business
Democratic governors back Biden as crisis deepens
Discussions come as polls show sharp drop in support for US presidentJoe Biden
More from The Hill
-
The Hill - Politics
Here's how the process to replace Biden works if he withdraws
Amid rising pressure for President Biden to withdraw from the race, questions are looming over the mechanics of getting another Democrat on the ballot ahead of November. Democrats do have a path forward: The filing deadline for the party to get ...Joe Biden -
The Hill - Politics
Heritage faces blowback after 'bloodless' revolution comment
The Heritage Foundation and its president, Kevin Roberts, are facing blowback in the wake of his comment about an ongoing second American revolution that will “remain bloodless if the left allows it to be.” President Biden’s campaign jumped on the ... -
The Hill - Politics
Law schools left reeling after latest Supreme Court earthquakes
The Supreme Court isn't making it easy to be a law professor these days. After overturning the 40-year-old Chevron deference last week, the justices threw law curricula for another major loop on Monday with their earth-shaking ruling on ... -
The Hill - Politics
Democrats take aim at Supreme Court with eyes on November
Democrats are aiming their fire at the Supreme Court after this week’s monumental ruling that granted former President Trump broad immunity from criminal prosecution, hoping that a messaging blitz focused on the bench could turbocharge campaigns ... -
The Hill - Politics
Trans state legislators slam White House opposition to gender-affirming surgery for minors
A group of transgender and nonbinary state legislators sent a letter to the Biden administration criticizing its decision to oppose gender-affirming surgery for minors. In the letter, the lawmakers said transgender youth in America have been under ...