America needs a working-class White House
Our first and only Black president went to Harvard; if he had gone anywhere else, he may not have been elected. Similarly, if he had chosen a running mate who wasn’t a career politician — a highly visible, white male politician at that — he may not have won.
But that was then. Now, in the Kamala Harris-Tim Walz ticket, we’ve got a prosecutor and a football coach with nary a sprig of Ivy between them, running against two White men who attended the prestigious Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania and Yale Law School, respectively.
The accession of Harris and Walz to the nomination represents an opportunity for us to imagine a White House that could reflect the least of us.
“Far too long, our nation has encouraged only one path to success: a four-year college degree,” Harris told attendees at a recent rally in Wilkes-Barre, Pa. “Our nation needs to the recognize the value of other paths, additional paths, such as apprenticeships and professional programs.”
Harris’s personal choices reflect this common-sense wisdom of education as a tool to open the doors of opportunity, rather than as an exclusive invitation to access.
I find this both refreshing and potentially transformative. As a law professor, I have chosen to teach at schools that promise the opportunity of an education to students from the middle and working classes. My students are bright, engaging and hard-working. Many of them are first-generation college students and will be the first in their families to earn a law degree.
Although they sit in classrooms and are taught a curriculum that does not vary significantly from any other U.S. law school, they will be overlooked for summer internships at blue-chip law firms, jobs at prominent national public interest organizations, and the most coveted federal judicial clerkships, simply because the classrooms where they sit are not located in a law school that is Ivy or Ivy-adjacent.
Their chance of clerking for a Supreme Court justice is almost non-existent, as our justices seek clerkship candidates with Ivy League degrees. They see these types of degrees as proxies for excellence, indices of belonging to the group that gets to make the decisions for all of us, without including the least of us.
A president from a middle-class background who keeps the concerns of middle- and working-class people in the public conversation could change all of this.
Who might such a president appoint to the Supreme Court, and who might that new justice appoint as a clerk? Breaking this class barrier in a Supreme Court appointment could have widespread implications for a nation struggling with questions of identity — fundamentally what America should look like and what it means to be an American.
What might it mean to have a president who attended a Historically Black University as an undergraduate and law school at a state university? What might this signal to those of us who have achieved more than our parents and grandparents could have imagined, but who have been met with a ceiling from which creeps Ivy — invasive, toxic, choking out our voices, smothering our dreams, weaving a wall to block us from full participation in public life, even as its verdant green and hardiness promises new beginnings and access to power and influence?
Almost half of the Black Cabinet members to serve under a U.S. president, one-third of the politicians in the Congressional Black Caucus, and two of the three Black justices ever to serve on the U.S. Supreme Court have attended an Ivy League or other elite school for either an undergraduate, graduate, professional degree, or all three. Their work at these institutions bolsters the notion that Black people are only capable of leadership and public visibility at the highest levels of government when they have matriculated through the halls of White, elite power.
Many members of the Congressional Black Caucus attended Historically Black Colleges and Universities and state colleges and universities for one or more degrees. Their presence but lesser national visibility creates the perception that even though their constituents believed them to be enough, they are somehow less educated, less worthy when educated at schools that sheltered Black people in emancipation and beyond and that remain standing strong even through the blitzkriegs of the culture war.
Part of the excitement of the possibility of a Harris presidency comes from the fact that, even if she is not “just like us,” she is more like us than any other minoritized presidential candidate in recent history. Her presence signals to us that people educated at Historically Black Colleges and Universities and state colleges and universities might have a place as leaders and decision-makers at the highest levels of American government.
Harris's choice of running mate, a plain-spoken Minnesotan, former high school teacher and football coach, doubles down on that premise.
A successful Harris-Waltz ticket may not be the perfect solution to the problems that plague our nation, but it might just be the perfect pairing for this moment. A middle- or working-class White House means that America’s perception of itself as an inclusive nation made stronger by our differences is finally catching up to its reality, earnestly attempting to hold its disparate pieces together.
Teri A. McMurtry-Chubb is a professor of law at the University of Illinois Chicago and a Public Voices Fellow with The OpEd Project.
Date: |
-
Politics - The Hill
Watch live: White House holds press briefing
The White House is scheduled to hold its daily press briefing at 1:45 p.m. Monday. The briefing is likely to be dominated by questions about Hurricane Milton and the first anniversary of the Oct. ...22 hours ago -
Business - The Wall Street Journal
In America's Factories, Even the Robots Are Getting Less Work
Orders have fallen as labor shortages ease and production volumes slide.Yesterday -
Politics - The Hill
White House, Fox News's Peter Doocy spar over Helene response
White House press secretary Karine Jean-Pierre and Fox News reporter Peter Doocy sparred Monday over the Biden administration's response to the damage and destruction wrought by Hurricane Helene. ...18 hours ago -
Politics - The Hill
Morning Report — White House aspirants talk everywhere, all at once
In today’s issue: Vice President Harris today will appear on ABC’s “The View,” Howard Stern’s Sirius XM radio show and CBS’s “Late Show with Stephen Colbert,” seeking to expand her support among ...4 hours ago -
Top stories - CBS News
White House on Middle East conflict one year since Oct. 7 attacks
White House press secretary Karine Jean-Pierre weighed in on the one-year mark since the October 7, 2023, attacks in Israel and the growing conflict in the Middle East since the Israel-Hamas war ...19 hours ago -
Business - Financial Times
America’s hurricane wreck of an election
Almost anything could tip the result in what is essentially a toss-up between Harris and Trump3 hours ago -
Top stories - CBS News
Washington's princess: How Alice Roosevelt captivated America
On "60 Minutes: A Second Look," hear what it was about former first daughter Alice Roosevelt that captivated America.4 hours ago -
Top stories - BBC News
Gibbs-White, Konsa and Mainoo out for England
England trio Morgan Gibbs-White, Ezri Konsa and Kobbie Mainoo are ruled out of England's Nations League games in October.19 hours ago
More from The Hill
-
Politics - The Hill
Cook Political Report shifts Wisconsin Senate race toward GOP
The Cook Political Report on Tuesday shifted the Wisconsin Senate race from "lean Democrat" to "toss up," handing Republican Eric Hovde a boost as he tries to unseat Sen. Tammy Baldwin (D-Wis.). ...25 minutes ago -
Politics - The Hill
Harris slips in national survey, now leads Trump by 3 points
Vice President Harris has slipped slightly in new Reuters/Ipsos polling, now leading former President Trump among registered voters by a slim 3-point margin as Election Day draws closer. The poll, ...35 minutes ago - Donald Trump -
Politics - The Hill
Panera settles Charged Lemonade wrongful death lawsuit
Panera has since discontinued the beverage nationwide.38 minutes ago -
Politics - The Hill
Musk, Tucker Carlson break out in laughter over Harris assassination post
Conservative media pundit Tucker Carlson hosted tech mogul Elon Musk for an interview on his online video show this week, a sitdown that opened up with the two laughing about Musk's support for ...39 minutes ago -
Politics - The Hill
Listen live: Supreme Court considers 'ghost guns' regulations
The Supreme Court on Tuesday is considering whether federal law allows for the Biden administration's crack down on "ghost guns," or self-assembled weapons that are difficult to trace. The case ...42 minutes ago