‘America First’ must not put national security last

 As the White House attempts to drastically reshape the U.S. government, alarm bells are ringing for those of us whose careers have focused on America’s national security.

In the Trump administration’s zeal both to radically curtail the size of government and to pay back his perceived enemies, we fear that many of these efforts are undermining the very safety of the country.

This is not the government reform that is required — we would applaud such measures, as there is significant waste and redundancy in government that should be eliminated. Instead, this is taking a sledgehammer to government without any consideration for short or long-term effects to critical national security institutions that keep Americans safe. 

It was recently reported that the government demanded a list of probationary CIA officers sent over an unclassified server to the Office of Management and Budget. This is ostensibly part of the administration’s goal of reducing the size of government agencies, but many of us who saw the news thought the order must have come from a Chinese operative who had hacked the system.

While the names were reportedly sanitized to show only a first name and last initial, any decent intelligence program can connect the dots through social media, data leaks and other avenues to figure out who these individuals are. Many of these officers are conceivably a part of the CIA’s invigorated efforts against China, which intelligence experts agree is America’s most formidable geopolitical adversary.

If the reporting is correct, this email potentially compromised the safety of these junior officers, made them counterintelligence targets and wasted untold amounts of money the U.S. has invested in keeping their identities and activities secret. Congress should seek answers about how this could happen. 

Nearly as unsettling is the potential purge underway at the FBI, where thousands of special agents may be targeted for political firings, despite assurances from FBI Director Kash Patel that he would not permit political retribution at the bureau.

It is essential to point out the dangers that go beyond the obvious fact that losing a large number of federal law enforcement officers — many of whom with decades of experience and contacts — makes America less safe. But what becomes of these individuals is also deeply concerning from a counterintelligence perspective.

While FBI special agents are some of the most patriotic public servants, many will face economic pressures from losing their jobs leaving them as prime targets for foreign spies. Intelligence agencies like the Chinese are adept at commercial approaches — for example on LinkedIn — and use subtle methods of tradecraft that don’t turn someone fully into an agent but collect just enough information to make them useful.

Counterintelligence officials in the U.S. government are surely concerned about the potential for thousands of national security personnel to be summarily dismissed.

While the damage that a purge could do to the FBI is concerning, if one does commence, the confirmation of Tulsi Gabbard as the Director of National Intelligence has been discomforting, even if this damage will likely be harder to gauge. The position is extraordinarily important in its central role in coordinating sensitive intelligence, and our allies are almost certainly troubled that a partisan without the requisite experience is now in this job.

Gabbard’s views on Russia in particular are alarming and our allies are less likely to share their most sensitive intelligence regarding Russia with us as a result. Her previous visit to Syria to call on Bashar Assad also surely causes concern — let us not forget that the U.S. government reportedly ran a years-long security assistance program to help the Syrian opposition. And finally, her inability to condemn Edward Snowden as a traitor causes discomfort throughout the intelligence community.

Gabbard will be hard-pressed to win the respect of those she leads, given these multiple instances of behavior entirely inconsistent with U.S. national security.             

In the world of intelligence, human sources are the linchpin to understanding the plans and intentions of one’s adversaries. And our allies share a great deal of their own human intelligence collection with us, which has helped the U.S. to thwart terrorist attacks, catch spies in our midst and interdict nuclear proliferation networks. 

Responsible foreign intelligence services may now carefully scrutinize what they will share and how they share it and a track record of both reciprocity and protection of sources is essential.

How are our allies to trust that a DNI who has a track record of sympathy for some of the world’s worst dictators is someone they can trust with information when lives are on the line? It is a difficult but fair question to ask. Again, Gabbard must reassure our foreign allies that she is a trustworthy partner.

The U.S. suddenly becoming an unreliable ally doesn’t end in a flawed DNI pick or a mercurial and unpredictable president.

The world’s richest person, Elon Musk, is leading a cabal of young techies as they seemingly pillage some of the country’s most sensitive financial information in the Treasury system. These inexperienced youngsters are a foreign spy’s dream — no matter how tech-savvy they are — and a U.S. counterintelligence officer’s nightmare. Our allies surely watch this all with great alarm.

Finally, while the excesses of diversity, equity, and inclusion initiatives might have needed curbing, the blaming of seemingly all of society’s ills on this movement is counterproductive.

At the CIA, diversity isn’t about hitting metrics to show how multicultural and inclusive the agency is. It’s about taking a “best athlete” approach to using the right officer to obtain the intelligence that the agency needs. Sometimes that means theoretically utilizing a female case officer working in the Middle East wearing an abaya — to take advantage of cultural norms — to move about while drawing less attention.

An entire generation of young people is potentially being turned off by the government loudly saying that diversity doesn’t matter at all. Diversity is our greatest strength, even if Secretary of Defense Hegseth doesn’t think so.

For many of us, it’s the previously unthinkable behavior toward our allies that is most upsetting.

One hundred fifty-eight Canadians died in Afghanistan in a war that was started when America was attacked on 9/11, and which featured our northern neighbors immediately rallying to our side. As our president needlessly and seemingly gratuitously insults Canada by saying he will turn it into the 51st state, how many Canadians will rally to our side, should we need them again?

The same is true in Europe, where our allies of many decades shake their heads and marvel at the rhetoric coming from Trump about clearing Gaza for a U.S. takeover, which would make the U.S. an even bigger terrorist target than it already is.

The list of how we may be becoming less safe even after only four weeks of this administration continues. The gutting of USAID and the soft power benefits it brings, the defunding of the science and health institutions that help us understand the threats of climate change and potential pandemics — the list seemingly grows daily.

All administrations should be given a chance to carry out their goals. And reform and new approaches must be welcome; the government always moves too slowly in instituting change. 

But those of us who have devoted our lives to American national security need to speak up loudly about the approach that the administration has taken — as we fear that we are becoming less safe by the day.

  Marc Polymeropoulos worked at the CIA for 26 years and retired in 2019. Jeremy Hurewitz is the author of “Sell Like a Spy” and the head of “Interfor Academy.”

Topics

How a national-security review made AppLovin America’s hottest stock — and its founders billionaires

Who says government can’t create wealth? CFIUS, an obscure panel playing an increasing market role, blocked the sale of AppLovin years before a stock-market bonanza.
MarketWatch - Feb. 21
America must break its addiction to fossil fuels

Our national goal should be to end the suffering caused by fossil fuels and leave our children a world where human society and nature coexist
The Hill - 1d
America must not surrender its Democratic values | Bernie Sanders

Together, we must fight for our long-held values and work with people around the world who share them. For 250 years, the United States has held itself up as a symbol of democracy – an example of ...
The Guardian - 4d
Desi Lydic: Trump Just ‘Put a Cover Charge on America’

“It’s $5 million to get in, but he’ll waive it if you bring in three hot girls with you,” Lydic said of President Trump’s “gold card” visa idea on the “Daily Show.”
The New York Times - 5d
Restoring Academic Ties With China Is a Matter of U.S. National Security

Decisions on U.S. policy toward China are being made based on diminishing insight into the country’s internal dynamics.
The New York Times - 2d
Trump's former national security adviser on the U.S.-Ukraine relationship

Russian attacks on Ukraine continue after President Trump's attempt to mediate the war erupted during an Oval Office fight with Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy.
CBS News - 1d
America vs. The World: Trump Shows How Far He Is Willing to Take ‘America First.’

President Trump has frayed alliances across the globe with his words and actions.
The New York Times - 2h
AI vs. endpoint attacks: What security leaders must know to stay ahead

Why enterprises must embrace an AI-first strategy that unifies endpoint, identity and network security within a zero-trust framework.
VentureBeat - Feb. 20
Europe must secure Ukraine's future if US won't, ex-Army head says

Sir Nick Carter says "others are going to have to step up to the plate" if the US does not want to.
BBC News - Feb. 21
St. John's secures first Big East title since '85

RJ Luis Jr. scored 21 points and No. 7 St. John's beat Seton Hall 71-61 to clinch its first outright regular-season Big East title since 1985 on Saturday.
ESPN - 2d
Worried about Social Security staff cuts? Put money aside now, the agency’s former director says.

Martin O’Malley said DOGE’s involvement in Social Security will hurt beneficiaries. Brace for delays in service — and even benefits.
MarketWatch - 3d
Las Vegas PD announce nation’s first fleet of police Tesla Cybertrucks

The Las Vegas Metropolitan Police Department (LVMPD) announced it had been gifted the country’s first fleet of Tesla Cybertrucks for law enforcement use. During an address, LVMPD said an unnamed ...
The Hill - 6d
Search underway at national park for man last seen nearly 2 weeks ago

The Black Canyon of the Gunnison National Park in Colorado is one of the last known locations where 31-year-old Jordan Marsters was seen, the National Park Service said.
CBS News - Feb. 25
In deporting Asians to Central America, Trump strong-arms weaker nations, experts say

Dozens of mostly Asian migrants were put on a deportation flight on Thursday. But instead of landing near their home countries, the plane arrived in San José, Costa Rica.
NBC News - 6d
Google Ad-Tech Users Can Target National Security ‘Decision Makers’ and People With Chronic Diseases

Google enables marketers to target people with serious illnesses and crushing debt—against its policies—as well as the makers of classified defense technology, a WIRED investigation has found.
Wired - Feb. 20
National Gallery of Australia says it covered Palestinian flags on tapestry after security assessment

Critics say NGA decision ‘is nothing less than a disgraceful act of censorship’ that is ‘rooted in political cowardice’. Follow our Australia news live blog for latest updates Get our breaking ...
The Guardian - Feb. 21
Hauler Talk: Behind the scenes of first playoff committee meeting, last-lap caution flag decision-making

The latest episode of the “Hauler Talk” podcast provided a glimpse into the NASCAR playoff committee that held its first meeting two weeks ago at Daytona International Speedway. The panel of more ...
Yahoo Sports - 6d
The number of babies born in South Korea last year rebounded for first time in nearly a decade

The number of babies born in South Korea has rebounded for the first time in nine years, welcome news for a country grappling with one of the the world’s most serious demographic crises
ABC News - 5d
The number of babies born in South Korea last year rebounded for the first time in nearly a decade

The number of babies born in South Korea has rebounded for the first time in nine years
ABC News - 5d
Ranking All 30 M.L.B. Franchises From First to Worst Over the Last 25 Years

The Dodgers’ recent dominance vaulted them into a strong position, but a different team claimed the top spot.
The New York Times - 6h
Club Brugge 1-3 Aston Villa: Champions League last 16, first leg – as it happened

A late own goal from Brandon Mechele and a Marco Asensio penalty give Villa the edge . Unai Emery: “We know their potential and we know we have to be strong, defensively, offensively, tactically. ...
The Guardian - 1h
PSV Eindhoven v Arsenal: Champions League last 16, first leg – live

Champions League updates from the 8pm GMT kick-off Live scores | Read today’s Football Daily | And mail Niall Real Madrid v Atlético Madrid: round of 16 first leg – live In the UK at ...
The Guardian - 17m
U.S. stocks are being trounced by Europe as Trump retreats from Ukraine, focuses on ‘America First’

Increased European defense spending as the U.S. backs away from Ukraine could bolster the euro and the region’s stocks
MarketWatch - 21h
Live Nation expects a big 2025, boosted by stadium shows, but sees some bumps in the first quarter

Live Nation Entertainment Inc. reported a dip in fourth-quarter sales Thursday, but that figure still came in above expectations, and the Ticketmaster parent said it expected bigger gains this year ...
MarketWatch - Feb. 21
Canada defeats USA in overtime to claim hockey's first 4 Nations Face-Off title

Canada defeated USA Thursday to win the first-ever 4 Nations Face-Off hockey tournament, capping what had become a heated and politically charged event.
NBC News - Feb. 21
More than 10,000 First Nations people killed in Australia’s frontier wars, final massacre map shows

‘Horrendous’ eight-year long project has ended with final fact check, leaving a legacy ‘nobody can argue’ with, says researcher. The Killing Times map of sites where violence occurred on the ...
The Guardian - Feb. 23
Iowa governor signs nation's first bill removing transgender civil rights protections

Iowa became the first state to strike anti-discrimination protections for transgender people from its civil rights code on Friday after the state’s Republican Gov. Kim Reynolds signed hotly ...
The Hill - 3d
America’s Flex

We cover President Trump’s new tariffs.
The New York Times - 9h
The Showgirl Must Go On

Gypsy Wood, a dancer and cabaret artist, is more than at home on the stage. But it was her Las Vegas ranch house that landed a big role in the film “The Last Showgirl.”
The New York Times - Feb. 22
‘America is now an adversary’

Plus, inside the UK's 'right-wing Davos'
Financial Times - Feb. 21
President William McKinley's America

Our 25th president loved tariffs, and oversaw an expansion of U.S. territory around the globe. But William McKinley is best remembered as being one of the four presidents that was assassinated.
CBS News - Feb. 23
2/24: America Decides

Macron, Trump offer contrasting paths to peace in Ukraine; Is the U.S. facing a constitutional crisis?
CBS News - Feb. 24
America Has a Rogue President

The firing of three judge advocate generals is one more element of this administration’s attack on the rule of law.
The New York Times - Feb. 25
2/25: America Decides

21 federal employees resign “in protest” over DOGE; U.S Secret Service Director discusses his experience during President Trump’s first assassination attempt
CBS News - 6d
2/26: America Decides

Trump holds first cabinet meeting; Will DOGE save gov't money? Is recession near?
CBS News - 5d
2/27: America Decides

Trump and U.K. Prime Minister Starmer discuss Ukraine war at the White House; Trump administration to take control of White House press pool
CBS News - 4d
2/28: America Decides

Trump clashes with Zelenskyy in White House meeting; WIRED: Musk's DOGE is 'worse than you think'
CBS News - 3d
America has turned on its friends

Donald Trump’s abandonment of allies is real and will endure
Financial Times - Feb. 21
America and Russia Are on the Same Side Now

The U.S. is embracing European far-right parties in sympathy with Moscow — the opposite of how Washington dealt with Europe’s Communist parties in the Cold War.
The New York Times - Feb. 25