A Russian economic meltdown is coming next year
Will Putin’s genocidal war against Ukraine end in 2025? If you believe the economic projections of three brilliant economists — a Russian, a Swede and an American — the answer is very likely yes.
Vladimir Milov, Anders Aslund and Jeffrey Sonnenfeld agree that Putin’s war is economically and thus militarily unsustainable. According to them, 2025 will be crunch time for Putin’s regime.
As the Russian economy tanks, immiseration and social discontent grow, and money dries up, Putin will run out of resources to fuel his war machine. Russia’s self-absorbed dictator has a penchant for preposterous bluster and will disagree with their analysis, but his empty pockets will point to a different conclusion.
The bottom line is that a country can be a great power or wage a massive war only if it has the requisite economic wherewithal. Soldiers, supplies and armaments cost huge amounts of money. Imperialism requires even more, as it involves a heightened expenditure of resources. Economic dwarves cannot be military giants, and bankrupt economic dwarves cannot sustain wars.
If Putin didn’t think of himself as historically exceptional, he would realize from a quick look at the past that he has embarked on the road to defeat — which is bad enough — and toward the collapse of his regime and possibly his state.
Austria-Hungary and the Ottoman Empire lacked the economic resources to modernize their militaries. They not only lost World War I, but fell apart in the process. No economic giant, Imperial Russia happened to be on the winning side, but it still fell apart. Kaiser Wilhelm II and Adolf Hitler had powerful economies and thought they could afford to launch mega-wars. But when they dragged the U.S. into their respective conflicts, they thereby tipped the resource balance against themselves.
The U.S. and China have the strongest economies in the world and, unsurprisingly, are superpowers. Small wonder that America retained that status even after suffering defeats in Vietnam and Afghanistan, and a semi-defeat in Iraq. In contrast, Putin and his comrades cannot afford to lose. They know that a loss in Ukraine probably means losing their shirts, themselves and their state.
Leonid’s Brezhnev’s Soviet Union should have taught Putin a lesson. The decrepit Soviet economy couldn’t support Brezhnev’s military expenditures, foreign policy adventures and repressions in Africa, the Middle East, Eastern Europe and Afghanistan. Competing with the far richer U.S. overextended the Soviets, depressed their economy, demoralized Russians, angered non-Russians and induced Mikhail Gorbachev to adopt the reforms that ultimately killed the USSR.
Russia’s current share of nominal global GDP stands at a relatively minuscule $2 trillion, compared to America’s $29 trillion, China’s $19 trillion and Germany’s $5 trillion. In fact, Russia’s share is virtually identical to that of Canada and Mexico, neither of which has evinced imperialist aspirations.
These figures haven’t stopped Putin from taking on all of NATO (whose combined share of global GDP amounts to roughly 30 times Russia’s), expending enormous sums on the war in Ukraine, inducing close to a million young Russian professionals to flee abroad, killing or maiming over 600,000 of their comrades at home, neglecting consumer sectors, producing inflation greater than 20 percent, transforming Russia into a Chinese colony and aligning it with such economic basket cases as North Korea, Iran and Venezuela. Economic irresponsibility of such awe-inspiring magnitude never goes unpunished.
The coming year will likely be the time the you-know-what hits the fan for Putin. If Russia's economy collapses, so too will the military and the war. Even if the military machine only slows down and the Ukrainians retake the initiative, the consequences for Putin will be devastating.
Bereft of money, Putin will have just two choices. One is to plead his case to the broader society and make concessions in return for resources — unthinkable for a megalomaniac such as him. The other will be to push his armies past the point of exhaustion in the hope that some miracle will intervene. This will only delay his defeat and the potential consequence of a coup d’etat by his former allies.
Russia’s coming economic crash has three implications. First, if Ukraine holds out and gets the support it needds, it will win, if only because Russia will lose. Second, the time to negotiate with Putin is in 2025, when his military and economy bog down — not now, when he’s still in chest-beating mode. And third, Putin may soon come to resemble France’s Louis XVI, who faced a similar problem in 1789, when a financial crisis forced him to convene the Estates General.
And we all know what happened next.
Alexander J. Motyl is a professor of political science at Rutgers University-Newark. A specialist on Ukraine, Russia and the USSR, and on nationalism, revolutions, empires and theory, he is the author of 10 books of nonfiction, as well as “Imperial Ends: The Decay, Collapse, and Revival of Empires” and “Why Empires Reemerge: Imperial Collapse and Imperial Revival in Comparative Perspective.”
Date: | |
Tag: | Russia |
-
Politics - Politico
The 5 factions Johnson has to appease to keep the speakership next year
His most outspoken and well-known critics are the nearly dozen GOP lawmakers who voted to advance an ouster effort against him earlier this year, but they’re not alone.2 days ago -
World - ABC News
Russian prosecutors seek more than three-year prison term for French citizen accused of collecting military information
Russian prosecutors seek more than three-year prison term for French citizen accused of collecting military information4 hours ago - Russia -
World - ABC News
Russian court convicts French citizen of collecting military information, sentences him to 3 years in prison
Russian court convicts French citizen of collecting military information, sentences him to 3 years in prison3 hours ago - Russia -
Top stories - BBC News
WWE’s Cody Rhodes wants WrestleMania to be hosted in UK within next five years
The "American Nightmare" thinks Manchester or London have venues perfect for hosting the event.3 hours ago - United Kingdom -
Top stories - BBC News
BBC boss warns of Russian and Chinese propaganda due to World Service cuts
The UK is losing out because of cuts to the World Service, the BBC's director general warns.42 minutes ago - Russia -
Politics - The Hill
Get ready: Republican election disruption is coming
Whichever presidential candidate is leading on that night, and however many ballots still need to be counted, Donald Trump will claim victory and dare the world to dispute him.2 hours ago -
Business - The New York Times
Russian Oil Flows Through Western ‘Price Cap’ as Shadow Fleet Grows
A report shows how Russia has largely evaded sanctions aimed at limiting its revenue from oil sales.8 hours ago - Russia -
World - The New York Times
Russian Disinformation Targets U.S.-Backed Anti-Malaria Campaign
Scientists fighting the spread of infectious diseases on the continent have been targeted online by pro-Russian activists, part of an effort to spread fear and mistrust of the West.8 hours ago - Russia
More from The Hill
-
Politics - The Hill
California’s deepfake ban can’t fool the deep protections of the First Amendment
California Governor Gavin Newsom has signed into law Assembly Bill 2839, which bans altered content during election season if it is materially deceptive and falsely portrays a candidate, in an ...18 minutes ago - California -
Politics - The Hill
12:30 Report — Trump escalates Election Day rhetoric
Plus: FEMA pauses some North Carolina aid efforts over threats {beacon} 12:30 REPORT It’s a quiet Monday morning. Today is Indigenous Peoples’ Day and Columbus Day. Are you off work? Either way, ...43 minutes ago - Donald Trump -
Politics - The Hill
Harris campaign touts Republican Mesa mayor's support in new Arizona ad
Vice President Harris’s campaign launched a $370 million ad blitz on Monday, debuting a 30-second spot highlighting an Arizona Republican mayor’s support for the Democratic nominee. In the new ad, ...44 minutes ago -
Politics - The Hill
Harris agrees to sit for interview with Fox News
Vice President Harris has agreed to sit for an exclusive interview with Fox News anchor Bret Baier, the network announced Monday. The interview will air Thursday at 6 p.m. during the network's ...50 minutes ago -
Politics - The Hill
Harris: Trump is 'dangerous' for Black Americans
Vice President Harris is zeroing in on former President Trump’s history of racially charged comments in an effort to warn Black voters away from casting their ballots for him in November. In an ...56 minutes ago - Donald Trump