A national abortion ban won't pass on its own, Republicans should make a deal
The pro-life movement is at a crossroads. Nearly two years after the Supreme Court overturned Roe v. Wade, activists continue to demand that Congress pass a national abortion ban — a policy that has no chance of passing on its own, especially after widespread outrage over Arizona’s reinstatement of an 1864 abortion ban.
We can either continue to advocate that failed strategy, or we can try something that may work. Those of us who care about saving unborn lives and protecting mothers should support a political exchange, giving politicians who support abortion something they want in exchange for the pro-life progress we want.
The abortion debate cannot be separated from America’s red-versus-blue political divide, with Republicans broadly supporting abortion restrictions and Democrats demanding abortion on demand. Since Congress is almost evenly divided, the only way to pass anything is by giving both parties a political victory.
Pro-life Republicans have never taken this approach. Instead, they’ve introduced stand-alone legislation. That includes Sen. Lindsey Graham’s (R-S.C.) Protecting Pain-Capable Unborn Children bill, which would outlaw abortion after 15 weeks, and Sens. John Thune (R-S.D.) and James Lankford’s (R-Okla.) Born-Alive Abortion Survivors Protection Act, which protects children born during botched abortions. The pro-life movement rightly says that a clear majority of Americans support these policies, based on years of polling.
But polling is no guarantee of passage, and on the rare occasions that stand-alone pro-life bills come up for votes, they inevitably fail to pass one or both houses — to say nothing of what would happen at the president’s desk. If anything, the chances of a pro-life bill becoming law have decreased in recent years. Democrats think abortion is a winning issue for them, based on the growing number of purple and red states that have voted to protect abortion.
Republicans can’t stick with the same old strategy. Nor should they abandon the pro-life cause, as Democrats and even some GOP strategists want. Rather, they should approach abortion the same way they tackle other policy issues — as a chance for horse-trading.
What liberal priority should the right offer in exchange for, say, a 12-week abortion ban? Since Democrats frequently accuse Republicans of ignoring life after birth, the GOP should start with a liberal humanitarian priority. Perhaps that means more funding for mental health, homelessness or general anti-poverty work. More likely, Democrats would only consider something much more substantial — say, amnesty for the estimated 2.3 million “Dreamers” or even for the 10-plus million illegal immigrants living in America.
Some Republicans may balk at exchanging amnesty for an abortion ban, but it’s also true that many Democrats would oppose giving up any abortions for the sake of illegal immigrants. That’s exactly why the bargain could work — because neither side gets all of what they want. Compromise is the proven path to passing a law, and without it, neither amnesty nor an abortion ban stand any chance of advancing.
There are other reasons pro-life Republicans could support this approach. Since Democrats wouldn’t be doing amnesty alone, newly legalized citizens would be less likely to support them at the ballot box, benefitting the GOP politically. Republicans would also be spared the indignity of continuing to demand that millions of illegal immigrants — many with families and children — be rounded up and sent home, a logistical impossibility. And the pro-life movement would be setting itself up for further progress. Illegal immigrants would continue to come to America, while abortions would continue to occur across the country. The next time Democrats call for amnesty, Republicans could trade it for even stronger restrictions on abortion.
If Democrats reject a bargain, they’d only hurt themselves. They’d prove to Americans, who overwhelmingly support restrictions on second- and third-trimester abortions, that they’re far outside the mainstream. They’d come across to voters as pigheaded, which is how Republicans seem when they demand stand-alone abortion restrictions. The GOP hasn’t benefited politically from that perception. Democrats would likely suffer, too.
Does any Republican have the courage to call for such a compromise? The opposition would be fierce from some quarters, especially on the fringes of both parties. But the pro-life movement has no other conceivable path to a federal legislative victory. If saving babies and mothers is as important as we say it is, we should be willing to trade something equally important to get the votes in Congress. Or the pro-life cause can continue down its current road — a road of defeat that’s littered with lost innocent lives.
Tim Busch is founder of the Napa Institute.
Date: | |
Tag: | Abortion |
Filter
-
Arizona Senate passes repeal of 1864 abortion ban
The Arizona Senate voted to pass a repeal of the near-total ban on abortion from 1864 that was upheld by the battleground state’s Supreme Court last month.NBC News - Top stories - Abortion -
Arizona Senate passes repeal of 1864 abortion ban
The Arizona Senate voted to pass a repeal of the near-total ban on abortion from 1864 that was upheld by the battleground state’s Supreme Court last month.NBC News - Politics - Abortion -
Arizona Voted to Repeal Its Abortion Ban
Also, the Fed eyes a longer period of high rates. Here’s the latest at the end of Wednesday.The New York Times - Top stories - Abortion -
Arizona senate passes repeal of 1864 near-total abortion ban
Democrats pick up support of two Republicans to repeal law reinstated three weeks ago, with governor expected to ratify repeal. Arizona lawmakers have repealed the state’s 160-year-old statute banning nearly all abortions.. The 1864 law, which was ...The Guardian - World - Abortion -
Arizona Senate passes repeal of 1864 abortion ban, sending it to governor's desk
The Arizona Senate has voted to repeal the state's 1864 abortion banABC News - Top stories - Abortion -
Kamala Harris Looks to Make Trump the Face of Florida’s Abortion Ban
The vice president sought to tie former President Donald J. Trump to the state’s six-week abortion ban, which took effect on Wednesday.The New York Times - Top stories - Donald Trump -
Arizona lawmakers vote to undo near-total abortion ban from 1864, with Gov. Hobbs expected to sign
The Arizona Legislature has approved a repeal of a long-dormant ban on nearly all abortionsABC News - Health - Abortion -
Harris makes case for flipping Florida blue as six-week abortion ban goes into effect
Vice President Harris bashed former President Trump on Wednesday in Florida, a state the Biden campaign is trying to flip to blue, as the state’s 6-week abortion ban went into effect. “As of this morning, 4 million women in this state woke up with ...The Hill - Politics - Abortion -
Kansas has new abortion laws while Louisiana may block exceptions to its ban
Kansas is requiring abortion providers to share patient information with the state and increasing funds to anti-abortion centers, while bills to loosen a restrictive ban in Louisiana face an uphill battleABC News - Health - Abortion -
‘Enough with the gaslighting’: Harris responds to Trump’s insistence that he doesn’t back national abortion ban – live
Vice-president calls abortion access a ‘fundamental freedom’ in Florida as state’s six-week ban takes effect. Florida’s six-week abortion ban takes effectArizona Democrats to make final push to repeal near-total abortion banGreene wrapped up the ...The Guardian - World - Abortion
More from The Hill
-
Morning Report — Speaker assures GOP critics of ‘big’ 2025 plans
Speaker Mike Johnson (R-La.) — the target of a promised GOP coup next week, which will fail — suggests he wants to lead Republicans in the next Congress. "I’m doing my duty, as I’ve been called by my colleagues to do. I’ll continue to do it as ...The Hill - Politics -
Ukraine opposition is building with Senate GOP hopefuls, a warning sign for McConnell
The new class of Senate GOP candidates are lining up against aid to Ukraine, underscoring how the tide is slowly shifting against Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell (R-Ky.) and his allies in the upper chamber. A number of Republican Senate ...The Hill - Politics - Ukraine -
Greene's motion to vacate vote leaves conservatives with no easy options
Rep. Marjorie Taylor Greene’s (R-Ga.) decision to force action on ousting Speaker Mike Johnson (R-La.) has created a dilemma for some rank-and-file Republicans who will now face a tough choice: vote to boot a party leader endorsed by former ...The Hill - Politics -
Global court in pressure cooker over threat of Israel arrest warrants
The Biden administration and Israel’s supporters in Congress are lashing out at the International Criminal Court (ICC) over potential arrest warrants that could be issued for alleged crimes by Israeli officials in prosecuting the country’s war ...The Hill - Politics - Israel -
Russia seizes on final window before US weapons fortify Ukraine’s front lines
As Ukraine desperately awaits the arrival of new U.S. weapons and equipment approved last month, Russia is seeking to make the most of the remaining window. Moscow’s forces in the past week have taken several villages in eastern Ukraine after ...The Hill - Politics - Ukraine