A growing body of data is debunking myths about remote work
![A growing body of data is debunking myths about remote work](https://thehill.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2024/06/GettyImages-1451397583.jpg?w=900)
As conflicts over return-to-office initiatives rage, whether in the U.S. government or the private sector, the amount of data about remote work continues to grow.
Many organizations, worried about potential drops in morale and productivity, are calling employees back to the office. But the employees, having experienced the flexibility of remote work, are reluctant to let it go.
In this context, a recent two-part meta-analysis published in the peer-reviewed journal "Personal Psychology" and led by Ravi Gajendran and his team offers crucial insights into the real effects of remote work, potentially reshaping this ongoing debate.
Gajendran's first meta-analysis covers 108 studies involving 45,288 participants. It examines the effects of remote work intensity — the extent to which employees work remotely, ranging from one or two days a week to full-time remote work — on various employee outcomes. Additionally, the meta-analysis compares remote workers to their office-based counterparts across 62 studies with 41,904 participants.
The findings of the meta-analysis show that, contrary to many leaders' concerns, remote work has beneficial effects on several critical employee outcomes. For example, remote work boosts employees' job satisfaction and commitment to their organizations. The flexibility of remote work allows them to better manage their work-life balance, leading to more positive attitudes towards their jobs and employers.
Additionally, remote work enhances employees' feelings of support from their organizations. This increased support likely stems from the more deliberate communication and support mechanisms necessitated by remote work, making employees feel more valued.
Supervisors often rate remote workers higher, dispelling the myth that remote employees are less productive or less visible to their managers. Moreover, remote work reduces employees' intentions to leave their jobs. The flexibility and autonomy of remote work serve as powerful retention tools.
Despite the overall positive findings, the analysis did uncover one significant downside to remote work: loneliness. As employees spend more days working remotely, they tend to feel more isolated. This increased sense of isolation can negatively impact their overall well-being. However, new research on mental health in remote work provides a nuanced perspective on this issue.
Groundbreaking research conducted at the University of Pittsburgh, which analyzed data from over 5 million mental health screens across multiple U.S. states, highlights the significant positive influence of workplace flexibility on mental well-being. This study found that states with a higher percentage of firms offering flexible work arrangements exhibited considerably lower rates of depression and suicide risk. The correlation was particularly robust in 2023, a fully post-pandemic year, indicating that the flexibility of remote and hybrid work can enhance mental health outcomes.
The research suggests that while feelings of isolation may have been prevalent during the enforced social isolation of the pandemic, these feelings likely diminished as people began to re-engage with social, civic and community activities. The study also shows that flexibility in work arrangements can reduce stress by alleviating the pressures associated with commuting, rigid schedules and work-life imbalance.
Additionally, increased autonomy and control over work schedules contribute to higher job satisfaction and overall well-being. Thus, whatever negative effects may come from feelings of isolation among some remote workers are more than outweighed by the mental health benefits of remote work.
The meta-analysis by Gajendran and his co-authors, along with the University of Pittsburgh study, offers a comprehensive view of the effects of remote work. The data suggest that, on balance, remote work has modest but positive effects on various employee outcomes. The only notable downside is the potential for increased feelings of isolation, which organizations can address through targeted interventions such as regular virtual check-ins, team-building activities and opportunities for in-person interactions when feasible.
In spite of such abundant evidence, many leaders still try to push a hard-nosed approach to forcing employees back into the office full-time. We see that in the private sector, in companies such as Boeing and UPS, causing these firms to lose their best talent. And we see it in the public sector. As one example, a proposed bill from Senators Mitt Romney (R-Utah) and Joe Manchin (I-W.Va.) aims to limit telework to 40 percent of a federal employee's total work hours, posing a significant threat to the extensive benefits associated with flexibility.
That’s despite extensive evidence from the federal government itself. The annual report from the White House Office of Personnel Management highlighted the concrete advantages of telecommuting. It showed that 68 percent of frequent remote workers intend to stay in their positions, compared to only 53 percent of non-teleworkers. Additionally, 77 percent of regular teleworkers reported high engagement levels, significantly higher than the 59 percent among those who work primarily in the office.
Performance benefits are also evident, with more than 84 percent of employees and managers recognizing enhancements in work quality and customer satisfaction due to telecommuting. All this data aligns well with Gajendran and Mark Ma’s studies' analysis, confirming that the federal government benefits from retaining flexibility.
In short, leaders should view flexible work not just as a temporary necessity borne out of a global crisis, but as a long-term opportunity to fundamentally improve work environments. By designing work models that promote both high productivity and strong mental health, organizations can create workplaces that are not only more humane but also more effective.
Gleb Tsipursky, Ph.D., serves as the CEO of the hybrid work consultancy Disaster Avoidance Experts and authored the best-seller "Returning to the Office and Leading Hybrid and Remote Teams."
Date: |
Filter
-
CNBC - Business
How to boost your EQ at the office—even if you work remotely, according to a career expert
Emotional intelligence can help you get ahead at work, but you'll have to work to show it if you work remotely, career experts say. -
CBS News - Top stories
Concerns about Biden's campaign growing among House Democrats
A group of House Democrats are circulating a letter calling on President Biden to end his 2024 reelection bid in the wake of last week's debate against former President Donald Trump. The letter has not yet been released. CBS News congressional ...Joe Biden -
The New York Times - Top stories
Sarah Sze Has Been Making Work About Life and Death Since Childhood
Sarah Sze discusses her practice, pet adoption and winning second prize in a painting contest. -
Inc. - Business
Thinking About Starting a Business Blog? These Time-Saving Ideas Will Help You Work More Productively
Take some tips from a productivity consultant and time management coach to streamline the blog creation process. -
Inc. - Business
Gig Work Company Settles With FTC for $7 Million Over Misleading Employees About Pay
"Operating in the 'gig' economy is no license for evading the law," Federal Trade Commission head Lina Khan tells Arise Virtual Solutions. -
The Wall Street Journal - World
'Bodies in the Water' Review: Awash in Questions
In this true-crime documentary from ID, a fisherman’s horrifying find off the New Jersey shore sends law enforcement on a tortuous journey to solve the murder of a high-school student. -
The Hill - Politics
No, there is not a war on America's working class
Let’s stop telling working-class Americans a false narrative of decline. -
BBC News - Top stories
Husband who put body in suitcase guilty of murder
Aminan Rahman choked Suma Begum before putting her into a suitcase and dumping it in a river. -
BBC News - Top stories
Body found in search for child missing in croc attack
Australian police have located the remains of a 12-year-old last seen swimming in croc-inhabited waters. -
Yahoo News - World
Bodies of 89 migrants retrieved from Atlantic
More from The Hill
-
The Hill - Politics
Nvidia's rapid rise hits 'bumps in the road'
After blowing past a $3 trillion market capitalization and briefly becoming the most valuable company in the world last month, Nvidia has lost and regained hundreds of billions of dollars in value in recent days. While the chipmaker’s volatility ... -
The Hill - Politics
Biden, critics fear emboldened Trump after Supreme Court immunity ruling
A Supreme Court decision giving presidents wide protection from facing charges after leaving office has sparked fears voiced by President Biden and Democratic critics that former President Trump will be further emboldened should he be elected to a ...Joe Biden -
The Hill - Politics
Supreme Court’s weakening of public corruption safeguards sparks alarm
Ethics and legal experts warn that the Supreme Court has struck a serious blow to prosecutors’ ability to crack down on the abuse of power and public corruption. And that’s ringing alarm bells when Donald Trump, who was convicted in May by a ... -
The Hill - Politics
Biden leans on family with political future at risk
President Biden is increasingly leaning on his family while navigating calls from fellow Democrats to end his 2024 candidacy. Jill Biden and Hunter Biden serve as some of the president’s closest inner circle of confidants with a public focus ...Joe Biden -
The Hill - Politics
Biden camp announces $50M ad blitz, $17M voter outreach push
President Biden’s campaign will launch a $50 million battleground state ad blitz, it announced Friday, a move that comes as he seeks to assure voters he’s up for the job following last week’s dismal debate performance. The campaign also said it ...Joe Biden