A future without newspapers: Tech execs 'go direct,' signaling an end to accountability
Mark Zuckerberg is done apologizing.
In September, the Meta CEO told the hosts of the “Acquired” podcast in front of a packed live audience at San Francisco’s Chase Center that he regrets taking responsibility in the past for issues out of his company’s control.
What might his vague comments refer to? Perhaps the Cambridge Analytica disaster of 2016, which gave Donald Trump an influential advantage on the back of Facebook user data? Or was it the platform’s dangerous proliferation of misinformation at the height of COVID in 2020? Both of these events were brought to light by in-depth reporting that harmed Zuckerberg’s reputation and made all that apologizing necessary to get back into the public’s good graces.
Today, freshly rehabbed with a Roman haircut and a cultivated wardrobe, Zuckerberg is stirring up new issues: Meta has removed Trump’s social media account restrictions, and the Meta CEO says he’ll push back on any pressure to get his platforms to take down potentially disruptive content. But who’s going to make him say sorry now?
It’s no secret that Meta, Google and other big tech giants have gutted the media industry; Google is currently facing an antitrust lawsuit for stealing millions in revenue from publications. Even just in the last few years, the critical pressure on public figures that journalism once provided has weakened to a light touch due to dwindling resources.
As an experienced communications professional for tech and other industries, what I’m seeing concerns me deeply. We’re quickly approaching a future where tech executives can spin stories and no newspapers exist anymore to provide an accurately fact-checked counter-narrative. Corporate whistleblowers won’t have any reporters to turn to. Consumers will never find out the truth. The most powerful voices will define right and wrong, and Zuckerberg and others like him won’t ever have to apologize again.
On second thought, maybe that future is already here.
An appearance like Zuckerberg’s at the Chase Center is part of a shiny new communication strategy for tech executives called “going direct.” The approach, coined by former Activision comms executive Lulu Cheng Meservey, is defined by a disregard for traditional media and its past influence on public perception. “There’s no longer a need to go through traditional gatekeepers of information and brokers of reputation,” Meservey’s manifesto declares.
In many ways, she’s correct. A decade ago, Zuckerberg would’ve taken his new messaging to a reputable reporter at a major newspaper to ensure that his story carried the weight of the outlet’s reputation into the homes of the outlet’s audience. Today, readership across all but the biggest journalistic institutions is way down, and even worse, so is public trust in them. Americans are getting their news from X, TikTok, and yes, Facebook. The market for podcasts like Acquired is exploding — it’s already a $25 billion industry — but the fact-checking and deep unbiased reporting that has historically been a requirement for traditional journalism hasn’t followed into these mediums.
Venture capital firms, tech companies and consultancies have built their own soapboxes too. Coinbase announced its controversial 2020 company policy to ban politics via its blog. Google CEO Sundar Pichai put out his own euphemistic “mission-first” policy on the company blog this year. LinkedIn has become a sea of CEO statements and product announcements from tech companies big and small. There are an almost uncountable number of platforms for the powerful to shout from.
It is no wonder Zuckerberg showed up on a stage. “Build your own platform, build your own audience, and build your own narrative” is the new way forward, according to the “Go Direct” playbook.
More voices isn’t necessarily the problem, although the ever-expanding sea of content makes discerning truth from fiction even harder. It’s the lack of accountability. Many of these platforms pride themselves on only lightly moderating content, if at all; fact-checks are few and far between.
Without independent institutions outside of the tech industry that can push back against false statements, take the time and resources required to investigate wrongdoing, carefully steward and publish whistleblower stories, and then hold the powerful to account — leading beyond apologies to new, more ethical behavior — we’re doomed to repeat the mistakes of the past with far more dangerous results.
Without independent journalism, Theranos would have continued to peddle fraudulent healthcare, Juul would have continued to sell tobacco to kids, and maybe Zuckerberg wouldn’t have felt pressured to pull all that COVID misinformation from Facebook before it caused more harm.
In today’s world, where AI is being used as an excuse to lay off thousands of workers and the most powerful in tech are pouring millions into lobbying before a history-making election, the stakes for tech accountability could not be higher. If these current trends persist unchecked, we’re facing a future where the Zuckerbergs of the world will do whatever they like and tell us what to think about it too. Accountability will be dead, no more sorrys about it.
William Fitzgerald is the founder and a partner at The Worker Agency, a policy and communications firm based in the Bay Area. Before setting up the firm, he worked on the public policy & corporate communications teams at Google, from 2008-2018.
Date: |
Topics
-
Top stories - NBC News
Tim Walz makes direct appeal to conflicted Muslim voters
Democrats are stepping up outreach to Muslim and Arab voters, who could be critical in states like Michigan but are concerned about U.S. support for Israel.Yesterday -
Business - Financial Times
The UK marketing exec who turned bedtime stories into a cartoon world
The Master Moley tales helped James Reatchlous beat cancer before spawning two animated series and a film company21 hours ago - United Kingdom -
Top stories - BBC News
Melania Trump is latest Republican First Lady to back abortion
Her apparent support of abortion access puts her at odds with her husband, who has taken credit for helping to overturn Roe v Wade.Yesterday - Donald Trump -
Top stories - BBC News
Rachel Reeves signals plan to spend more on big projects
The UK will prioritise and increase investment in major projects in the Budget, Rachel Reeves says.Yesterday -
Business - Financial Times
The conflicted investment case for defence tech
There’s a bull market for the fast-changing sector but investing and innovating in weapons carries risks2 days ago -
Top stories - The New York Times
Four Weeks to Go
With Kamala Harris and Donald Trump locked in the tightest of races, who will come out on top? Listen to our political round table on the 2024 election.Yesterday -
Top stories - The New York Times
JD Smirks His Way Into the Future
The misogynist ticket takes a shot at Kamala for dancing — and being a woman.3 hours ago
More from The Hill
-
Politics - The Hill
Trump claims he knows 'nothing' about post floating Jamie Dimon endorsement
Former President Trump says he knew “nothing” about a Friday TruthSocial post on his account falsely claiming he’d been endorsed by JPMorgan Chase CEO Jamie Dimon. “I don’t know anything about it,” ...28 minutes ago - Donald Trump -
Politics - The Hill
China is tackling the symptoms rather than the causes of its economic problems
The problems over the past decade are structural in nature and will require fundamental reforms of the economy to put it on sounder footing.30 minutes ago - China -
Politics - The Hill
Former Defense chief: Israeli attack on Iran nuclear facilities would be 'significant strike'
Former Defense Secretary Mark Esper weighed in on Israel's likely response to a barrage of missiles launched by Tehran earlier this week and potential attacks on Iran nuclear facilities, saying it ...42 minutes ago - Israel -
Politics - The Hill
Israel and Iran are on the path toward a catastrophic war
The history of the Middle East and beyond is being shaped right now.1 hour ago - Iran -
Politics - The Hill
Israel's latest attack on Beirut cuts off crossing between Lebanon, Syria
Israel's latest attack on Lebanon's capital city of Beirut has cut off a key crossing with Syria, as tens of thousands of people look to escape the growing conflict between Israel and Iran-backed ...2 hours ago - Israel