4 ways to simplify the income tax
As millions of Americans sit down to prepare their income tax returns, a recent survey suggests that this activity is driving people to tears and to therapists. Despite the widespread desire across the political spectrum for simplicity, the tax code keeps getting more complicated.
It does not need to be this way. Congress could take concrete steps to simplify taxes for all Americans. In a new project from the Brookings-Urban Tax Policy Center, we lay out four proposals that simplify the income tax code, don’t add to the government’s debt, and make the tax system less punishing for low- and middle-income households.
The key to simplification is, put plainly, to cut down on complexity. Policymakers should remove targeted provisions and tax everything at the same rate, while still helping those who need it most. Congress has several options for doing so. Lawmakers can eliminate itemized deductions. They are expensive, regressive and used by relatively few households since the 2017 tax act raised the standard deduction substantially.
They could also end all preferential tax rates — for capital gains, dividends and business income. These are generally regressive, meaning they help high-income Americans more than the middle class or poor. Preferential rates also create opportunities for sheltering and tax avoidance, which generate further complexity.
If Congress wanted to move further, it could remove the head of household filing status and standardize the definition of who counts as a child for tax purposes. Currently, there are four separate definitions of a “qualifying child” for different tax credits and filing statuses, each with their own complicated rules and significant penalties for getting it wrong.
Replacing the current “alphabet soup” of complex tax credits with credits that are simpler, broader and more easily administrable would also do some good. For example, current Earned Income Tax Credit rules stretch to 15 pages, which may explain why more than a fifth of eligible taxpayers do not claim the credit. Finally, changes to the system should replace existing credits with a personal credit for each family member and a work credit that depends on an individual’s earnings. That would ensure families still get support they need without encouraging Americans to not work.
With those changes in mind, our first proposal calls for a personal credit of $1,000 in cash for all Americans, regardless of income. If policymakers wanted to boost incomes for lower-income families with children, our second proposal shows that they could increase the benefit to $2,000 per person per year, but phase it out beginning at $72,000 of income for a married couple or $36,000 for a single filer.
If Congress wanted even simpler income taxes, they could create a value-added tax (VAT), a tax on goods and services used by every other developed country in the world, and use the revenue to pay for bigger reforms. In our third proposal, based on a pitch by Columbia University professor Michael Graetz, VAT revenue would fund an increase in the standard deduction to $100,000 for married couples and $50,000 for single filers from its current values of $27,700 and $13,850, respectively. Almost two-thirds of Americans would not need to file taxes at all. It does not get any simpler than that.
Alternatively, our fourth proposal shows that VAT revenue could go toward providing a small universal basic income (UBI) of $3,900 per person per year. UBIs have received historical support from both the left and the right. This would lift the average after-tax income of families below the federal poverty line by more than 30 percent on average, effectively slashing poverty in America. It would also be revenue-neutral, paid for by the savings from simplification and the VAT.
Some of the most sweeping improvements can be implemented under any of the four proposals. The Treasury could pre-populate tax forms for most filers (as has been done in many other developed countries since the early 2000s), simplifying tax filing tremendously. And the IRS’s nascent direct-file system could be used for an even greater share of returns, saving taxpayers time and money.
Simplification is not an easy proposition. The tax code did not get complicated by accident, and the factors that generate complex tax systems — policy trade-offs, the complexity of families and businesses, the role of lobbyists, etc. — are not going away. Still, while everyone talks about simplification, policymakers now have four concrete proposals to choose from, all of which would make taxes (and life) simpler for many people.
William Gale is senior fellow and Samuel Thorpe is senior research assistant at the Brookings Institution and the Urban-Brookings Tax Policy Center.
Date: |
Topics
Filter
-
That sinking feeling: why long-suffering Venice is quite right to make tourists pay | Simon Jenkins
The overcrowded city is leading the way with a tax on day trippers. Surely other great European destinations should follow suit. Venice has had enough. It is sinking beneath the twin assaults of tourism and the sea and believes the answer lies in ...The Guardian - World -
I’m going to inherit $6 million in property along with my two siblings — is there a ‘clever’ way to avoid capital-gains tax?
“There are three siblings who are heirs, including me. What happens with the eventual distribution upon my surviving parent’s death?”MarketWatch - Business -
Inflation ticked higher in March as incomes, spending rose
Inflation picked up slightly in March as Americans saw their paychecks rise and kept up a sturdy pace of spending, according to data released Friday by the Commerce Department. The personal consumption expenditures (PCE) price index, the Federal ...The Hill - Politics -
Here's how much income it takes to be considered rich in your state
The income needed to join your state's top earners can vary considerably, from a low of $329,620 annually in West Virginia to $719,253 in Washington D.C.CBS News - Top stories -
HMRC’s struggles pose ‘a threat to tax compliance’
Authority’s chief in talks with ministers over additional fundingFinancial Times - World -
Move Over, TurboTax? IRS Considers Expanding Free Tax-Filing Program
The Direct File website processed more than 140,000 returns, exceeding a goal announced in March.The Wall Street Journal - World -
Putin’s War Will Soon Reach Russians’ Tax Bills
Russia’s president has signaled an increase in income and corporate taxes that will help finance the war. The move reflects his firm control over Russian policy.The New York Times - World - Russia -
Putin’s War Will Soon Reach Russians’ Tax Bills
Russia’s president has signaled an increase in income and corporate taxes that will help finance the war. The move reflects his firm control over Russian policy.The New York Times - Top stories - Russia -
BlackRock wants to make it easier to get paycheck-like income from your retirement savings
One of Americans' biggest retirement fears is running out of money. BlackRock hopes a new way to take paycheck-like withdrawals from investments may help.CNBC - Business -
South Korean police raid office of incoming head of doctors' group over protracted strikes
South Korean police have searched the office of the hard-line incoming leader of a doctors association and confiscated his mobile phoneABC News - World - South Korea
More from The Hill
-
Trump slams RFK Jr. in latest social media rant: 'Wasted protest vote'
Former President Trump came out swinging against independent presidential candidate Robert F. Kennedy Jr. Friday, despite weeks of amping him up over his likely November rival, President Biden. In a series of post on Truth Social, Trump suggested ...The Hill - Politics - Donald Trump -
RFK Jr. threatens to challenge TikTok ban: It's just a 'smoke screen'
Independent presidential candidate Robert F. Kennedy Jr. threatened to challenge a potential TikTok ban Friday, as efforts to block the video app in the U.S. came closer to reality earlier this week. “I’m going to file a lawsuit challenging the ...The Hill - Politics - Tiktok -
White House rips 'dangerous, appalling statements' from Columbia protest leader
The White House heavily criticized comments that resurfaced this week from a student leader of the pro-Palestinian protests at Columbia University. “These dangerous, appalling statements turn the stomach and should serve as a wakeup call. It is ...The Hill - Politics -
Freight train derails, catches fire near New Mexico-Arizona border causing road closures
A freight train detailed and caught fire, resulting in the closure of a nearby interstate, the Arizona Department of Transportation announced on Friday. "I-40 EB is closed at milepost 357 due to a train derailment in New Mexico," the Arizona DOT ...The Hill - Politics -
Paramedic sentenced to 4 years of probation for Elijah McClain's death
A Colorado paramedic has been sentenced to four years of probation for his role in the 2019 death of Elijah McClain. Jeremy Cooper, a former Aurora Fire Rescue paramedic, was convicted on Dec. 22 of criminally negligent homicide. He was the last ...The Hill - Politics