2024 is the first podcast election
The revolution will not be televised.
This 2024 election might go down in history as the year that YouTube and podcasts supplanted the mainstream media/television model of broadcasting. Maybe that’s not quite fair, but what we are seeing is that presidential candidates are increasingly relying on influencers, podcasters, talk radio hosts and friendly cable news shows to campaign.
In the last week or so, Donald Trump has appeared on Fox News’s “The Ingraham Angle,” Hugh Hewitt’s radio show, “The Ben Shapiro Show” podcast and the “Flagrant” comedy podcast. He declined to appear on “60 Minutes.”
In recent months, Trump has talked to several others. According to NPR, this includes “Logan Paul — who has a combined following of 46 million across TikTok and Instagram — and Theo Von, who has collectively 14 million followers on the same platforms.”
Meanwhile, Harris appeared on “The Late Show with Stephen Colbert,” ABC’s “The View,” “The Howard Stern Show,” the “All The Smoke” basketball podcast and the “Call Her Daddy” podcast. Harris’s running mate, Minnesota Gov. Tim Walz, did interviews with “Fox News Sunday” and ABC’s “Jimmy Kimmel Live!”
On the one hand, the contrast between the candidates is telling. As liberal writer Bill Scher noted in Washington Monthly, “Harris is trying to reach broad audiences across demographic spectrums,” while “Trump is strictly focused on animating conservatives — with an emphasis on young male podcast listeners — and spreading misinformation.”
On the other hand, Trump and Harris are both making media choices that would have raised eyebrows a few years ago. And a few years before that, these outlets may not have even existed.
To be sure, politicians have always sought to capitalize on changing media trends. This sometimes requires balancing the desire to uphold the dignity of the office with the need for attention and the desire to come across as a regular person. Eventually, the pols always go where they can get the most attention — think of Richard Nixon saying “Sock it to me” on “Laugh-In” — and today’s media fragmentation, coupled with emerging technology, has led many Americans to YouTube and podcasts.
Although “60 Minutes” can still draw close to 10 million viewers, few TV shows come close to those numbers these days. What is more, appearing on a show like “Call Her Daddy” doesn’t just allow Harris to reach millions of listeners, it also allows her to communicate with a targeted demographic that is predisposed to her message — young women likely receptive to her position on abortion.
This has been a long time coming. I was among the early conservative bloggers who experienced the charm offensive put forth by politicians such as Sen. John McCain. As part of the effort to win the 2008 GOP primary, bloggers (who could never have made it past the mainstream media gatekeepers) were granted all sorts of access and attention — most of which we probably didn’t deserve.
As alternative media matured and professionalized, President Barack Obama upped the ante. He appeared with a YouTube star who drinks cereal out of bathtubs, went on the “WTF with Marc Maron” podcast, filled out NCAA brackets on ESPN and appeared on “Between Two Ferns with Zach Galifianakis,” just to name a few highlights (or lowlights).
But this year feels like a tipping point. Rather than dabbling in podcasts and YouTube to create a cool image for broadcast TV, these alternative outlets are now the destination.
Yes, some politicians will embrace this brave new world to avoid accountability and ensure softball interviews. At the same time, so-called friendly interviews can sometimes be insightful. Trump, specifically, seems much more likely to say interesting things when he doesn’t feel like he is facing a hostile interrogator.
What’s more, so-called “friendly” settings can also inadvertently set traps. When it comes to committing gaffes, softball interviews are often more perilous than interviews perceived as hostile.
The bigger danger is that voters self-segregate — that conservatives and progressives cloister into their own echo chambers, listening to their own favorite podcast hosts interview their favorite candidates, and rarely, if ever, being challenged.
This, of course, is already happening. In some cases, politicians have eliminated the middleman by launching their own podcasts — see Ted Cruz.
The question is whether enough of us will demand that presidential candidates subject themselves to a handful of mainstream vetting interviews as a rite of passage.
It now seems likely that Harris and Trump will debate each other only once (Trump continues to refuse to debate again). President Joe Biden skipped the traditional Super Bowl interview in February. Harris hasn’t held a press conference since August. And Trump just bucked the “60 Minutes” interview tradition.
I am a YouTuber and podcaster myself. I consume hours of podcast content each day. There are plenty of serious professionals and journalists in this medium. In many ways, technology and alternate media have enriched our lives and provided us with more quality and diversity of information.
The transition toward YouTube and podcasts doesn’t have to look like “Idiocracy.” The question is what we the people are willing to accept from our leaders.
Matt K. Lewis is a columnist, podcaster and author of the books “Too Dumb to Fail” and “Filthy Rich Politicians.”
Date: |
-
Politics - NBC News
Harris' political operation crosses $1 billion raised for the 2024 election
Vice President Kamala Harris' presidential campaign operation crossed the $1 billion fundraising threshold in September.2 days ago -
Politics - The Hill
Kari Lake dodges question over whether she’d certify 2024 election
Arizona Senate GOP candidate Kari Lake dodged a question on whether she would vote to certify the 2024 election results regardless of the outcome during an interview aired Wednesday. NBC News ...Yesterday -
Politics - The Hill
Speaker Johnson's 2020 election challenge raises questions for 2024
What will Speaker Mike Johnson (R-La.) do? That’s the quiet question bouncing around Washington this month as the parties race furiously toward Election Day — when both the House and White House ...Yesterday -
World - The Guardian
Hurricane Milton: providing conspiracy theorists with loads of made up material since 2024 | First Dog on the Moon
It would be entertaining if civilisation wasn’t ending. Sign up here to get an email whenever First Dog cartoons are published Get all your needs met at the First Dog shop if what you need is ...11 hours ago -
Business - Inc.
Put First Things First
How to leverage the Eisenhower Matrix personally and professionally23 hours ago -
Lifestyle - The New York Times
She’s Only Playing a Therapist, but the Revelations Are Real
The designer Bella Freud — a great-granddaughter of Sigmund Freud — is using her podcast to “learn vicariously all the things I’ve secretly wanted to know” about celebrities.Yesterday
More from The Hill
-
Politics - The Hill
Mika Brzezinski knocks 'aging bulls--- artist' Trump over Detroit speech
MSNBC host Mika Brzezinski railed against former President Trump following his speech at the Detroit Economic Club this week. "I mean that’s like an epic weave that he talks about, but his weaves ...3 hours ago - Donald Trump -
Politics - The Hill
Democracy and reality are on the ballot
Trump’s hallucinatory vision of an economically ruined America besieged by rampaging criminals and pet-eating immigrants seems to grow more hysterical with every campaign rally.3 hours ago -
Politics - The Hill
Watch live: Walz campaigns in 'blue wall' battleground Michigan
Democratic vice presidential hopeful Minnesota Gov. Tim Walz is holding a campaign event Friday in Michigan, with just 25 days left until the election. Walz's latest visit to the state comes as ...3 hours ago -
Politics - The Hill
Walz blasts Trump for Detroit criticism: All these guys know is ‘how to manufacture bulls‑‑‑’
Minnesota Gov. Tim Walz (D) is poised to hammer former President Trump in Michigan Friday over remarks he made a day earlier bashing Detroit while in the Motor City. Walz, the Democratic nominee ...3 hours ago - Donald Trump -
Politics - The Hill
Harris lands on cover of Vogue
Vice President Harris appeared on the cover of Vogue Magazine's last edition ahead of Election Day, now less than a month away. The photo, shot by photographer Annie Leibovitz, appears next to the ...3 hours ago - Kamala Harris