2 Trump nominees raise red flags for GOP
Republican senators are warning that two of President Trump's nominees for national security positions who have championed radical views will face tough scrutiny.
Elbridge Colby, Trump’s pick to serve as Defense undersecretary for policy, and Darren Beattie, his choice to serve as undersecretary of State for public diplomacy, in particular have raised eyebrows for statements or policy views at odds with those of many GOP senators.
Even though other controversial nominees, most recently Director of National Intelligence Tulsi Gabbard, have won confirmation with near GOP unity, Republicans say Colby and Beattie could face some challenges.
And they say the fact that Colby and Beattie are lesser-known names who would be placed in under-the-Cabinet roles means they could come under more, not less scrutiny.
“I think Tulsi Gabbard is flawed but [is] she going to be harmful? No, because I think that there are going to [be] enough strong intelligence people around her. I feel the same way about RFK Jr.,” said a Republican senator, referring to Trump's nominee for Health and Human Services secretary, Robert F. Kennedy Jr.
“When it comes to those nominees below the Cabinet who may be less on people’s radar, who will be able to facilitate things, that’s where I think it can be dangerous. I’m going to be looking at them more critically,” said the senator, who requested anonymity to discuss the skepticism facing Trump’s next batch of nominees.
Colby is coming under criticism for advocating that the United States cut back its military posture in Europe and the Middle East to focus on the growing threat posed by China in the Indo-Pacific.
Senate Armed Services Committee Chair Roger Wicker (R-Miss.) told Congressional Quarterly that some of Colby’s views are “a concern to a number of senators.”
The Conference of Presidents of Major American Jewish Organizations wrote a letter to Wicker and Sen. Jack Reed (R.I.), the top Democrat on the Armed Services panel, voicing the concerns of their member organizations about Colby’s view of the role of the American military in the Middle East and U.S. policy toward Iran.
The group urged senators to press Colby about his views on a range of topics, including his previous support for drawing down U.S. military forces in the Middle East.
Reed told The Hill that several of his Republican colleagues have “serious questions” about Colby.
“I had a chance to speak with him, and he has made it very clear in the last few years in writing that he feels there should be a dramatic shift to Asia and minimal involvement elsewhere, and that raises a lot of strategic questions,” he said. “I heard there are colleagues on the other side that have serious questions.”
Several Republicans on the Armed Services Committee have already met with Colby, including Sens. Joni Ernst (R-Iowa) and Mike Rounds (R-S.D.), but are withholding judgment until his confirmation hearing, which has yet to be scheduled.
“I have sat down with him. We had a really great discussion. I’ve worked with him on projects in the past. I hope he does well before our committee,” Ernst told The Hill.
Rounds said he, too, “had a very good discussion” with Colby but said he would “wait and see” on how to vote on his nomination.
A key figure in the debate over Colby and other sub-Cabinet level nominees will be Sen. Mitch McConnell (R-Ky.), the chair of the powerful Appropriations subcommittee for Defense.
McConnell has kept his cards close to the vest but opposed both Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth and Gabbard on their final confirmation votes.
He asserted that Hegseth “failed” to show he could manage 3 million military and civilian personnel and an annual Defense budget of nearly $1 trillion.
And he voted against Gabbard on Wednesday, citing her refusal to call former government contractor Edward Snowden a traitor despite his theft of 1.5 million classified records, which McConnell said “endangered sources, methods and lives.”
McConnell has repeatedly argued that the United States should build up its defense capability to deter threats posed by Russia, Iran and China simultaneously, and he would oppose cutting back the U.S. military posture in Europe and the Middle East.
Sen. Dan Sullivan (R-Alaska), another member of the Armed Services Committee, said he knows Colby “pretty well” and plans to meet with him soon.
Sullivan has already raised concerns over some Pentagon moves, specifically those by deputy assistant secretaries (DAS).
“You had a DAS — maybe they don’t have these views now — but a DAS who had a plan a couple years ago to cut 12 brigade combat teams from the Army,” he told The Hill. “That’s like [former President] Obama.”
“There’s concern about who’s in the policy shop there. There are some concerns, not just me,” he added.
Sullivan said he also had questions about Michael DiMino, Trump’s nominee to serve as secretary of Defense for the Middle East, who was sworn into the administration last month.
DiMino said in a webinar a year ago that the Middle East does “not really” matter to U.S. national security interests and that the existential threats in the Middle East are “best characterized as minimal to nonexistent.”
“I’ve seen statements by him that are total, unequivocal head-scratchers,” Sullivan said of DiMino.
Beattie, who serves as the State Department’s acting undersecretary for public diplomacy and public affairs, is starting to come under criticism for past controversial statements and social media posts attacking Republican senators.
The former Trump speechwriter has voiced support for sterilization and suggested paying smart people to have more kids, according to NOTUS.
Beattie’s social media posts have been criticized by the Anti-Defamation League (ADL), a group dedicated to fighting antisemitism, which said he “has no place in a role representing American values abroad.”
The ADL said that Beattie throughout the years “has participated in several conversations and events organized by notorious racists, antisemites and white supremacists and has continuously promoted an array of conspiracy theories.”
Beattie has also taken shots at Graham and Sens. Tom Cotton (R-Ark.) and Tim Scott (R-S.C.) on social media.
“Where do they get some of these guys?” asked one Republican senator, who requested anonymity to voice frustration with some of Trump’s personnel choices. “If you really want to do something publicly, put your phone down.”
Sen. Steve Daines (R-Mont.), a member of the Senate Foreign Relations Committee, said he was not familiar with Beattie.
Topics
-
Trump's labor nominee once worked at Planned Parenthood, risking further GOP ire
Labor secretary nominee former Rep. Lori Chavez-DeRemer listed on her questionnaire for a Senate committee that she worked at a Planned Parenthood clinic when she was in her early 20s.NBC News - 16h -
Schumer warns GOP against a 'Trump shutdown'
Politico - 2d -
Trump unveils nominees for CFPB director, comptroller of the currency
President Trump sent a new list of nominations to the Senate on Tuesday, unveiling his picks to lead several key financial regulatory agencies in his second administration. Jonathan McKernan was ...The Hill - 17h -
GOP lawmaker proposes renaming Greenland 'Red, White, and Blueland’
Rep. Buddy Carter (R-Ga.) introduced a new bill this week aiming to rename Greenland to "Red, White, and Blueland," as President Trump seeks to acquire the island territory. The legislation, called ...The Hill - 1d -
Super Bowl halftime performer who raised Sudanese-Palestinian flag will not face charges
A member of Kendrick Lamar's halftime show went off-script, holding up a flag representing Palestine and Sudan during Sunday's performance.Yahoo Sports - 2d -
Can Trump bring unions into the GOP fold? His labor nominee presents a major test
President Donald Trump has repeatedly challenged Senate Republicans with his Cabinet picksABC News - 3d -
Trump’s FBI nominee Kash Patel under fire over Shein stake
Controversial official discloses stock in owner of Chinese fast-fashion retailer that has been accused of forced labourFinancial Times - 4d -
GOP gains in voter registration raise red flags for Democrats
Republican gains in voter registration are raising red flags for Democrats in key states, underscoring the inroads the GOP made across the country in 2024. Active registered Republicans now ...The Hill - 4d -
Trump Trade Nominee Defends Plan to Reorder International Trade
Jamieson Greer advocated restructuring the international trading system and defended the president’s aggressive actions against Canada and Mexico as he testified before the Senate.The New York Times - 6d
More from The Hill
-
Trump really can achieve lasting peace between Russia and Ukraine — here’s how
President Trump has stated that he has begun to work with Russian President Vladimir Putin to put an end the war between Ukraine and Russia “immediately.”The Hill - 36m -
Live updates: Kennedy faces final Senate vote; Trump to meet Indian prime minister
Embattled nominee Robert F. Kennedy Jr. faces a final vote of the full Senate on Thursday, capping a twisting journey to become the nation's next Health and Human Services secretary. Kennedy's ...The Hill - 41m -
Pilot killed in collision involving Mötley Crüe singer's plane identified as Marine Corps veteran
Joie Vitosky, 78, was certified as a flight engineer since 1978 and a pilot since 2019, according to FAA records.The Hill - 59m -
Fetterman urges Trump to rescind ban on transgender troops
Sen. John Fetterman (Pa.), the maverick Democrat who has praised President Trump at times, on Thursday condemned the Trump administration’s decision to bar transgender individuals from serving in ...The Hill - 1h -
Trump must treat China, Iran, Russia and North Korea as a package deal
American foreign policy choices have repercussions elsewhere on the world stage.The Hill - 1h
More in Politics
-
Trump really can achieve lasting peace between Russia and Ukraine — here’s how
President Trump has stated that he has begun to work with Russian President Vladimir Putin to put an end the war between Ukraine and Russia “immediately.”The Hill - 36m -
Live updates: Kennedy faces final Senate vote; Trump to meet Indian prime minister
Embattled nominee Robert F. Kennedy Jr. faces a final vote of the full Senate on Thursday, capping a twisting journey to become the nation's next Health and Human Services secretary. Kennedy's ...The Hill - 41m -
Pilot killed in collision involving Mötley Crüe singer's plane identified as Marine Corps veteran
Joie Vitosky, 78, was certified as a flight engineer since 1978 and a pilot since 2019, according to FAA records.The Hill - 59m -
Fetterman urges Trump to rescind ban on transgender troops
Sen. John Fetterman (Pa.), the maverick Democrat who has praised President Trump at times, on Thursday condemned the Trump administration’s decision to bar transgender individuals from serving in ...The Hill - 1h -
Trump must treat China, Iran, Russia and North Korea as a package deal
American foreign policy choices have repercussions elsewhere on the world stage.The Hill - 1h