18 senators push to fund immigration court children's docket
U.S. immigration courts are moving toward more child-appropriate procedures, but funding could determine whether those procedures will effectively protect minors in immigration proceedings.
A group of 18 senators led by Sens. Michael Bennet (D-Colo.) and Catherine Cortez Masto (D-Nev.) are calling on the upper chamber’s appropriators to dive into the weeds on Executive Office for Immigration Review (EOIR) procedures as they craft the fiscal 2025 budget.
In a letter to Sens. Patty Murray (D-Wash), Susan Collins (R-Maine), Jeanne Shaheen (D-N.H.) and Jerry Moran (R-Kan.), the 18 senators highlighted a December memorandum issued by EOIR Director David Neal with guidelines on treatment of cases involving minors.
“Properly implemented, the Director’s Memorandum could help children understand and participate in their court proceedings by creating accommodations that complement a child’s developmental level,” they wrote.
“It could also relieve strain on the immigration courts by aggregating these similar cases and streamlining the handling of pending cases of children who have claims awaiting adjudication by U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS), thereby avoiding duplication of efforts by multiple government agencies.”
EOIR, the immigration court system, is part of the Department of Justice, an administrative court rather than part of the judiciary.
Its funding is under the jurisdiction of the Commerce, Judiciary and Science (CJS) Appropriations Subcommittee, led by Shaheen and Moran. Murray and Collins lead the Senate Appropriations Committee.
In their letter, the senators led by Bennet and Cortez Masto ask the appropriators to include specific language in the fiscal 2025 Committee report, commending EOIR for Neal’s memorandum, and directing the Department of Justice to submit a report detailing its implementation.
“This report shall address at a minimum: the name and number of immigration courts implementing juvenile dockets; training that has been provided to juvenile docket judges; protocols for assessing individual court compliance with the memorandum as well as corrective actions taken in the event of noncompliance; methods that courts are using to facilitate legal representation for children; and any immigration court resources conserved by utilization of juvenile dockets,” reads the proposed language.
Because EOIR is not part of the judiciary, standard constitutional protections afforded to criminal defendants are not mandatory in immigration cases.
That means, for instance, that people in immigration proceedings don’t have the right to an attorney, even if they are unable to understand the allegations against them, or the consequences of their actions in court.
Neal’s memo directs immigration judges to take certain measures to protect children in proceedings, including elemental issues like understanding an oath and sworn testimony.
“The immigration judge should take care to explain the oath to the child at a level appropriate to the age of the child. For example, a child may be told they should promise to ‘tell the truth’ or to ‘tell what really happened.’ A child should also be reassured that they may say 'I don’t know' if they are unsure how to answer a question and that they may request a question be asked a different way if they do not understand it. A child should be told they should not feel at fault if an attorney raises an objection to a question,” reads part of Neal’s memo.
Yet even with those administrative safeguards, EOIR faces challenges in providing safe and fair environments for children who are essentially under trial.
According to the Transactional Records Access Clearinghouse, a government data tracker housed at Syracuse University, 31 percent of all foreign nationals issued a notice to appear in 2022 were 17 or younger, and 16 percent were 18 to 24 years old.
Neal’s memorandum says immigration courts should have a separate docket for respondents under 21.
“The Memorandum also outlines certain procedures and practices that immigration judges should follow in order to create an environment where children can better comprehend and participate in their proceedings and where judges can better administer justice. Ideally, the immigration courts will seek to engage legal service organizations that represent unaccompanied children in the juvenile dockets with the goal of maximizing legal representation,” reads the letter led by Bennet and Cortez Masto.
In November, Bennet introduced a bipartisan bill that would establish a separate children’s court within EOIR, with judges and court officials specialized in processing children.
Date: |
Filter
-
SF supervisors push back on funding for pandas at zoo
Yahoo News - World -
Supreme Court upholds funding structure for CFPB
The Supreme Court said in a 7-2 decision that the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau's funding structure complies with the Constitution's Appropriations Clause.CBS News - Top stories -
Supreme Court Rejects Challenge to CFPB Funding
A decision against the agency, the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, could have cast doubt on all of its regulations and enforcement actions.The New York Times - Top stories -
Supreme Court: Consumer Financial Protection Bureau funding doesn't violate Constitution
The Supreme Court has ruled the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau's funding practices do not violate the Constitution. CBS News legal contributor Jessica Levinson breaks down the ruling.CBS News - Top stories -
Supreme Court rules Consumer Financial Protection Bureau funding structure is legal
The Supreme Court decision protects the CFPB from the potentially crippling risk that Republicans in Congress will block annual funding for the agency.CNBC - Business -
Supreme Court Upholds Consumer Finance Protection Bureau Funding Method
The way the agency--a target of a conservative attacks--gets money from the federal government does not violate the Constitution, the court rules in a 7-2 vote.Inc. - Business -
Biden administration looks to speed review of asylum cases with new dedicated docket
The Biden administration is taking aim at the backlog of asylum cases from those who have recently arrived at the border, creating a dedicated docket in the hopes of more swiftly adjudicating the claims. Although largely a matter of managing the ...The Hill - Politics - Joe Biden -
5/18: Saturday Morning
Trucks carrying desperately needed aid are rolling across a newly U.S. built pier into Gaza; Chef Salil Mehta introduces diners to Malaysian food after eatery earns Michelin starCBS News - Top stories -
News Quiz for May 18, 2024
Test your knowledge of the week’s events as reported in The Wall Street Journal.The Wall Street Journal - World -
5/18: CBS Weekend News
Biden travels to Georgia ahead of Morehouse commencement address; Anchovies behind surge of sea lions in San FranciscoCBS News - Top stories
More from The Hill
-
Biden's proposed tax hike would crush workers and the economy
Biden is eager for more hard-earned money from U.S. taxpayers, and he is willing to drive businesses overseas again by raising corporate tax rates.The Hill - Politics - Joe Biden -
Morning Report — Vulnerable Senate Democrats break with Biden
Six months out from Election Day, some vulnerable Democrats are looking at President Biden’s poll numbers with concern. Some Senate Democrats are distancing themselves from Biden’s ailing brand after polls show him trailing former President Trump ...The Hill - Politics - Joe Biden -
Schumer tees up round two for bipartisan border bill
Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer (D-N.Y.) is tee-ing up a second attempt at passing the bipartisan border bill — after Republicans blocked it earlier this year — a move that comes as the situation at the southern border remains top of mind for ...The Hill - Politics -
Democratic group targets Republicans over IVF in Arizona
A Democratic super PAC is targeting Republicans over the issue of in vitro fertilization (IVF) in the battleground state of Arizona as Democrats ramp up their attacks on reproductive access ahead of the 2024 election. Progress Action Fund, which ...The Hill - Politics - Republican Party -
Alarmed Democrats flee Biden’s ailing brand in battleground states
Vulnerable Senate Democrats are distancing themselves from President Biden’s ailing brand after polls show him trailing former President Trump in several battleground states. Democrats in tough races are breaking with Biden over border security, ...The Hill - Politics - Joe Biden