Voters want to tax outrageous CEO pay. Are lawmakers listening?
For decades now, I’ve been conducting my own informal survey of American views about CEO pay.
Whenever family, friends, or random strangers ask about my job, I tell them it involves research on executive compensation. Last year, for example, I found that CEOs of America’s 100 largest low-wage employers made, on average, over 600 times what their median workers made — and often thousands of times more.
Invariably, people see red when I share these numbers. And they often have choice words about the unfairness of it all.
A new poll reinforces my informal findings: Americans across the political spectrum are fed up with overpaid CEOs — and want something done about it.
The Data for Progress survey asked likely voters about one possible congressional action: a tax hike on corporations that pay their CEO at least 50 times more than they pay their median employee.
This policy would give companies with huge internal disparities two choices: narrow their pay gaps or face a bigger IRS bill. A company where half of employees earn less than $60,000, for instance, would have to limit CEO compensation to no more than $3 million or raise worker pay to avoid higher taxes. In 2022, the average S&P 500 CEO pay hit $16.7 million.
The survey results? Overall, 80 percent of participants support the idea, including large majorities in every political group (89 percent of Democrats, 77 percent of independents and 71 percent of Republicans). In swing states, 83 percent of likely voters gave it a thumbs up.
The Data for Progress results are consistent with two previous surveys on a much tougher policy approach: an outright cap on executive pay relative to worker pay. Those polls — one by Just Capital and another by the Stanford Business School — found broad public enthusiasm for such caps, including among a majority of Republicans.
Using tax policy to narrow corporate pay gaps has been gaining momentum for nearly a decade. Two U.S. cities — San Francisco and Portland — adopted such taxes years ago. At the federal level, the 100-member Congressional Progressive Caucus recently endorsed the proposal and three Senate committee chairs have expressed support as well.
With such broad popularity, penalties for huge CEO-worker pay gaps should be squarely in the mix in the big tax fight of 2025, when several provisions in the 2017 Trump-GOP tax cuts for corporations and the rich are set to expire. This will be a key opportunity to push bold tax code changes that advance an equitable and sustainable economy and reject the disastrous “trickle-down” paradigm.
Back in 2017, advocates of the Republican tax law promised that a central pillar of that plan — slashing the corporate tax rate from 35 percent to 21 percent — would lead to more and better jobs for ordinary workers. Instead, almost all benefits of this rate cut, a group of academic and government analysts recently found, have flowed to wealthy shareholders and executives. Employees who fall below their company’s top 10 percent tier have seen no trickle-down wage boosts whatsoever.
Reversing this failed policy should be part of any deal coming out of the 2025 tax negotiations. And the chances of that happening — especially if Congress remains narrowly divided — would arguably be higher if a corporate tax rate hike were combined with the broadly popular idea of taxing big CEO-worker pay gaps.
CEO-worker pay gap taxes might even win over some pro-business reformers. Extensive academic research has shown that extreme wage disparities are bad for business because they undermine employee morale and productivity.
The problem of overpaid CEOs and underpaid workers is not going to go away on its own — and is likely to get worse. Equilar analysis of preliminary data for 2023 finds that big company CEO pay rose 11.3 percent last year, while median worker pay at these firms dropped by 9.3 percent.
It’s time for responsible government action on a problem that’s had Americans’ blood boiling for far too long.
Sarah Anderson directs the Global Economy Project and co-edits Inequality.org at the Institute for Policy Studies. She’s the author of the IPS Executive Excess report series on CEO pay.
Date: |
Filter
-
Trump's conviction draws reactions from lawmakers, voters
Reaction is pouring in from politicians and voters on both sides of the aisle after former President Donald Trump was convicted Thursday on all 34 counts of falsifying business records. CBS News congressional correspondent Nikole Killion spoke ...CBS News - Top stories - Donald Trump -
UK voters resigned to tax rises despite Tory and Labour assurances
Financial Times/Ipsos poll shows scepticism over both main parties’ promises on dealing with stretched state financesFinancial Times - Business - United Kingdom -
Foot Locker's turnaround is showing signs of life, CEO sees consumers willing to pay full price
Foot Locker is making gains under CEO Mary Dillon, who has been working to win back brands and Wall Street's confidence with an ambitious turnaround plan.CNBC - Business -
Tesla investors advised to vote against Elon Musk’s ‘excessive’ $56bn CEO pay
ISS is the second proxy advisory firm to recommend that shareholders vote against Musk’s high salary in recent weeks. ISS, a top proxy advisory firm, recommended Tesla shareholders vote against ratifying CEO Elon Musk’s $56bn pay package, calling ...The Guardian - World - Tesla -
In South Africa, first-time voters want their choice to count and keep their dreams alive
Yahoo News - World -
Starmer has given in to the Labour left over Diane Abbott, says Sunak – UK politics live
The prime minister said if Starmer was elected then he would also pander to the left in power. SNP leader John Swinney has urged people to take part in a “Scottish national service” by using the general election to vote Tory MPs out of office, PA ...The Guardian - World - United Kingdom -
Tesla issued a scathing rebuttal to Glass Lewis after the proxy advisers counseled shareholders to vote against CEO Musk's pay package.
Tesla issued a scathing rebuttal to Glass Lewis after the proxy advisers counseled shareholders to vote against CEO Musk’s pay package.The Wall Street Journal - World -
9 Best Earplugs (2024): For Concerts, Sleep, and Listening
Whether you want to sleep through the party or rock out (safely) to your favorite band, these will help block out the noise.Wired - Tech -
Algeria’s Cease-Fire Proposal Circulates at U.N. Amid Outrage Over Rafah
Algeria, the only Arab representative in the current makeup of the Security Council, drafted the resolution.The New York Times - World -
'Outrageous!' 'Tears of Joy.' Hollywood reacts to Trump's guilty verdict with rage, rapture
Thursday afternoon's guilty verdict for Trump rippled throughout Hollywood with reactions spanning the political spectrum.Los Angeles Times - Entertainment
More from The Hill
-
North America at a crossroads as Mexico kicks off trio of major elections
Looming elections across North America could upend a decades-long integration process as the continent’s three major nations face sharp choices between populism and traditional liberalism. The interactions among Mexican, U.S. and Canadian leaders ...The Hill - Politics -
In defending Trump, the GOP attacks the justice system
Republican allies of former President Trump are taking to the airwaves to boost his attacks on the justice system and condemn those who say people should respect the justice system that delivered his guilty verdict in the New York hush money ...The Hill - Politics - Donald Trump -
Trump’s hush money conviction: What happens next
NEW YORK — Former President Trump’s hush money trial ended in a sweeping conviction, but his historic case is far from over. As Trump vows to appeal, the proceedings will meanwhile move ahead toward sentencing on July 11 — just days before Trump ...The Hill - Politics - Donald Trump -
Women in Congress spotlight challenge of legislating as a new mother
A bipartisan effort to let new mothers vote by proxy after giving birth is putting a spotlight on the unique challenges congresswomen face as they weigh motherhood against the archaic rules of the House chamber. After suffering significant ...The Hill - Politics -
Stormy Daniels' lawyer says Trump's conviction in hush money case 'hit her hard'
A lawyer for Stormy Daniels, the adult film star central to former President Trump’s hush money trial, said Friday that Trump's recent conviction "hit her hard." “I got a pretty instant report from the courthouse,” Attorney Clark Brewster said in ...The Hill - Politics - Donald Trump