In the fog of forever war, the US no longer recognizes alternatives
The fog of war makes it difficult for most people to think beyond the here and now. In the wake of the chaotic U.S. exit from Afghanistan in August 2021, policymakers, the military and others focused on the bungling of the singular operation — the withdrawal — and not the overall feasibility or desirability of U.S. foreign policy.
Any window for broader introspection closed with the Russian government’s invasion of Ukraine in February 2022, which led to renewed calls for American involvement abroad. The following year, in October 2023, Hamas attacked Israel. Most recently, the governments of Israel and Iran have engaged in tit-for-tat military strikes.
These conflicts have spawned constant arguments about aid and other involvement. Concerns over China, North Korea and other unfriendly regimes generate further debate about how U.S. policymakers should respond to specific scenarios.
Although these conversations are relevant, they highlight an important blind spot in foreign policy. It is exceptionally difficult for many to rise above the fog of war and look at the big picture. But they must do so, or else we will remain mired in a myopic and continuous cycle of war-making, moving from one crisis to the next.
Our never-ending proactive foreign policy has normalized war-making, with its significant costs and brutal realities. When war and foreign intervention are treated as immutable facts of life, our focus shifts from understanding their realities and causes to their violent execution. We treat the symptom while ignoring the disease that caused it.
Writing in the late 19th century, Argentine political theorist John Baptist Alberdi noted that war legitimizes crimes such as robbery, murder, arson and destruction on a massive scale. These activities, outlawed and viewed as wrong throughout the world, become business as usual.
“War sanctions [these crimes],” he wrote, “and converts them into just and lawful acts...a horrible and sacrilegious perversion of sense, which is a sarcasm on civilization.”
What Alberdi asked us to realize is that our myopic focus on today's conflict requires us to think in simple dichotomies — “good” and “bad,” or “us” versus “them” — while neglecting the true horrors of the enterprise of war itself. The treatment of war as something unavoidable presumes from the start that the atrocities of war cannot be avoided.
When faced with the brutal actions of others, proponents of war say, “What are we to do other than use force in response to force?” One simple but neglected answer is to not respond with violence, precisely because we recognize the inherent savagery of the war-making enterprise.
The typical reaction to this answer is that it is naive. But that reaction is itself naive. How confident can we be that, in all cases of war-making, all other feasible, nonviolent means of navigating conflicts have been exhausted, leaving war as the only remaining option? Are we confident that there are clear and attainable objectives with a high likelihood of success; that the wide range of unintended consequences have been fully considered?
Beyond these issues, the normalization of war-making neglects other significant consequences. These include fiscal and imperial overreach, expansions in the scale and scope of government power at home and the concomitant erosion of constitutional constraints.
It also neglects the natural result of continuous interventions in complex systems — the emergence of a network of intricate tripwires, or hidden triggers, that ignite conflict and violence. These tripwires are easily set off, pulling the U.S. and hence the U.S. citizens it represents into a perpetual war for perpetual peace.
Because of the presidential election later this year, many foreign policy discussions are framed as a contrast between the two nominees, Joe Biden and Donald Trump. But perhaps the bigger issue is that the decades-long U.S. role as the world’s policeman has significantly stressed the nation's economic and political institutions while normalizing war-making and the crimes inherent to war.
Only by rising above the fog of war can we hope to appreciate these nuances and think about alternative paths to peace that avoid the brutalities of armed conflict.
Christopher J. Coyne is a professor of economics at George Mason University. Abigail R. Hall is an associate professor in economics at the University of Tampa. Both are senior fellows at the Independent Institute and coauthors of the upcoming satirical book, "How to Run Wars: A Confidential Playbook for the National Security Elite."
Date: |
Filter
-
Discovering ‘This Was a Forever Romance’
Once Timothy Murray landed a date with Michael Bullard, the two were inseparable — except when they were separated by their work as actors.The New York Times - Lifestyle -
To win the messaging wars, restore the US Information Agency
We’ve lost foreign publics formerly disposed to giving us a sympathetic hearing because they experienced positive interactions with American outreach programs.The Hill - Politics -
US seeks to choke off supplies via China for Russia’s war machine
Ukraine’s allies and western businesses will be told to stop flow of critical componentsFinancial Times - World - China -
Will using Western weapons on Russia help Ukraine change the war?
The latest Russian advance in the Kharkiv region has convinced Kyiv’s allies to change their policy.BBC News - Top stories - Ukraine -
Israel-Gaza war live: Israel’s opposition leader urges Netanyahu to accept ceasefire proposal
It comes after Israeli PM’s comments appeared to contradict a ceasefire plan Joe Biden presented as Israeli-endorsed. See all our Israel-Gaza war coverage hereAt least 36,379 Palestinian people have been killed and 82,407 injured in Israeli ...The Guardian - World - Israel -
Women on Mediterranean diet live significantly longer: Study
Women who are on a Mediterranean diet live significantly longer, according to a new study. The Mediterranean diet often consists of higher consumption of food and ingredients like olive oil, fruits, fish, nuts and vegetables and lower consumption ...The Hill - Politics -
Slovenia's government endorses a motion to recognize a Palestinian state, sends it to parliament for approval
Slovenia's government endorses a motion to recognize a Palestinian state, sends it to parliament for approvalABC News - World -
Post uses photo from Ethiopia’s Tigray war to claim rebels recently surrendered in Amhara
Yahoo News - World -
Israel-Gaza war live: IDF says its troops have ended operations in eastern Jabaliya
IDF said it destroyed 10 kilometres of tunnels and several weapons production sites in days of fighting that included more than 200 airstrikes. Here is an extract from a piece about a small group of Israelis stopping settlers obstructing aid ...The Guardian - World - Israel -
Ukraine war briefing: Poland, allies scramble jets as Russia targets Ukrainian regions
Volodymyr Zelenskiy tells Guardian that permission needs to go further; Putin labels as ‘foreign agents’ wives who want their husbands back. What we know on day 829. Russian missile and drone attacks on Saturday morning damaged energy facilities ...The Guardian - World - Ukraine
More from The Hill
-
North America at a crossroads as Mexico kicks off trio of major elections
Looming elections across North America could upend a decades-long integration process as the continent’s three major nations face sharp choices between populism and traditional liberalism. The interactions among Mexican, U.S. and Canadian leaders ...The Hill - Politics -
In defending Trump, the GOP attacks the justice system
Republican allies of former President Trump are taking to the airwaves to boost his attacks on the justice system and condemn those who say people should respect the justice system that delivered his guilty verdict in the New York hush money ...The Hill - Politics - Donald Trump -
Trump’s hush money conviction: What happens next
NEW YORK — Former President Trump’s hush money trial ended in a sweeping conviction, but his historic case is far from over. As Trump vows to appeal, the proceedings will meanwhile move ahead toward sentencing on July 11 — just days before Trump ...The Hill - Politics - Donald Trump -
Women in Congress spotlight challenge of legislating as a new mother
A bipartisan effort to let new mothers vote by proxy after giving birth is putting a spotlight on the unique challenges congresswomen face as they weigh motherhood against the archaic rules of the House chamber. After suffering significant ...The Hill - Politics -
Stormy Daniels' lawyer says Trump's conviction in hush money case 'hit her hard'
A lawyer for Stormy Daniels, the adult film star central to former President Trump’s hush money trial, said Friday that Trump's recent conviction "hit her hard." “I got a pretty instant report from the courthouse,” Attorney Clark Brewster said in ...The Hill - Politics - Donald Trump